Best Milkshake Machines Reviewed & Rated for Quality

In a Hurry? Editors choice:
Hamilton Beach HMD200
Test Winner: Hamilton Beach HMD200
Amazon Link
If you have found yourself on this page, then you probably agree that milkshakes are the best dessert that you could ever have. It is always difficult to find one when you want one. You could, of course, go to McDonald's to buy yourself one, but it just isn't the same. If you ever get a late night craving for a milkshake, the most satisfying thing you can do is make one for yourself. There are specific machines to do this. Milkshakes need a smoothness that can only be achieved by the strongest of blenders. This list is a collection of blenders and mixers that are up to the task. These blenders will also do a good job of giving you the smoothest and most well-mixed drinks you could hope for. There are choices here that are more specifically for milkshakes, but also choices for more general use, too.

Standout Picks

Hamilton Beach HMD200
The Hamilton Beach mixer is a very powerful mixer that will do a great job of giving you any kind of drink that you could imagine in the smoothest form possible.
Amazon Link
$399.00
Nestpark Portable
This is the complete opposite of the Hamilton Beach mixer. This is a small and portable mixer that will do a good job of making sure your drinks stay smooth.
Amazon Link
$15.95
Hamilton Beach Classic
This is another entry from Hamilton Beach. This one is a more home-oriented milkshake maker that takes up less space and will ensure that you have smooth drinks every time.
Amazon Link
$49.16
Nostalgia MLKS100BL
This is a sleek profiled milkshake maker that will be a great fit on just about anybody's shelf. It does a great job of giving you smooth drinks.
Amazon Link
$48.45
Magic Bullet Express Deluxe
The Magic Bullet is a classic when it comes to all kinds of blending. It will do just as good of a job when it comes to making your milkshakes.
Amazon Link
Waring Commercial
The Waring Commercial Mixer is a good choice if you want the power and reliability of a strong mixer, but without the hefty size or price tag.
Amazon Link
COSORI Blender 1500W
The blender from COSORI can do a little bit of everything and is sure to give you a smooth and creamy milkshake with little effort.
Amazon Link
Breville BSB510XL
The Breville is a unique option on this list because it gives you the ability to use it as both an immersion blender, and as a traditional blender.
Amazon Link
$129.95
Hamilton Beach Proctor Silex 60200
This is another commercial drink mixer that will fit right in at your restaurant or coffee shop. It is sleek and doesn't take up too much space.
Amazon Link
$249.99
Vitamix Drink Machine
The Vitamix is another very famous blender that has taken up a good share of the market. This is a very powerful blender that will be great at making you a milkshake.
Amazon Link

Criteria Used for Evaluation

Effectiveness

If you are buying a milkshake machine, then the most important thing that it can do is make a milkshake. This category is an indication of how well your new milkshake machine will make your milkshake. It is a delicate process, and it takes a powerful mixer to get the milkshake to just the right consistency. The best milkshake machines do a good job of blending everything together into a perfectly smooth mixture, without any loose bits of ice or material. It takes a good deal of work to do this. The blenders on this list chop everything up until it is small enough that it feels smooth, while the drink mixers shake the materials until they blend together. Both methods work, but this category measures how well each mixer accomplishes its task.

Speed

When the craving for a milkshake strikes, it should be sated as quickly as possible. That is why this category is here. This is an indication of how long it will take for your milkshake to be made. Faster is always better in the case of getting to eat your dessert. The speed of milkshake creation really depends on the motor. The blenders on this list will create milkshakes quicker than the mixers, but they do not blend the drink together, as well, so you are going to have to make a choice. The higher the wattage of the motor on the blender, the quicker it will probably be able to make your milkshake. Look for indications of how quick the mixers are on their individual store pages. This will let you know what you can expect from your soon to be blended drinks.

Fit

There are a few options on this list that are considered commercial mixers. This is not a big deal if you are a business owner who owns a commercial business, but it might concern someone who is the owner of a cramped kitchen. Although it says that it is a commercial mixer, the commercial mixers will easily fit in your home for the most part. This category is a way of telling you how likely it is that your mixer will fit in your home. They can usually be placed right on the counter so that you don't have to worry about the milkshake machine taking up too much space. Making a milkshake is not an everyday task for most people, so you might want to think about buying one of the blender options on the list so that you have a bit more versatility with your new toy.

Adjustability

A nice thing to look for in your almost milkshake machine is the ability to change the speed of your mixing. This is useful in a few different ways. If you start the milkshake machine at too high a setting it can aerate the milk so that the milkshake has too light of a texture. On the other hand, a slow milkshake machine might not do a good job of mixing at all. Having the ability to change the speed as you go is the best way to make sure that you end up with a high-quality milkshake. Outside of the milkshake realm, being able to change the speed on your blender lets you cater the blender to whatever ingredients you are mixing up. This is an indication of how many options you will have when it comes to using each of the milkshake machines on this list.

Value

There's a pretty wide variety of choices on this list when it comes to price. The biggest reasons for this is that some of the milkshake machines and blenders on this list are commercial products. These drink mixers are more specialized appliances. They are great appliances that do a good job of making milkshakes, but they cost a little extra so that you can do that. You're the one reading this list, though, so you must be at least a little interested. A drink mixer is the best way to blend a drink because of well it mixes everything together. On the other hand, blenders give you many more options for use. If you don't have the space or the money, then it is a good idea to buy one of the blenders for their wider range of use. If you have both of those things, a drink mixer will truly change the way you enjoy your blended drinks.

10 Best Milkshake Machines

1. Hamilton Beach HMD200

Where to buy
Amazon Link
$399.00
Hamilton Beach HMD200
Amazon Link

The Hamilton Beach mixer is a very powerful mixer that will do a great job of giving you any kind of drink that you could imagine in the smoothest form possible.

Commercial Drink Mixer
This mixer is designed to do a good job at a business, as well as in your own home. It has a very powerful motor that will create smooth drinks of any kind within seconds. The motor has a one-third horsepower, which means that anything that you try to blend will get mixed up within seconds. Being a commercial blender means that it is made of very high-quality materials too, so it will last for a long time.

Other Features
The Hamilton Beach blender has lots of other great things going for it. It has three different speeds, so you can choose the quickness and smoothness of your milkshake making. It also has multiple ways that it can be turned on. It can either automatically turn on when you put the cup that comes with the machine in it, or you can have it be turned on with a button press.

Cost and Value
The Hamilton Beach commercial blender is quite expensive, but that is because it is designed to give you quick and successful results. If you have the money and the space for it, this blender will make it easy for you to get anything looking the way you want it, and that is doubly true for any milkshakes that you might want to have.

Amazon Link
$399.00

2. Nestpark Portable

Where to buy
Amazon Link
$15.95
Nestpark Portable
Amazon Link

This is the complete opposite of the Hamilton Beach mixer. This is a small and portable mixer that will do a good job of making sure your drinks stay smooth.

Portable Milkshake Maker
This milkshake maker is much less powerful and quick than the Hamilton Beach, but it makes up for it with its convenience and portability. This is a blender that you can bring with you on a trip. It is designed so that you can just hold it in one hand and then let it do its magic. Another great thing about it is that you can just put the stick blender right into your cup, so there will be fewer dirty dishes.

Other Features
There are lots of other reasons to love Nestpark. It is made of high-quality stainless steel that is durable enough to handle getting smacked around but will also do a good job of remaining stainless. This blender will also be incredibly easy to clean. You can just rinse it off and hang it up, without needing to worry about cleaning it in the dishwasher.

Cost and Value
This blender is a great choice for anyone who wants something low impact, and easy to use. It is more designed for lighter mixes but will do a good job of fluffing you up a milkshake given enough time. The small design of this mixer makes it a perfect choice for anyone who doesn't have the counter space for a milkshake machine. It also doesn't cost very much at all, which is great.

Amazon Link
$15.95

3. Hamilton Beach Classic

Where to buy
Amazon Link
$49.16
Hamilton Beach Classic
Amazon Link

This is another entry from Hamilton Beach. This one is a more home-oriented milkshake maker that takes up less space and will ensure that you have smooth drinks every time.

Milkshake Master
This is a great choice for anyone who wants the stylings of a classic milkshake maker that you would see in a 50's diner, but without the bulky size, or exorbitant price tag. This milkshake maker comes with a large cup to hold your drinks, and it has an easy way for you to make your drinks in seconds. It has a powerful motor that will make you a smooth drink in seconds.

Other Features
There are lots of other great features with the Drink Master that should get you excited. It has two speeds so that you can choose the level of intensity you would like while you are making your food. It is also very easy to get at the head of the milkshake maker because it can be tilted back so you have easier access to the cup. It also has a removable spindle, which makes it very easy to clean.

Cost and Value
This Drink Master is the perfect choice for anyone who wants the power of a commercial drink mixer but without the price tag or the bulkiness. It can be used for all kinds of drinks, and not just milkshakes. which is great too. The price of this unit is incredibly cheap for the value that you are sure to get out of it. This has lots of longevity as a simple and easy drink mixer for just about anybody.

Amazon Link
$49.16

4. Nostalgia MLKS100BL

Where to buy
Amazon Link
$48.45
Nostalgia MLKS100BL
Amazon Link

This is a sleek profiled milkshake maker that will be a great fit on just about anybody's shelf. It does a great job of giving you smooth drinks.

Classic Drink Mixer
This a classically styled drink mixer that will do a good job at making you a smooth and delicious milkshake. It has all the things you would expect in an old school milkshake maker. It is great because underneath that cute and small appearance there is a strong one hundred watt motor that you can use for any kind of smooth drinks.

Other Features
Beyond the powerful motor, there are lots of other great things about the Nostalgia that will make it easy to love it as a milkshake maker. It has a slim profile, but there is also a weighted base to the Nostalgia that makes it secure when left on the counter. It also comes with two different speeds so that you can choose how blended you want your drinks.

Cost and Value
A great thing about Nostalgia is that it doesn't cost very much. It will make you a great smoothie in no time at all, and all you need to do is throw some ice cream and other ingredients in. The Nostalgia is a good fit for anybody who is worried about how much space they have for another appliance. It doesn't take up much space and does a great job at its size.

Amazon Link
$48.45

5. Magic Bullet Express Deluxe

Where to buy
Amazon Link
Magic Bullet Express Deluxe
Amazon Link

The Magic Bullet is a classic when it comes to all kinds of blending. It will do just as good of a job when it comes to making your milkshakes.

Easy to Use
The Magic Bullet is great because of just how easy it is to use it. This blender is simple in how it is set up, how it is used, and how it is cleaned. You can just attach your cup to the base of the Magic Bullet, and then press down to get the Magic Bullet to blend. Your cup is also the blender so you don't need any extra steps to get at your milkshake.

Other Features
The Magic Bullet comes with tons of different features, which will do a good job of making your life very easy. The Magic Bullet doesn't have any settings for its speed, which can be a good thing for just pressing down until your drink is done. The Magic Bullet is incredibly fast at making you a blended drink that you can enjoy.

Cost and Value
The Magic Bullet is a very good price for how much you get when you buy it. This is a full set of all the different Magic Bullet attachments. It comes with many different cups and jars that you can attach to the Magic Bullet. They come with colored indicators so you can know who is who's. There are enough pieces for a few people at once.

Amazon Link

6. Waring Commercial

Where to buy
Amazon Link
Waring Commercial
Amazon Link

The Waring Commercial Mixer is a good choice if you want the power and reliability of a strong mixer, but without the hefty size or price tag.

Good Mix of Both
This commercial mixer is a good choice for both people who are running a business, and for people who want a drink mixer for their house. It has the power of a commercial mixer and has a motor that runs at full horsepower. It also has a smaller size that makes it an easy fit into just about anybody's kitchen. The Waring can do both.

Other Features
The Waring has lots of other features that make it worth a look. It has a strong motor that is great for breaking down any kind of ice cream, even the stuff that has been spending some time in the back of the fridge. Just to make sure, there are multiple speeds that you can choose from, with the strongest moving at a whopping 24.000 rpm.

Cost and Value
Another great thing about the Waring is that it doesn't cost nearly as much as other commercial mixers that you might find online. This, coupled with its size, makes it a good choice for anyone who wants a powerful milkshake maker that is dedicated to making the best-blended drinks. This milkshake maker is a great fit in any kitchen, large or small.

Amazon Link

7. COSORI Blender 1500W

Where to buy
Amazon Link
COSORI Blender 1500W
Amazon Link

The blender from COSORI can do a little bit of everything and is sure to give you a smooth and creamy milkshake with little effort.

Versatile Blender
The COSORI is not just a milkshake maker, but it can do that too. This is just a good choice for anyone who is looking for a powerful blender. It has six blades inside of it, which makes it a quick and easy solution for making sure that you can have a blended drink as fast as you want. The motor comes in at a very powerful 1500 W.

Other Features
This milkshake machine has lots of other things that might pique your interest. It has a uniquely designed speed knob, which will make it very easy for you to find the perfect speed. No more clunky buttons on your way to the perfect blending speed. It also has a very large container so that you can make lots of milkshake for the whole family.

Cost and Value
The COSORI is a great choice for anyone who wants a milkshake machine for their kitchen. This is a very powerful blender that will make short work of anything that you put in it. It has a lot of versatility and can make lots of food very quickly. The COSORI doesn't cost very much at all, and won't do much to break the bank for how much value you are getting out of it.

Amazon Link

8. Breville BSB510XL

Where to buy
Amazon Link
$129.95
Breville BSB510XL
Amazon Link

The Breville is a unique option on this list because it gives you the ability to use it as both an immersion blender, and as a traditional blender.

Easy to Switch
The Breville is designed like a traditional immersion blender or hand blender. It will do a great job when you just pull it out of a drawer and get straight to work. What makes it unique is that you can also attach it to the container that it comes with to turn it into a more traditional blender. This makes it so that you can liquefy thicker materials, and not have to worry about the mess.

Other Features
The Breville is great for many reasons. It is a very well-designed immersion blender. It has a very comfortable grip, which makes it easy to let the mixer do its work. It also has a soft ridge at the bottom of it, which means you don't need to worry about if the blender is going to scratch the bottom of your pots. The Breville is great in both of its forms.

Cost and Value
The convenience of using the Breville makes your life much easier. It can be used very quickly if you just want to use it as an immersion blender, but can also be set up to make it a more traditional blender. In both of these forms, the blender will do a great job at giving you the results that you want. The price of the Breville is also very reasonable for the amount of use that you will get out of it.

Amazon Link
$129.95

9. Hamilton Beach Proctor Silex 60200

Where to buy
Amazon Link
$249.99
Hamilton Beach Proctor Silex 60200
Amazon Link

This is another commercial drink mixer that will fit right in at your restaurant or coffee shop. It is sleek and doesn't take up too much space.

Commercial Drink Mixer
This drink mixer is a good fit for any kind of establishment that needs the ability to fluff up a drink or make milkshakes. It is very easy to put a cup in the mixer and then let it go. It will turn on automatically and very quickly blend you up a shake or coffee drink. It is also very easy to buy extra cups if you need them.

Other Features
There are lots of reasons that this mixer is a good fit for your business. It has a very heavy base so that you can leave it on the counter, and then not have to worry about if it is going to tilt or fall over. It is also well-designed in the arm and motor department. The 300 W motor is designed for durability and quickness, while the arm is made of easy to clean stainless steel.

Cost and Value
The price of the Procter Silex is actually very reasonable for what you will get out of it. It is a very reliable and well-designed drink mixer for any kind of home. It is easy to use and also very easy to clean. This is a good choice for anyone whose main priority with their drink mixer is that it won't give them a hassle.

Amazon Link
$249.99

10. Vitamix Drink Machine

Where to buy
Amazon Link
Vitamix Drink Machine
Amazon Link

The Vitamix is another very famous blender that has taken up a good share of the market. This is a very powerful blender that will be great at making you a milkshake.

Famous Blender
The Vitamix has been famous for a good while now, and there is a very good reason for it. This is a personal blender for home use that is more than powerful enough for use at a restaurant. It is very quick and powerful and will send your milkshake splashing around in no time. It has a very advanced design that lets the blades fly at a very powerful speed.

Other Features
There are lots of things to get excited about with the Vitamix. It can be used for many different things, because of its power. It also has a very high capacity, which makes this a good choice if you want to be able to feed the entire family. The Vitamix also comes with six different settings so that you can choose the perfect speed for making your drinks.

Cost and Value
The Vitamix is a good deal for anyone looking for a milkshake machine, or any other kind of blender for that matter. It is very powerful and fast, and it also gives you tons of space so that you can make as much milkshake as you want. This is a good choice for anyone who wants their blenders powerful and convenient.

Amazon Link

Sources

  1. KaleidoScoops, Using A Milkshake Machine Vs. Blender, Article
  2. Scott Damon, Can I Freeze Milkshakes?, Article
  3. Sarah De Heer, How to Make the Perfect Milkshake at Home, Article