to top 10 table

Best Ice Makers Reviewed & Rated for Quality

last updated Mar 18, 2019

One of those things that always ends up being an annoyance in the home is the amount of ice that you have. Not every fridge comes with an ice machine, which means that you have to go and find one for yourself. Ice trays work, but they are often very limited in their use. They are hard to use, and it always turns out that you will run out of ice at the most inconvenient time. Enter the ice maker. This nifty device will have you rich with ice cubes in no time. Now you can always have ice on hand when guests come over, and just for when you might need it. They are very easy to use, and makes lots of ice so that you won't run out. This list has ten of the very best ones that you can find.

In a Hurry? The test winner after 15 hrs of research

icon
NewAir
99/100 our score
Speed
99
Capacity
99
Effectiveness
99
Ease of Use
99
Protection
99
NewAir
Why is it better?

Makes ice quickly

Designed for transport

Makes a good deal in one go

Multiple settings for ice making

In a Hurry? Editors choice:
NewAir
Test Winner: NewAir
Amazon Link
Researched Sources
12
Researched Sources
Reviews Considered
3211
Reviews Considered
Hours Researching
15
Hours Researching
Products Evaluated
10
Products Evaluated
Sorting Options
Speed Capacity Effectiveness Ease of Use Protection By Default
Rank
PictureProduct
Name
Rating
Shops
#1
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
99
Speed
99 %
Capacity
99 %
Effectiveness
99 %
Ease of Use
99 %
Protection
99 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (21.09.19)
Amazon Link
$162.99
#2
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
97.6
Speed
98 %
Capacity
97 %
Effectiveness
98 %
Ease of Use
97 %
Protection
98 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (21.09.19)
Amazon Link
$138.99
#3
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
96.4
Speed
97 %
Capacity
96 %
Effectiveness
97 %
Ease of Use
96 %
Protection
96 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (21.09.19)
Amazon Link
$489.99
#4
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
95
Speed
95 %
Capacity
94 %
Effectiveness
96 %
Ease of Use
95 %
Protection
95 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (21.09.19)
Amazon Link
$119.99
#5
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
93.2
Speed
94 %
Capacity
94 %
Effectiveness
93 %
Ease of Use
93 %
Protection
92 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (21.09.19)
Amazon Link
$139.00
#6
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
90.8
Speed
90 %
Capacity
91 %
Effectiveness
91 %
Ease of Use
91 %
Protection
91 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (21.09.19)
Amazon Link
$119.99
#7
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
88.6
Speed
89 %
Capacity
88 %
Effectiveness
88 %
Ease of Use
88 %
Protection
90 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (21.09.19)
Amazon Link
$109.99
#8
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
87.6
Speed
87 %
Capacity
87 %
Effectiveness
88 %
Ease of Use
87 %
Protection
89 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (21.09.19)
Amazon Link
$174.70
#9
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
84.8
Speed
85 %
Capacity
86 %
Effectiveness
84 %
Ease of Use
85 %
Protection
84 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (21.09.19)
Amazon Link
$99.99
#10
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
82
Speed
82 %
Capacity
83 %
Effectiveness
82 %
Ease of Use
82 %
Protection
81 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (21.09.19)
Amazon Link

10 Best Ice Makers

1. NewAir

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
99
NewAir
Amazon Link
Speed
99
Capacity
99
Effectiveness
99
Ease of Use
99
Protection
99
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$162.99
Pros:

Makes ice quickly

Designed for transport

Makes a good deal in one go

Multiple settings for ice making

Cons:

Too large for some

The NewAir is great for anyone who wants to make sure that they are never worried about running out of ice.

Read more

Tons of Ice
This ice maker is great because it can make pounds and pounds of ice for you every single day. It is easy to fill up with water, and then it can make enough ice to last for anything that you might need it for. It also does all this very quickly, and can make you some ice within fifteen minutes of being turned on.

Other Features
There are a lot of other things to love about the NewAir. It is designed to be used on the road. It has a very convenient shape that makes it easy for you to be able to bring it along with you to anywhere that you need to go. It is designed for use in the home, but also in other places like on a boat or on an RV. It also comes with a few different settings that make it possible for you to choose the ice that you want.

Cost and Value
The NewAir doesn't cost as much as it could, either. It is a very good deal for anyone who considers the amount of money they can save on going to the store to buy ice. It also produces much more ice much more quickly than any ice trays that you might buy. The NewAir is the perfect choice for anyone who wants their ice cubes at the ready at any time.

2. Aicock

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
97.6
Aicock
Amazon Link
Speed
98
Capacity
97
Effectiveness
98
Ease of Use
97
Protection
98
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$138.99
Pros:

Makes smaller ice

Great insulation

Easy to leave alone

Very quick in making ice

Cons:

Very expensive

The Aicock does a great job of making sure that you are always rich in ice. It is easy to use and makes ice very quickly.

Read more

Efficient Ice Maker
This machine is capable of making around nine ice cubes per every 6 to 10 minutes. This quick speed means that it can make a whopping 26 pounds of ice in a 24 hour period, making this machine great for being able to very quickly make the ice that you need for your daily drinks.

Self-Cleaning
If you've ever owned an ice machine before, you know that they can grimy instead very quickly. A bonus of this machine is that it has a self-cleaning function. All you need to do is add some water and vinegar and choose the cleaning option on the machine and voila - pure ice every time.

Cost and Value
This product is more affordable that the NewAir option that took our first place. It's a smart looking device that will look great on your countertops and is very efficient at producing ice.

3. FirstBuild Opal Nugget

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
96.4
FirstBuild Opal Nugget
Amazon Link
Speed
97
Capacity
96
Effectiveness
97
Ease of Use
96
Protection
96
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$489.99
Pros:

Very portable design

Great looking ice

Can turn it on from anywhere

Large capacity tray

Cons:

Only one kind of ice

This ice maker creates that most treasured of ice, the opal. Opal ice is incredibly portable and will look great in just about any situation.

Read more

Opal Ice Maker
Opal ice is like a more good-looking version of the crushed ice feature on your fridge. It is perfect for any kind of drink that would benefit from a little design flourish. The FirstBuild is also great for how much of this ice that it can make at one time. The drawer will become completely full of the stuff within about an hour.

Other Features
The FirstBuild has some other clever design choices. It makes ice at a very rapid pace, and can make a pound of ice in an hour. It also comes with an app. The app means that you can make ice whenever you want. You don't have to go up to the ice maker to get this done, and can just press a few buttons on your app so that you have ice waiting for you when you are ready.

Cost and Value
This ice maker is great because it does a good job of making the most aesthetically pleasing ice that you could hope for. There's lots more to love, including the convenient app, and the very portable nature of this ice maker. It costs quite a bit, but not as much as the Della. This is a good choice for anyone who likes a big pitcher of Mojito once in a while.

4. Frigidaire

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
95
Frigidaire
Amazon Link
Speed
95
Capacity
94
Effectiveness
96
Ease of Use
95
Protection
95
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$119.99
Pros:

Great price

Makes ice quickly

Comes with a scoop

Easy to see how the ice is doing

Cons:

Ice freezes together in fridge due to wetness

The Frigidaire is great because it does a good job at making your ice in the quickest time possible. This one is great for those who like things on the fly.

Read more

Quick Ice Maker
One of the biggest things that people look for in an ice maker is the ability to make their ice quick. Running out of ice is no good at all. The Frigidaire promises to start clinking some ice down within six minutes. This means that you won't have to wait very long at all. It makes the classic nugget ice that you would expect to see out of a refrigerator.

Other Features
There are lots of other things to love about the Frigidaire. It is designed with your ease of use in mind. It comes with a viewing window on the top so that you can see what is going on inside of the ice machine. It is also great because it comes with a little ice scoop so that you have easy access to the ice as it falls down.

Cost and Value
This ice maker is great for another very important reason. It can be bought at a very reasonable price. This ice maker is designed for anyone who wants the quick and easy solution to their cold drink needs. The fast output and the easy access makes this a good choice for anyone who is too forgetful to make their ice on a schedule.

5. Avalon Bay

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
93.2
Avalon Bay
Amazon Link
Speed
94
Capacity
94
Effectiveness
93
Ease of Use
93
Protection
92
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$139.00
Pros:

Quickly makes ice

Easy to move around

Warning light for adding more water

Great for personal use

Cons:

Not much ice per cycle

The Avalon Bay ice maker is another choice if you want your ice to come out quickly. This is a good choice for anyone looking to fill up a drink or two.

Read more

Very Quick Ice Maker
The Avalon Bay is another ice maker that promises to give you your ice within six minutes. This makes this a good choice for anyone who just wants some ice for their own personal use. It will give you nine pieces of ice in six minutes, which is just enough to fill up a glass or two with just the right amount of ice.

Other Features
This ice maker is designed with your convenience in mind. It has lots of little features that make it easy for you to use. It has a convenient warning light that lets you kn ow when more ice is needed in the ice maker. This makes it possible to always be on top of the ice maker so that the stream of ice is constant. It can make around twenty-five pounds of ice in a day, as long as you stay on top of it, and that it made easier through the use of its digital display.

Cost and Value
The Avalon Bay is another good choice for anyone who wants to make sure that their ice cubes are coming at a rapid pace. This is a good ice maker for personal use. It doesn't make too many ice cubes per cycle, but it does it quickly enough that you don't have to worry too much about it. It also costs so little that just about anybody can buy it.

6. Vremi

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
90.8
Vremi
Amazon Link
Speed
90
Capacity
91
Effectiveness
91
Ease of Use
91
Protection
91
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$119.99
Pros:

Doesn't take up too much space

Automatic shutoff feature

Energy efficient

Very convenient use

Cons:

Can be hard to clean

The Vremi is perfect for anyone who wants their life to be as simple as possible. It is most akin to an ice maker that you would find in a fridge.

Read more

Convenient Ice Maker
This ice maker is great because you can use it just like a refrigerator ice maker. It is designed so that it will make ice automatically that you can just leave in the tray without needing to worry about if it will melt. It will keep your ice nice and cold, and it will only make ice until the bucket is full. Just leave it plugged in and refill it once in a while, and you'll be in the clear.

Other Features
The Vremi is great for many other reasons, too. This ice maker is a good choice for those who are worried about energy consumption too. Because it is designed to remain plugged in, the Vremi has taken steps to not add too much to your energy bill. The Vremi is also a very portable size, which makes it perfect for anyone's home.

Cost and Value
The Vremi is a good choice for anyone who misses the ice maker in the refrigerator, and want something as similar as possible. This thing is very easy to use, and will remain convenient for just about anybody. It also doesn't cost very much, either, which will make it a relief to just about anybody who wants it.

7. hOmelabs

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
88.6
hOmelabs
Amazon Link
Speed
89
Capacity
88
Effectiveness
88
Ease of Use
88
Protection
90
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$109.99
Pros:

Great price

Good size for a small kitchen

Removable basket

Comes with a scoop

Cons:

Basket doesn't stay cold in maker

The hOmelabs option is a good one because it does just about everything right. It is quick, quiet, and comes with a good deal of features.

Read more

Portable Ice Maker
This ice maker is a good choice because it does all the things that other ice makers can do, but with a very convenient shape and size. This ice maker is a little taller, rather than thicker, which makes it perfect for the countertop. It makes it very easy to leave this one out, without needing to move anything around in your kitchen.

Other Features
Another great thing about the hOmelabs ice maker is that it does a great job at making you ice in the most convenient way. It comes with a easy to remove basket that will let you move the ice to the freezer after you are done. It also comes with a scoop, so that you don't have to get your fingers cold when you are getting a cup of drink ready.

Cost and Value
The hOmelabs is a good choice for just about anybody. It is designed to be very easy to use, and it does everything else just as quick. It will only take a few minutes to get you enough ice for a drink. This ice maker is great for anyone who is low on space in their home. Even better, it comes at a very reasonable price, even when compared to the other cheaper ice makers.

8. Igloo

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
87.6
Igloo
Amazon Link
Speed
87
Capacity
87
Effectiveness
88
Ease of Use
87
Protection
89
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$174.70
Pros:

Choice of ice cube size

Great price

Automatically turns off when full

Lots of capacity for size of cooler

Cons:

Little too noisy

The Igloo is a good choice for anyone who wants to be able to choose the kind of ice that they get out of their ice maker.

Read more

Choose Your Size
This ice maker is special because it will let you choose the size of your ice. For some drinks and uses, larger ice cubes are better. It has the smaller ones that you would get from the other ice makers on this list, too. That is great for getting to choose the ice that you would like. Larger ice cubes are great for things like chilling a cooler, as well.

Other Features
The Igloo has some other great features too. It is designed to be very quick and easy to use. Just set the type of ice that you would like, fill up the reservoir in the back, and you should start getting ice within the next seven to ten minutes. It will also hold a great deal of ice for its size. The Igloo can comfortably hold two pounds of ice cubes before it will shut itself off.

Cost and Value
The Igloo is great because it gives you some choice in what you want from your ice cubes. The larger cubes are great for keeping their shape for longer, and the smaller ones will really cool down a drink. The Igloo is also wonderful for being able to store so much ice at a much smaller size. It also doesn't cost very much, which is a welcome thing to see.

9. Hamilton Beach

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
84.8
Hamilton Beach
Amazon Link
Speed
85
Capacity
86
Effectiveness
84
Ease of Use
85
Protection
84
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$99.99
Pros:

Great price

Lots of indicator lights

Quiet motor

Options for sizes

Cons:

No scoop

The Hamilton Beach is a useful and easy to operate ice maker that will do a good job of making sure that you never run out.

Read more

Easy to Understand
The Hamilton Beach ice maker is great because you will always be on top of what you need to do to keep that ice coming. It has been designed with multiple warning lights that let you know just what needs to be done in the ice making process. There is a light for letting you know when the water is low, and also lights for when the ice tray is full, and when ice is being made.

Other Features
This ice maker is great for many other reasons too,. It does a good job of getting the ice out as quickly as possible. It should take under ten minutes for some ice to be made. Another great feature is the ability of this ice maker to have different sizes of ice that it can make. It also has a good capacity, and can fit two pounds of ice in its tray.

Cost and Value
The Hamilton Beach is actually the cheapest option on this list, so far. It does a great job for the price. It is missing some of the extra features you might be looking for, but it is great for always letting you know what you need to do to get more ice made. It also has a small and portable design which makes it a great choice for smaller kitchens.

10. RCA

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
82
RCA
Amazon Link
Speed
82
Capacity
83
Effectiveness
82
Ease of Use
82
Protection
81
best offer for today
Amazon Link
Pros:

Large reservoir

Makes ice quickly

Good price

Options for ice size

Cons:

Issues with durability

The RCA is a quiet and efficient ice maker that will do a good job of keeping your house full of cooling ice.

Read more

Large Reservoir
This ice maker is great because it will make it easier for you to always have water at the ready. It has an extra large reservoir that can hold over two quarts of water. This means that it will take a little while before you run out. Less steps in the ice making process is always a good thing, and the RCA will make your life easier in that way.

Other Features
There are other great things going on with the RCA ice maker. It has a decently-sized tray that can hold up to one and a half pounds of ice. It is also very quick, and will have you sipping on a nice cold drink in under six minutes. It comes with a few options for the size of ice that you want, which is great for choosing the right ice for the occasion.

Cost and Value
The RCA ice maker is a really good choice for anyone who is in the market. It does everything just right. This includes the price, which is not overly expensive at all. This ice maker is great for anyone who wants the process to be as streamlined as possible. It is designed with your ease of use in mind.

Criteria Used for Evaluation

Speed

The most important thing about any ice maker is making sure that it is going to do a good job at making sure that you will have ice at the ready at any time. All the ice makers on this list will do a good job of making it easy for you to not have to worry about if there will be ice ready. There are some general baselines to look out for when looking for an ice maker that will meet the average requirements. A good ice maker will take less than ten minutes to give you the first set of cubes. This is a good amount of time for if you first get home, and need to wait for enough ice cubes for a drink. The best ice makers will take around five minutes to get a set of ice cubes out for you. There will always be an element of waiting, but the higher the rating in this category, the less waiting there will be.

Capacity

This is another important element to look for in an ice maker. There are two parts of the ice maker that have capacity as an important element of their design. There is always a tank in the back of the ice maker that you fill with water. This is the ammo that will make the ice for you. Look for an ice maker that has at least a few quarts of room back there for water. Every time that it runs out, you will have to fill it up again. The more capacity back there, the less time you will have to spend maintaining your ice maker. The other element of the ice maker where capacity is important is in the front of the ice maker. The ice will usually drop into a tray. The best ice makers will have lots of room up here so that you can make a huge amount of ice and then forget about it. If the cooling tray is properly insulated, then you can just make as much ice as you want and then forget about it.

Effectiveness

The ice in an ice maker is made very quickly. Because of this, it is often the case that the ice isn't as frozen as you are hoping for. This is okay sometimes. Many people point out that the ice that an ice maker produces is wet ice. This is because it is made so quickly that it doesn't have time to completely freeze on the outside, so there is still some moisture on the outside of the ice cube. Other ice makers will do a good job of giving you completely frozen ice. It isn't always the case, but the longer that the ice maker takes, the more likely that the ice will be of a higher quality. This category is a rating that will let you know how frozen you can expect the ice that you are getting to be.

Ease of Use

Anyone buying themselves an ice maker probably wants the experience of using it to be as painless as possible. The options on this list will all make it very easy to use them. You want to be able to set it and forget it. Fill up the reservoir, and then turn it on, and then let it do its thing. Look for ice makers that are designed to stop making ice once the max capacity in the front of the machine has been met. This will make it easier for you to be able to leave the ice maker alone. There are other useful things to look out for like if the ice maker lets you know when certain things need to be refilled. This could be something like an indicator light that lets you know when the ice bucket is full, or maybe something that lets you know when you have to refill the ice maker with more water.

Protection

This is another important thing to look out for. There are some ice makers that will do a better job of keeping your ice frozen. This can be seen in the amount of insulation that the ice maker has been designed with. If there is a lot of plastic in between the ice and you, then it is likely that the ice isn't very well insulated. On the other hand, some of the ice makers on this list are designed so that you can remove the ice bucket from the maker and then put it in your freezer so that you can use it later. This is great for keeping the ice, while not having to keep the ice maker on all the time. Some people enjoy the convenience of being able to leave the ice maker on for long periods of time, and if that fits your description, then make sure to look for an ice maker with thick insulation.

Expert Interviews & Opinions

Most Important Criteria (According to our experts opinion)
Sort criterias acording to:
Experts Opinion Editors Opinion Users Opinion By Default
Click on a to rate the most important criteria:
#1
ico Effectiveness
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
#2
ico Speed
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
#3
ico Ease of Use
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
#4
ico Capacity
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
#5
ico Protection
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
expert tips icon
Keep Your Options Open

Some of the ice makers on this list come with multiple sizes that you can choose from. This will make it much easier for you to choose the kind of ice that you want. Some ice is better for certain drinks. This can be a decorative choice, but larger ice also won't melt as quickly.

Preparation is Key

Ice makers take a little bit of time before they start spitting out ice. If people are coming over, then it might be a good idea to start getting that ice going early in the day. Many of the ice makers on this list brag about the twenty pounds of ice that they can create in a day. This is a little excessive, but if you start early, then it might happen.

Other Factors to Consider

Features

Something useful to think about getting for your ice maker is a scoop and a removable bucket. Both of these simple little tools will make your life much easier when you are using your ice maker. A scoop is great for making it easier on you when it comes to getting your precious ice. It is totally fine using your hands to get the ice out of the tray, but sometimes it might be off-putting to a guest, or at the very least, it will make your fingers cold. A bucket will work wonders for your ice maker because it will give you somewhere to put your ice after you have made it. You can keep it in the ice maker, but then you have to leave it on. If it ends up in the freezer then your life will be much easier, as the ice will be truly frozen, and you don't have to worry about how cold the ice maker is. Some of the ice makers on this list come with these tools, while others don't. Try to look out for the ones that do.

Portability

Many people who buy an ice maker are doing it because they do not have an ice maker attached to their fridge, but there is a huge benefit to buying an ice maker. They are all very portable. If you want to be able to have ice anywhere that an outlet is nearby, then an ice maker is good for you. It is very easy to bring your ice maker along on any kind of trip that you are going on. They are a great addition to anyone's RV, or even on someone's boat. This is much better than having to buy ice at the gas station for the cooler. An ice maker is totally fine with making ice out of lake water, or any other dirtier water source, as long as you clean the machine afterwards.

Size

You can buy an ice maker in a variety of sizes. The bigger that they are, the more capacity that they will have. On the other hand, it will make the ice maker a bit more cumbersome when it comes to finding a place for it. A good idea is to make sure that the measurements of the ice maker will fit in your home. If you live in a smaller apartment, then it might be a good idea to find an ice maker that is more designed to fit into a smaller space. The reality is that you won't need that much ice on an average day, so why not find an ice maker that is a good fit for your home before you find the one that can hold the most ice. A small ice maker is also a bonus if you buy an ice maker with a basket that can be moved to the freezer. This means that you won't need to keep the ice maker on at all times.

Frequently Asked Questions

q: Are these easy to clean?

a:

Ice makers are actually very easy to clean. The biggest issue is that there are parts of it that are hard to reach with your hands. The easiest way to clean an ice maker is to run it through a few cycles while adding some vinegar or lemon juice to the water tank. This will help remove any build up that may have developed over the times that you have used. An ice maker does not need to be cleaned very often seeing as it is just water, but this is a good idea for once every few months. The rest of the ice maker can just be wiped down with a cloth.

q: Can I use thisr right out of the box?

a:

Once your ice maker makes it to your home, you might want to try and use it right away. There are a few reasons not to. Appliances that freeze or cool things actually need a little bit of time for them to settle down after they have been transported. The cooling liquid in the ice maker needs to settle into its rightful place before it will be very effective at making ice that is actually frozen.

q: How do I stop my ice from having a plasticy smell and taste?

a:

This is something that everyone who has had an icy drink has to deal with. There is a residue on the plastic that washes off into your ice cubes as they move through the machine. It is actually very easy to fix. If you just clean your ice maker as described above, then that slightly gross flavor will go away. If the taste comes back, then just do it again. The flavor is caused by the materials that make up the ice maker, but also by the mineral buildup that comes from using the ice maker over and over again.

Sources

  1. Tom Harris, How Icemakers Work, Article
  2. This is Neat, How to Transport a Fridge the Right Way, Article
  3. Air & Water, Cleaning your Portable Ice Machine, Article