to top 10 table

Straw Cowboy Hats Reviewed & Rated for Quality

last updated: May 22, 2019

Fashion changes with each passing moment. As such, with each moment that goes by individuals would require something that would enable them to stay at par with the advancements in technology and the new brands developed. Cowboy hats can be an exceptional addition to individuals’ outfit drawers. The hats had to the outward beauty of the bearer of such kinds of costumes. All that individuals are required to do is to arrive at the best kind of cowboy hat if they wish to maximum on some of the benefits that may accrue with having a cowboy hat as additional stylish wear. The following are some examples of straw cowboy hats that individuals could choose from in making their purchases. You need to look at and try out the different available options so that you could arrive at the best hat selection that would suit your tastes and preference.

In a Hurry? The test winner after 9 hrs of research

icon
 Play Platoon Hat
99/100 our score
Materials
100
Style
99.7
Brand
99
Size
98
Play Platoon Hat
Why is it better?

Good fit

Lifetime warranty

Exceptional customer service

High quality

In a Hurry? Editors choice:
 Play Platoon Hat
Test Winner: Play Platoon Hat
Amazon Link
Researched Sources
18
Researched Sources
Reviews Considered
18
Reviews Considered
Hours Researching
9
Hours Researching
Products Evaluated
32
Products Evaluated
Sorting Options
Materials Style Brand Size By Default
Rank
PictureProduct
Name
Rating
Shops
#1
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
99
Materials
100 %
Style
99.7 %
Brand
99 %
Size
98 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (26.02.20)
Amazon Link
$22.99
#2
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
97.5
Materials
98.4 %
Style
97 %
Brand
97.2 %
Size
98 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (26.02.20)
Amazon Link
$26.95
#3
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
94.5
Materials
95.2 %
Style
94.8 %
Brand
95.5 %
Size
94.1 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (26.02.20)
Amazon Link
$19.99
#4
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
91.5
Materials
92.8 %
Style
91.5 %
Brand
92 %
Size
91.3 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (26.02.20)
Amazon Link
$8.85
#5
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
88.5
Materials
89.5 %
Style
88.5 %
Brand
89 %
Size
88 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (26.02.20)
Amazon Link
$24.99
#6
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
85.5
Materials
86.3 %
Style
85 %
Brand
86.9 %
Size
85.2 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (26.02.20)
Amazon Link
$19.99
#7
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
82.5
Materials
83.2 %
Style
82 %
Brand
83.8 %
Size
82 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (26.02.20)
Amazon Link
$13.00
#8
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
80.8
Materials
81.5 %
Style
80.8 %
Brand
82 %
Size
80 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (26.02.20)
Amazon Link
$14.49
#9
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
77.5
Materials
78.6 %
Style
77 %
Brand
77.4 %
Size
78 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (26.02.20)
Amazon Link
#10
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
74.5
Materials
75.3 %
Style
75.9 %
Brand
74.2 %
Size
74 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (26.02.20)
Amazon Link
$22.99

10 Best Straw Cowboy Hats

1. Play Platoon Hat

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
99
 Play Platoon Hat
Amazon Link
Materials
100
Style
99.7
Brand
99
Size
98
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$22.99
Pros:

Good fit

Lifetime warranty

Exceptional customer service

High quality

Cons:

Slightly big for kid’s heads

Does not come together with matching bandanas

A single hat can fit perfectly on the heads of different users. In fact, the hat has been discovered as reliable wear for kids of all ages as well as the majority of adults. This particular feature makes the hat a perfect purchase given that consumers could recommend the hat to another person if it happens that the person the hat is bought does not like it or changes his or her mind about the hat. For the few people who have tried this type of hat, it is clear that the hat can be used in different kinds of situations including dress ups, birthday parties, and in most occasions as a quick comfortable cowboy costume.

Chinstrap

The hat is fitted with an additional chinstrap that can be used in retaining the hat in place even as children play around with the hat on the head. Even if the user bends over and the chinstrap is in place the hat would remain on the head.

Enhanced quality

The hat design is of the highest quality. The hat is also made of exceptional materials to make it one of a kind. This cowboy hat comes with a package that contains 12 hats with six hats in the package having been designed with a blue star and the remaining six hats designed with a red star.

Cost and Value

One thing that makes this product a wise investment opportunity is that it has a lifetime warranty. The lifetime warranty guarantees the quality of the product given that the user can easily take back faulty hats to the manufacturers for a replacement. The replacement would be done at no additional cost under certain conditions.

2. Fun Express

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
97.5
 Fun Express
Amazon Link
Materials
98.4
Style
97
Brand
97.2
Size
98
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$26.95
Pros:

Adorable

Sturdy

Affordable

Cons:

Too small even for a child

Uneven quality- at one point you may get very quality hats and other times the quality depreciates exponentially thus leading to the acquisition of poor quality products. 

This cowboy hat has a star design at the front end, which adds to the beautiful outlook of the hat. It is best suited for the child’s fashion wear addition. Besides, the hat comes in different colors and designs that make it a suitable costume to use for different occasions based on the color of the hat rim and the star fitted on the hat.

Easy fit

A single size of this particular hat can fit the heads of a majority of children belonging to different age groups. This makes the hat a suitable costume addition to use when attending a party or any occasion that would require individuals to be dressed in unique costumes.

Affordable

These are adorable party favors that are sold at a considerate price. The hat is suitable for children aged between 4 years to 12 years. The hat helps in promoting fun activities for children who can use the hat to play cowboy games.

Cost and Value

These types of cowboy hats can be a good present for our children during their birthday. Children look good when dressed in these types of hats. Besides, acquiring more hats for the friends of the child celebrating his or her birthday places the child in a celebratory mood. The hats are of exceptional quality and very affordable thus making it easier for a parent to afford one for the child celebrating his or her birthday and additional cowboy hats for the children who would join the birthday child in his or her celebrations.

3. Simplicity Headband

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
94.5
 Simplicity Headband
Amazon Link
Materials
95.2
Style
94.8
Brand
95.5
Size
94.1
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$19.99
Pros:

Adjustable

Stylish

Removable headband

Both girls and boys can use it

Cons:

The decorative element on the headband is not well centered

This particular cowboy hat is designed to suit the fashion needs of all kids. It has a teardrop folding that gives the hat its unique structure. The brim of the hat can be adjusted into any shape one may desire. This feature makes the hat comfortable wear at any time of the day. The hat is also suitable for dress-up idea parties. The hat can also be worn with different types of outfits. The hat reminds consumers of the old-fashioned dress code amongst cowboys.

Secure Band

Particular types of cowboy hats have bands that are elastic and can easily be adjusted. This enables consumers to attain a secure fit, which comes with great convenience for any one user. Other hat designs are made with more than a single color and this adds to the style of the cowboy hat. The different colors make the hat more appealing from an outward look.

Stylish

The headband of the hat is usually fitted with different unique decorative elements such as a metal bull, a turquoise gem and in other cases different types of styled buttons and beads. These features add to the outward appeal of the hat.

Cost and Value

Purchasing this cowboy hat comes with so much benefit in the sense that both boys and girls can wear it. The hat also has decorative features that make it stylish and appropriate wear for different occasions. The headband can easily be removed from the hat when the user desires. In doing so, the user has the option of replacing the existing headband with another one he or she considers suited for particular occasions. The headbands exist in different colors and styles thus making it easy for consumers to dress appropriately for different occasions by replacing the headband where appropriate.

4. Hat w/Star

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
91.5
 Hat w/Star
Amazon Link
Materials
92.8
Style
91.5
Brand
92
Size
91.3
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$8.85
Pros:

Affordable

A good fit

Durable if used with great care

Can be stored with much ease

Cons:

Poor quality finish

Only a few of this product is currently available in the stores. This is a clear indication of how this particular product is valued by a large group of people who would not hesitate to acquire one if necessary. However, the hat is most suited for children aged 3-10 years.

A good fit

The hat can fit perfectly on the head, given that it has a strap that can be used to tighten the cowboy hat around the chin area of the body. The string strap feature enables the user to walk around comfortably with the hat well fitted on the head.

Durable

Regardless of how children use this type of hat and no matter how many times this hat is ran over by the children’s feet or the equipment that children use during their play time period, this type of hat always regains its original size. The fact that the hat can easily regain its original shape and size makes it easy to store even during travel.

Cost and Value

In as much as the hats might not seem to look like they are of super high quality the benefits that accrue with purchasing this type of hat for your child are overwhelming. Besides, the hats are designed to not look like ones made from high-quality materials. However, buying the hat for your child would mean that the child would experience great fun and happiness brought about by having such kind of a costume. Most children adore this type of hat. The price may seem much when it comes to acquiring a single hat. Nevertheless, you would be able to get a good deal by acquiring several hats of the same kind. Furthermore, the shipping cost would remain the same even if you decide to order for more of the product instead of a single hat.

5. Children's Cowboy Hat

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
88.5
 Children's Cowboy Hat
Amazon Link
Materials
89.5
Style
88.5
Brand
89
Size
88
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$24.99
Pros:

Professional design that gives it a beautiful outlook

Quality material

Good fit

Cons:

Plain and not colorful

This product arrives as a single hat instead of a collection of several hats. However, the advantage of acquiring this type of hat lies in the fact that a single sized cowboy hat can fit on most heads. This makes it easier for children to swap their hats if need be so that they could have a different feel for their friend’s hats.

Suitable for Different Occasions

The fun costume can be used in different situations or fun activities children enjoy such as cowboy theme parties, kids’ birthday parties, Wild West parties, and the rodeo-themed parties.

Well Designed

The hat is well constructed to make it look beautiful and presentable when on the head. It is a perfect gift for kids’ birthday celebrations. The hat is not only exceptional but it also makes children feel like they have taken up an important role in the society by perhaps acting as a chief guest for instance in a birthday party event.

Cost and Value

If you wish your children to have a sense of self-fulfillment and significance then this is the kind of hat to purchase for your kid. The cowboy hat is designed in a unique manner to make the bearer appear top of the class. Most children who wear this type of cowboy hat are usually considered guests of honor in the birthday parties for the children. The hat gives children a sense of self-worth.

6. Simplicity Decorated Headband

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
85.5
 Simplicity Decorated Headband
Amazon Link
Materials
86.3
Style
85
Brand
86.9
Size
85.2
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$19.99
Pros:

Affordable

Adaptable to different scenarios and times of the day

Well made

Cons:

Easily bunched up

Particular designs of the hat come with an adjustable elastic band that would help the user to fit the hat on the head securely. Other designs come in more than a single color, which adds to the stylish nature of the hat. The hat is structured in a way that makes it a suitable wear for both cowboys and cowgirls. The teardrop folding structure of the hat adds to the stylish outlook of the hat.

Removable Band

If need be, you can easily remove the existing headband to replace it with a more appropriate headband. The headbands for this type of cowboy hat exist in a variety of colors and designs. Therefore, it would be much easier for any consumer to find more appropriate headband for different occasions.

Stylish

Removable headbands of the hat are acquired with different kinds of decorative features such as a metal bull, a turquoise gem, beads and buttons that are styled in different ways.

Cost and Value

Anyone in need of a hat that can easily be adjusted to be used in different occasions and during different times of the day then this hat is the best option you can invest in. The brim of the hat can be adjusted into different shapes with much ease. The ease with which the brim can be adjusted makes the hat a comfortable fit for different times of the day and occasions. It can also be used as a fun costume for the dress up parties given the hat’s unique designs.

7. MG Toyo

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
82.5
 MG Toyo
Amazon Link
Materials
83.2
Style
82
Brand
83.8
Size
82
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$13.00
Pros:

Affordable

Comfortable

Universal fit

Adjustable brim

Cons:

Weak material vulnerable to damage

This hat is made of pure paper straw material. A single size of the hat would fit most heads perfectly. It would fit perfectly on the heads of individuals who would prefer the extra large type of cowboy hat. The elastic band fitted as part of the hat’s design can be used to attain a more suitable fit for individuals who may require an adjustable hat.

Design

The decoration band incorporated as part of the cowboy hat design makes this costume more appealing to look at. The color of most of these hats fit perfectly with most clothes individuals may decide to wear more so the brown colored hat.

Convenient

The consumer can shape and reshape the brim of the hat into the shape that he or she considers most suitable for different occasions. The brim is 4 inches in width thus making its brim easily adjustable.

Cost and Value

The hat is sold at a very affordable rate, which leaves most consumers wondering why the companies would charge so little given some of the immense benefits that come with purchasing the hat. For one, the hat is made of a thin and soft material that helps increase the comfort of the user during use. The material is well ventilated thus providing cool conditioning on the head when in use more so during the hot times of the year.

8. Child's Plastic Star

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
80.8
 Child's Plastic Star
Amazon Link
Materials
81.5
Style
80.8
Brand
82
Size
80
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$14.49
Pros:

Affordable

Good quality

Comfortable

A good fit

Cons:

Flimsy

These hats are acquired in a set of six hats a piece. Each set would be comprised of hats of different colors such as three blue hats and three red hats to make it six hats in total. However, you may come across a collection of this particular hat that varies in color and not just designs in two basic color, blue and red, like the ones outlined above.

Durable

The hat is not easy to destroy or break. You may bend the hat material in whichever way you please in order o fit perfectly on the head without damaging it in the process. Once the hat fits perfectly on the head, it becomes much easier for the user to walk around in great comfort and with the surety that even if they bend at any given point in time, the hat would not fall off.

Stylish

The quality and outward look of the hat is adorable. Anyone in his or her right senses would resolve to purchase the hat for the son or daughter. I would recommend this particular cowboy hat to any person who may be in need of an outstanding quality cowboy hat.

Cost and Value

Individuals who purchase this type of hat would find it quite appealing. The moment you place your order for the hats, within a week you would have the hats delivered to your residence. These hats are the perfect pick for children’s cowboy theme party session. The hat gives children the impression that they are conquerors just in the same way cowboys showed great strength and attained great things in life.

9. Windy City

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
77.5
 Windy City
Amazon Link
Materials
78.6
Style
77
Brand
77.4
Size
78
best offer for today
Amazon Link
Pros:

Authentic quality

Comfortable

Affordable

Well-designed

Cons:

Limited warranty period

The hat is made with a stylish Mexican design. It helps individuals embrace the culture of the Mexicans in the form of a stylish head costume. The materials used in designing the hat are authentic and it was created with good artistry. In Mexico, it is believed that parties would never be complete without the attendees dressing in their most favorite attires with a Sombrero Hat to complete individuals’ stylish outlook. It is an original product imported directly from Mexico.

Stylish

The hat is made in a unique way as a way of embracing the unique cultural values of the Mexicans. The hat can be used for different tasks. The hat can be an exceptional tool to use in protecting consumers from the hot rays of the sun. It has a very wide brim and a high pointed crown, which leaves plenty of room for the head, features that make it a comfortable costume to have.

Quality Material

The material used in making the hat is durable and made of a material that helps in protecting consumers from the scorching rays of the sun at all times. Some people even use the hat to protect themselves from the hot sun when cutting grass within their compounds.

Cost and Value

Acquiring this hat would give you value for your money since the hat can be used for various functions. The hat can be used for the holidays, as a cowboy outfit for Halloween celebrations or casual wear to help protect your head from the hot rays of the sun. The hat is also very comfortable just as has been outlined earlier. An outfit that can be worn by an entire family unit to give the family members an exceptional outlook.

10. Straw Harvest

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
74.5
 Straw Harvest
Amazon Link
Materials
75.3
Style
75.9
Brand
74.2
Size
74
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$22.99
Pros:

Affordable

Fun costume

Appropriate for different occasions

Cons:

The material used in making it is vulnerable to fold and damage

This cowboy hat is affordable and looks very adorable. When you make your request, the hat would be shipped to your place of residence within the shortest time possible. The hat is convenient when used on different occasions.

Design

The hat comes in assorted colors and designs. This provides consumers with numerous options they could choose from when making a purchase. The different colors make this hat appropriate wear for most dress-ups. The material used in making the hat makes the cowboy hat very easy to clean. The hat also dries up very fast when wet. Such features make it an appropriate choice for the majority of people who opt to look stylish in a hat.

Fun Costume

This cowboy hat is a suitable costume for most fun activities individuals engage in. the hat comes in different shapes and sizes that make it a suitable wear for children as well as adults. All that individuals are required to do is make sure that they try out the different sizes of the hat so that they could find the right fit for them.

Cost and Value

The moment you purchase this hat, it would take you sometime before you decide to buy another cowboy hat. This is because the hat can be used for different occasions without the user feeling out of place in any way. For instance, the hat can be used for giggles, Halloween celebration, and themed parties. The hat fits well with the majority of outfits that individuals may have as part of their cloth collection.

Criteria Used for Evaluation

Materials

Cowboy hats are made from a different material such as leather, wool, fur felt, palm leaf, suede, and straw. The cowboy hats made of wool or the ones made of fur felt are mostly preferred during the winter season and the cool autumn times of the year. However, during the hot summer period, it is advisable that individuals go for the cowboy hats that are made from palm leaf material and straw. The materials used in designing the cowboy hats are unique in many different ways. The materials used in designing cowboy hats have their pros and cons. Therefore, the choice concerning the material that an individual would wish to have as part of the hat’s design is all dependent on the consumer.

Style

The style of the cowboy hat that you would wish to acquire at any point in time is a major factor that should be considered by any consumer. It has been discovered that finding the best style of hat for any consumer is one of the most tedious and time-consuming aspects of hat selection that a consumer can ever be subjected to. The process of selecting a stylish hat requires the consumer to engage in a great deal of thinking. This is because cowboy hats come in a variety of deigns given the numerous manufacturers that come up with these products. The shape of the hat a consumer would select would depend on factors such as the consumer’s current dressing style and most of all the consumer’s taste and preferences.

Brand

The market is flooded with both quality cowboy hats and the cowboy hats that are of reduced quality. In as much as we may rely on the manufacturer’s ratings of the quality of materials used in designing the cowboy hats, the truth is that not all manufacturers provide their consumers with an honest opinion concerning the actual ratings of their products. In fact, there are certain brands of hats that would be denoted as 10 xs when in truth, the material used in making the hat is polyester (which would not have any element of far in it). In the end, a majority of clients may be duped into paying a high price for a low-quality cowboy hat just because of the miscommunication passed on to the final consumers.

Consequentially, if you want the right cowboy hat for you then you should be willing to take your time so that you could select the right brand that would suit your needs. If you decide to purchase a cowboy hat from an online market then it is important that you make sure that read some of the reviews posted by other buyers about the item that you are about to acquire. The reviews would help any consumer easily determine whether the brand they are about to invest in is worth a squeeze of their existing budget.

Size

The moment you spot the cowboy hat that you desire the other most important thing that consumers would be required to do is to select the right size of the hat. Selecting the right size of the hat becomes even much easy in a situation whereby individuals are exposed to different hat brands of different sizes. Placing the hat on the head would enable the user to see whether the hat fits perfectly or not. A good hat would snug perfectly around your head to enable you to experience great comfort when you wear it. The best choice of a hat is one that would not fall off the head when you bow down. Further, the hat should not be too tight or too loose for the consumer as such a feature may be of great inconvenience to the user. Nevertheless, being aware of your head size way in advance makes it easier for you and the workers in a hat store to pick the right fit in the shortest time possible.

Knowing the size of your head is even more important for individuals who opt to purchase a hat from an online shop. You would be able to acquire the right fit without much struggle. A soft measuring tape would be very handy in attaining the measurements of your head. All you would be required to do is to put the tape around the part of the head where the hat inner circle usually sits. You can then measure your head in centimeters and inches.

Expert Interviews & Opinions

Most Important Criteria (According to our experts opinion)
Sort criterias acording to:
Experts Opinion Editors Opinion Users Opinion By Default
Click on a to rate the most important criteria:
#1
ico Materials
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
#2
ico Style
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
#3
ico Brand
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
#4
ico Size
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
expert tips icon
Consider all your options

Numerous types of cowboy hat designs are available on the market at present. This leaves consumers with a wide range of options to choose from when it comes to arriving at the best cowboy hat that would suit their needs. Particular types of cowboy hats can easily be adjusted at the brim to make it a unique product with every consumer or individuals who love having different designs of the same product.

Always consider the quality of your item

It is believed that for a straw cowboy hat, the higher the quantity of Xs the better the quality of the cowboy hat that you are about to buy. Xs, represent the percentage in the quantity of the material used in creating the hat whether it is fur, straw or leather.

Frequently Asked Questions

q: Does the Sombrero Hat have a strap that can be used to secure the hat nicely on the head?

a:

The truth is that most Sombrero Hats do not have a strap that can be used in securing the hat to the head. However, if the consumer deems it fit to have a strap he or she could request the manufacturers to customize the hat by adding a hat strap that can be used in keeping the hat in place at all times.

q: Could the Simplicity kid’s hat be folded for travel?

a:

It is possible to fold this particular hat during times of travel to enable the easy storage of the hat. The wire rim fitted as part of the hat’s design makes it easier for the user to fold and reshape the hat gently back to its original shape.

q: Does the decorative element on the Fun Express hat (plastic star) indicate sheriff or is it just blank? This is because before I made my purchase the logo on the hat indicated sheriff. However, after acquiring the hat, it had no such thing as a sheriff emblem. What is the truth about the product symbol?  

a:

If you ordered the hats that have the word sheriff on the logo then there must have been a mishap during the packaging and shipping process. Otherwise, you would have attained what you ordered just the same way I did.

q: Can a Kids Straw hat perfectly fit the head of a 14-month-old child?

a:

It is possible that the hat would be slightly bigger when fitted on the head of a 14-month-old child. Nevertheless, it should be remembered that the hat is very adorable and it can fit very well on the head of a child when the hat strap is used to fasten the hat. Just make sure that the hat is placed the right way on the child’s head.

Sources

  1. Cutter Streeby, How to Choose a Straw Cowboy Hat,
  2. Editing Team, Buying a Cowboy Hat,
  3. Editing Team, Cowboy Hat Info,