to top 10 table

Best .40 Caliber Pistols Reviewed & Rated for Quality

last updated Feb 22, 2019

A .40 pistol might be the next weapon you decide to add to your arsenal. They are a larger caliber for a pistol, but not so large that they can't be easily pocketed and carried around as a self-defense weapon. These pistols are great for those who want something heavy-duty, but still realistic for being carried around. The .40 isn't really the most popular kind of pistol, either. On the other hand, it has a deep line-up of some of the best pistols that can currently be found on the market. This list has ten of the best that you can find. There are a lot off familiar faces here, but also some lesser knows ones. This list is a great place to find the right pistol for you. Come and look down the list until you find the one for you.

Researched Sources
13
Researched Sources
Reviews Considered
511
Reviews Considered
Hours Researching
14
Hours Researching
Products Evaluated
10
Products Evaluated
Sorting Options
Accuracy Comfort Protection Durability Adjustability By Default
Rank
PictureProduct
Name
Rating
Shops
#1
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
98.4
Accuracy
99%
Comfort
99%
Protection
98%
Durability
98%
Adjustability
98%
Price Comparison Last Updated (19.04.19)
#2
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
97.4
Accuracy
98%
Comfort
98%
Protection
97%
Durability
98%
Adjustability
96%
Price Comparison Last Updated (19.04.19)
#3
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
96
Accuracy
97%
Comfort
96%
Protection
97%
Durability
95%
Adjustability
95%
Price Comparison Last Updated (19.04.19)
#4
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
94.4
Accuracy
95%
Comfort
95%
Protection
95%
Durability
93%
Adjustability
94%
Price Comparison Last Updated (19.04.19)
#5
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
92.8
Accuracy
93%
Comfort
94%
Protection
93%
Durability
92%
Adjustability
92%
Price Comparison Last Updated (19.04.19)
#6
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
90.2
Accuracy
91%
Comfort
90%
Protection
90%
Durability
89%
Adjustability
91%
Price Comparison Last Updated (19.04.19)
#7
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
88.2
Accuracy
88%
Comfort
88%
Protection
87%
Durability
89%
Adjustability
89%
Price Comparison Last Updated (19.04.19)
#8
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
86.6
Accuracy
87%
Comfort
87%
Protection
85%
Durability
86%
Adjustability
88%
Price Comparison Last Updated (19.04.19)
#9
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
85
Accuracy
85%
Comfort
86%
Protection
84%
Durability
86%
Adjustability
84%
Price Comparison Last Updated (19.04.19)
#10
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
83.8
Accuracy
83%
Comfort
84%
Protection
83%
Durability
84%
Adjustability
85%
Price Comparison Last Updated (19.04.19)
$549.88
See Deal
In Depth Review Top 10
  • Walther PPQ M2
  • Glock Gen 4
  • Beretta PX4
  • Sig Sauer P320
  • Smith & Wesson M&P Shield
  • HK Semiautomatic Centrefire
  • Ruger SR40
  • Springfield Armory XD Mod.2
  • Smith & Wesson M&P Compact
  • Glock Gen 3 Compact
Table of contents
  • Criteria Used for Evaluation
  • Other Factors to Consider
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Sources

Top 10 Picks

1. Walther PPQ M2

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
98.4
Accuracy
99
Comfort
99
Protection
98
Durability
98
Adjustability
98
best offer for today
more shops
Pros:

Easy trigger

Adjustable back strap

Quick release magazine

Easy to get into a rhythm

Cons:

Expensive pistol

The Walther PPQ is a series of .40 pistols that will do a great job of keeping you safe with their reliable firing, and easy to use trigger.

Read more

Smooth Shot
The Walther is an easy to use pistol that is designed so that it can be used instinctively by the shooter. The Walther has a very light trigger pull that makes it easy to fire and trusts that you'll know when to fire. It is also designed so that it makes an audible click when the gun is ready to fire again. This is great for getting into a rhythm with your shots.

Custom Fit
The Walther is also a very easily customized pistol, which is why it is such a good choice for anyone looking to buy a pistol. The back grip on this pistol can be very quickly changed out for a strap that makes more sense to the grip of your hand. The slide stop can also be used by both left and right handed people, which makes it useful for anyone.

Cost and Value
The Walther is a pretty expensive pistol, but it is also just about the best one that you can find on the market. This pistol will do well by you with its reliable firing, and very easy to adjust pieces. This pistol is perfect for just about anybody looking to buy a .40 pistol, and will do a great job for whatever use you have in mind for it.

2. Glock Gen 4

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
97.4
Accuracy
98
Comfort
98
Protection
97
Durability
98
Adjustability
96
best offer for today
more shops
Pros:

Designed to work in all kinds of weather

Good price

Safe design

Can be used with gloves on

Cons:

Trigger can dig into hand

The ever reliable Glock has its first entry on this list. The Gen 4 of Glock pistols are as reliable and praxtical as you could expect from one of the biggest names in firearms.

Read more

Reliable Name
The Glock Gen 4's are as reliable a set of pistols as you can find. They are designed to be able to continue to work in any kind of setting, and under any kind of workload. They are made of a heavy-duty polymer that can withstand the shock of many shots. They have also been coated in a strong material that stops the pistols from being damaged by the elements.

Universal Use
The Gen 4's claim to fame is that it has many new upgrades in terms of how easy it is to use out in the elements. The coating of the gun makes it a great choice for being a reliable shot even out in the rain or snow. The Gen 4 is also designed to be easily used even if you have gloves on, because it has been designed with a rough texture that makes it easier to grip.

Cost and Value
The Gen 4 Glock is a little bit cheaper than the Walther. These guns are designed to be reliable, especially in any kind of bad weather. A Glock is a great choice because you won't ever have to worry about if it is going to work when you need it most. That is the standard that has kept Glock afloat all these years.

3. Beretta PX4

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
96
Accuracy
97
Comfort
96
Protection
97
Durability
95
Adjustability
95
best offer for today
more shops
Pros:

Accurate design

Lightweight materials

Durable design

Smooth firing

Cons:

Hard to use safety

Beretta is another famous name when it comes to the production of pistols, and this one is no exception. The PX4 is a reliable and accurate .40.

Read more

Tight Engineering
Every piece of the Beretta has been designed to be of the highest quality you can hope to find in a pistol. The pieces are made of the most durable materials allowed, but they also attempt to keep the pistol's weight as low as possible. This makes the feeling of using a Beretta both reliable, and easy to wield.

Innovative Design
The PX4 is also great for some of the clever features that Beretta has thought of over the years. This pistol does a great job at keeping itself accurate and reliable, because of the locking of the barrel after every shot. This keeps the pistol steadier so that your shots will go where you want them to. It also uses a heat-resistant plastic that keeps the weight lower than with other pistols.

Cost and Value
The price of the Beretta is comparable to the Walther. This is a great gun if you want your accuracy, but also some lighter weight. These pistols are great for everyday use, and will do a good job on both the range, and in the field. They come with a few different back straps so you can choose the right fit for you.

4. Sig Sauer P320

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
94.4
Accuracy
95
Comfort
95
Protection
95
Durability
93
Adjustability
94
best offer for today
more shops
Pros:

Complex safety system

Can change many parts in the gun

Lightweight frame

Durable design

Cons:

For people who like switching pieces out

The Sig Sauer P320 is the choice of pistol for you if you like to switch around all the pieces in your pistol. This pistol is great for those who treat their pistol like an ongoing project.

Read more

Modular Design
The Sig Sauer lets you change anything that you can think of in its design to have the pistol that you want. You can change the caliber of this pistol from .40 to many other kinds. You can also change the grip on the pistol if you want something more comfortable. Finally, even the size of the gun can be changed due to Sig Sauer's interesting design.

Safety Features
As they say, safety first. This pistol has been designed that it will always be safe in your hands. Seeing as it is designed to be changed around a lot. This pistol has a complex safety system that means it can't be taken apart when there is a round chambered, or if there is a magazine in the pistol. This will keep you safe while you switch out the parts you like.

Cost and Value
The Sig Sauer is around the same price as the other pistols on this list. This pistol is a great choice for any kind of hobbyist who likes looking at all the new gadgets and pieces online for pistols. This pistol will keep you safe, while you are trying to make the perfect gun for yourself.

5. Smith & Wesson M&P Shield

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
92.8
Accuracy
93
Comfort
94
Protection
93
Durability
92
Adjustability
92
best offer for today
more shops
Pros:

Easy to carry around

Smooth firing

Durable polymer

Thin profile

Cons:

Trigger needs to be worked in

This pistol is designed as the perfect pistol for anyone who has a concealed carry permit. It is designed to be easy to carry and keep put away.

Read more

Portable Design
The Shield is designed to be used on a daily basis as your sidearm when you are going out and about on your day. This pistol has a very thin profile that makes it easy to comfortably fit on your person for when you go out. It is also designed to be easily carried around due to its very lightweight construction and materials.

Other Features
This pistol is also great for a multitude of other reasons. This pistol is great at giving you consistently accurate firing in a very smooth motion. It is also designed to be very durable, and has stain resistant polymers in it that will last through years of use. The barrel is made out of durable steel that can withstand many bouts of firing.

Cost and Value
The Shield is a little cheaper than many of the other pistols on this list, but not by much. This is a great pistol for everyday use. It won't get in the way while you are doing other things, but it is still more than useful enough to be effective in any situation that comes up. These pistols also come with flat and extended magazines so you can choose your capacity, as well.

6. HK Semiautomatic Centrefire

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
90.2
Accuracy
91
Comfort
90
Protection
90
Durability
89
Adjustability
91
best offer for today
more shops
Pros:

Safe design

Modular grip

Easy trigger

Efficient design

Cons:

More expensive

Heckler & Koch bring their widely respected effort and reliability to .40 pistols with ease and professionalism.

Read more

High Caliber Pedigree
The engineers at Heckler & Koch have always done a great job when it comes to producing their firearms, and it can be seen in who buys them. They are designed for people of all stripes, from the military to law enforcement, to the hobbyist. This is because their guns are reliable and dependable no matter the season or weather.

Safe and Simple
The HK pistols do a great job at riding the balance between safety and simplicity. The trigger is very easy to use and has a light pull, but it is also designed with a very tight safety system that will keep you safe from an unintended firing. This pistol is a great choice for anyone who values the safety of the gun their firing above all else.

Cost and Value
These pistols cost a little more than the other ones on the list, but it makes up for itself in the level of quality on display with this pistol. They can be easily modified so that they can better fit the hand of anyone using it, as well. These pistols are great for anyone who want an efficient pistol that prioritizes intention of use.

7. Ruger SR40

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
88.2
Accuracy
88
Comfort
88
Protection
87
Durability
89
Adjustability
89
best offer for today
more shops
Pros:

Compact design

Simple look

Good price

Good grip

Cons:

Jams with certain kinds of ammo

The pistols from Ruger are designed to be very sleek and simple. These pistols are designed for those who want all the features in a simple package.

Read more

Feels Good in the Hand
The Ruger SR40 is a smaller pistol that is designed to be easy to carry but to also feel really good in your hand. The grip is very comfortable, and the profile of the gun is very simple so that there won't be any distractions. The safety is manually released, and it can be used with either your right or left hand. A simple, but polished, gun.

Striker Fired
The SR40 is a semi-automatic, striker-fired pistol. This means that you can keep shooting it as much as you want without having to cock the hammer. Being a striker-fired pistol means that it doesn't even have a hammer to cock. This does make releasing the firing pin a little more complicated, but it will make your life much easier in the long term.

Cost and Value
The best thing about the Ruger is that it can be bought at a very reasonable price. This is a very reliable gun that you can use in many different settings. It will do a good job for you in whatever you need of it. It is designed to a little smaller than the other guns on this list, but it still packs quite a punch in any real, dangerous, situation.

8. Springfield Armory XD Mod.2

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
86.6
Accuracy
87
Comfort
87
Protection
85
Durability
86
Adjustability
88
best offer for today
more shops
Pros:

Compact profile

Good price

Comfortable grip

Easy to conceal

Cons:

Needs a good squeeze

Springfield Armory's .40 pistols are designed to be a sleek, compact, and usable pistol that you can take anywhere, and feel comfortable with immediately.

Read more

Take Anywhere Design
This is another pistol that is designed to be taken with you. It is a pistol with a very compact design, which makes it a good choice for using as your everyday pistol. It has a very slim profile that makes it easy to carry in the small of your back. This makes this a good gun that you can rely on when an unforeseen situation comes up.

Comfortable Design
The XD is designed to be able to be used out of the box. It won't take very long for you to get used to using this pistol. The grip is very comfortable and will fit right into anyone's hand. This pistol is designed so that you can quickly intuit all of its nooks and crannies, and be comfortable using it as quickly as possible.

Cost and Value
This pistol is a great choice for anyone who has been looking for their everyday gun. It is very easy to use. It has a slim profile that makes it easy to carry around with you comfortably. It also just feels really good in your hand. This pistol costs a little less than the other ones on this list and would do a great job as your first conceal carry.

9. Smith & Wesson M&P Compact

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
85
Accuracy
85
Comfort
86
Protection
84
Durability
86
Adjustability
84
best offer for today
more shops
Pros:

Good size

Comfortable grip

Quality sights

Durable

Cons:

Not a very good trigger

This is another entry from S&W. This pistol is similar to the shield, but has been designed so that yiou can take it with you as a concealed carry gun.

Read more

Convenient Size
The Compact is the right choice for you if you like Smith & Wesson pistols, but are worried about how large the M&P is. The Compact is great for day to day usage. It has a small profile that makes it a good choice for putting in a back holster. The pistol is also very easy to use so you can quickly pull it and have it at the ready.

Other Features
The Compact is great for many other reasons too. This pistol is made out of durable parts that are put together very well so that the pistol has a very smooth action. It has an ergonomic grip that makes sure that it feels good in your hand when you are steadying your aim. Finally, the Compact comes with a very useful sight that will immediately improve your accuracy.

Cost and Value
The Compact costs around the same amount as the other Smith & Wesson. It is more a matter of which size you are more comfortable with. This pistol is the perfect choice for someone who needs a weapon to bring around with them during the day, but also wants to feel comfortably with it in their holster.

10. Glock Gen 3 Compact

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
83.8
Accuracy
83
Comfort
84
Protection
83
Durability
84
Adjustability
85
best offer for today
$549.88
See Deal
Pros:

Useful size

Durable polymer

Glock quality

Great safety system

Cons:

Bit pricey

The Gen 3 from Glock is another great choice for anyone who wants to buy a Glock. This is another great type of gun from them with the same high standard of quality.

Read more

Reliable Glock Style
The Glock Gen 3 is another great example of all the reasons that the Glock is one of the most beloved kinds of pistol. The Gen 3 is a type of very compact handgun that is great for being carried around by you. The Gen 3 is a tinier version of the Gen 4, but it still sports the reliability that Glock is known for.

Safety Design
The safety of the Glock is one of the big reasons that they have become so well known. These pistols are designed with a very safe safety that will make sure you are never in danger when handling the weapon. The pistol is very reliable and uses Glock's very durable polymer that can handle many kinds of conditions for its use.

Cost and Value
The Gen 3 is a set of Glocks that do just as good of a job as the Gen 4 but at a little bit of a smaller size. The Gen 3s are a great choice for people who want to be able to take their gun with them. They are made with Glock's signature eye for quality so that you know that you can always rely on this pistol's performance.

Criteria Used for Evaluation

Accuracy

It is important that your pistol does a good job hitting its target. This can be seen in multiple ways. The most obvious is the sights. It is important to find a pistol with sights that do a good job of perfectly zeroing in on a target. This makes it easy to see the target properly. There are many ways that sights can improve your effectiveness, including different ways of setting up the sights that focus on either improved accuracy, or improved speed of target acquisition. The other thing that will improve the accuracy of your pistol is the way that the rifling is assembled. Some barrels are tighter than other, and this can effect the size of your grouping. the higher the rating in this category, the more likely that your bullets will hit where they are supposed to.

Comfort

This is another very important aspect of choosing the gun that you use. The better that it feels in your hand, the more confident you will feel when you are shooting the gun. There are many kinds of ways that a gun can feel good in your hand. There sis the weight of the pistol. Some pistols have a more evenly distributed weight to them that makes them feel more properly weighted when you carry them. It makes them easier to use, and also makes them feel more proper when palmed. Another way that guns can feel comfortable is how the grips are designed. Some .40s will have comfortable grips that you can hold in both your left and right hand. The score in this category will dictate how comfortable you will be when you use this pistol.

Protection

A lot of .40 pistols are designed to be used as concealed carry pistols. This means that they will often be held by being tucked towards the body. This means that you better hope that the pistol you're about to own has a confident and established safety system. Safety systems are very diverse among the pistols on this list. Some are simple buttons that need to be pushed, while others expect you to hold a button in the entire time you are shooting. The kind of system you want will depend a lot on how confident you feel around pistols. Some people are okay with a simple safety system, while others may want something more complex. This category tracks how effective the safety system of the pistol is.

Durability

It takes a lot of heavy-duty materials and design work to survive the barrage of firing the larger caliber .40 bullets. These bullets are designed to be large, but are also used in smaller pistols. They put the guns that inhabit through a good deal of stress. This means that these pistols have to be very well-made. All the pistols on this list are very well-designed to be able to handle a good round of firing action. They all use different materials, such as complex polymers, or old-fashioned steel, but they all do a good job of successfully keeping it together when you need them most. It is important that the barrels are designed so that they won't corrode over the course of long bouts of use, as well. The score in this category tracks the amount of use that you can put this pistol through without having to worry about it.

Adjustability

The .40 pistols are also well-known for being easy to customize. Many people enjoy the hobby of replacing a piece here and there in their pistol. It makes the pistol a bit more your own. All pistols can be modified to a different degree, and to differing levels of difficulty. It is more desirable to find a pistol that can easily have its parts switched out for new ones. There are also many stock parts that are worth looking into switching out. Sights, for example, are commonly known to be quickly replaced in many kinds of guns, such as the Glock. Some pistols try their best to make it as easy to change out parts as they can, and even market themselves as pistols designed to be modified. This category's score refers to how easy it is to change parts out in that particular gun.

Expert Interviews & Opinions

Most Important Criteria (According to our experts opinion)
Sort criterias acording to:
Experts Opinion Editors Opinion Users Opinion By Default
Click on a to rate the most important criteria:
#1
Accuracy
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
#2
Comfort
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
#3
Protection
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
#4
Durability
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
#5
Adjustability
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
Great Carry Around Weapon

A large reason that many people thing about buying a .40 pistol is that they do such a good job as a concealed carry weapon, but without having to sacrifice much in terms of stopping power. The .40 is larger than the 9 mm and the .38, but it can still be housed in a pistol that is about the same size. That makes these guns a good choice for a weapon that you need to carry around with you on a day to day basis. These pistols will do a good job of not poking or prodding you when you are just trying to go about your day. Secondly, they won't bulge through your shirt and make other people uncomfortable.

Flat VS Extended Magazines

Flat and extended magazines are the difference in a few rounds for your pistol. Which one is more for you depends completely on your preference. This is an especially important decision if you are a practitioner of concealed carry. The extra size of an extended magazine may make it impractical to use an extended magazine. Something that other users suggest is to use an extended magazine as a back-up magazine so that you don't need to have a bulging weapon on you at all times. Extended magazines usually only add a few more round to your overall clip size, but that may be the difference in an important situation.

Other Factors to Consider

Accessories

Something great about many of the guns on this list, is that they come with a few replacement parts so that you can better create the gun that you want. Most of the guns here come with a few different grips, which is helpful for finding the one that you find the most comfortable. Another thing that many of the pistols on this come with are different kinds of magazines. They come with extended and flat magazines so you choose the amount of rounds you want to be holding at one time. All these choices means that you don't have to worry about choosing something and worrying about one little thing not working. There will be many chances for you to find something that does work.

Materials

These pistols are made of a few different materials, and those materials each have different properties that may appeal to you in a different way. The pistols on this list are made with both steel and polymer. Both of these materials are designed to do a good job with the massive amount of heat created by the firing of a bullet, but they are different in other ways. Polymer is lighter than steel, but it might not be as reliable.

Frequently Asked Questions

q: Why should I choose a .40 pistol?
a:

There are a few reasons that you should choose to use a .40 pistol over other kinds of pistols. 9 mm pistols have definitely become the most common and popular used pistol when it comes to everyday use, but the .40 still has a place if you interested in a few things. The first thing that the .40 does better than everyone else is that has a good deal more penetration than the 9 mm. It does a better job of getting deep into a target, or for being able to shoot through things. It is also considered a pistol with more stopping power in general. When firing a .40, you will definitely feel more recoil after every shot. Many people enjoy that strong kick that you get from firing a heavy pistol.

Another reason to get a .40 is that they can be used with many different kinds of ammo. Many .40 pistols are designed so that you can use them with many different weights of ammo. This is useful for being able to buy the cheapest kinds of ammo that you can find on the market, which is great for saving you some money.

q: What are some good things to modify in my pistol?
a:

There are many things that you can change around in your .40 pistol that might make it a better shot, or just more appealing to your sensibilities as a shooter. Here is a list of some things that you can think of changing.

Trigger: It is actually possible to switch around the trigger of your pistol. Many triggers are either too light or too tough of a pull for many people. This means that it can feel uncomfortable using many new pistols because the pull won't be what you are used to. It is easy to buy a new trigger system that will be more in line with what you are comfortable with.

Sights: Many sets of factory sights that you get with pistols are not quite up to snuff when it comes to being able to accurately shoot. This can manifest in a few ways. Some pistols don't do a very good job when it comes to durability. They might be made of cheaper plastic that breaks if you drop the gun or smack it against a hard surface. New sights will do a good job of giving you a set of sights as durable as the rest of the gun. Custom sights are also great because they can give you the capability to be able to fire at night. They might use tritium to be able to glow in the dark and give you that extra edge during the evening.

q: How should I hold my .40?
a:

All the .40 pistols on this list are semi-automatic pistols. There is actually a preferred way to hold a semiautomatic that means you will have the best kind of grip on your weapon. This is especially important with a .40 pistol, because of the amount of kickback that these pistols have.

To do this stance, start by holding the pistol with your dominant hand in a safe position. The hold the bottom of your dominant hand with your other hand. Finally, place your weaker thumb behind your dominant thumb. This better braces you against the recoil of the shot without entirely losing your target.

q: How do I clean my .40 pistol?
a:

It is important to make sure to properly maintain and clean your pistol on a regular basis. The process is simple if you have the proper tools. This is a general idea of how to do that. The first thing that you have to do is unload your pistol. This means making sure that the magazine is ejected and that there isn't a round chambered in the pistol. After this, remove the barrel of the pistol from the rest of the gun. You are going to need a cleaning kit for the rest of the process. This includes having some solvent, some grease, a boring brush, and a brush. First you should scrub the barrel with a bore brush to get rid of all the extra bits of gunk left over from firing your weapon. Then you can lubricate it with the grease. After that, you are going to want to use solvent on the action, which is the top of the barreless pistol. This will get rid of any dirt that has gotten in there. Finally, use lubricant to lube the action so that the pistol will slide properly when fired.