Best Doormats Reviewed & Rated for Quality

The entryway of your home will be the first impression your guests will have of your home. Finding the perfect doormat is not only the best way to protect your floors, it is also a fun way to show your personality and instantly make your foyer look pulled together and organized. A good doormat will also defend against all the debris that could be tracked in from wet shoes and boots, so it is important to consider the mat’s material and size in relation to where you plan to use and display it.

Featured Recommendations

Dog Gone Smart
  • Dog Gone Smart
  • 4.8 out of 5
    Our rating
  • Removes All Types of Debris
  • Price: See Here
ABI Home
  • ABI Home
  • 4.7 out of 5
    Our rating
  • Compact and Decorative
  • Price: See Here
Grassworx Clean Machine
  • Grassworx Clean Machine
  • 4.5 out of 5
    Our rating
  • Cleans Easily
  • Price: See Here
[/srpshortcode

 

10 Best Doormats

 

1. Dog Gone Smart

1. Dog Gone Smart
Well, this doormat is just fun! It is made for all us dog-lovers and has a huge paw print in the center. These mats have a GSM absorption rate of 3000, which is considerably higher than most competitors mats with a GSM rate of 900-1500. In this mat you will get even stitching and double basting which results in increased durability. This is the only dog specific mat that features non skid backing. This doormat comes in a variety of colors, including brown, grey, khaki, maroon, and pacific blue. It is machine washable and dries quickly.
Expand to see more
Runner Size and Regular Doormat Size

Having a size option for different areas in your home is a real perk for this product. It is used primarily as an indoor mat and your dogs will absolutely love it! It is thick and soft with a rubberized bottom to help keep it in place and maintain all types of moisture. The option of different sizes allows you to place these throughout your home.

Removes all Types of Debris

Not only does this adorable mat absorb dirt, mud, sand, and water, it is also great at stopping stickers, foxtails, and even pine needles. The soft material is somewhat sticky and will naturally pull these things from your shoes, and your puppy’s paws as you and they walk across and pause for a moment. The rubber backing makes it water absorbent as well and allows for a non-slip factor to keep that rug in place. This doormat is also well served as a water bowl mat for your dogs. Just place it under your water dish and when those pups drip water all over it will stay in mat instead of all over your floor. Great look and multi-functional. It’s a win win!

Cost and Value

This one costs a little more than some of the others listed here. However, it is quite large, comes in a variety of colors, and is multi-functional. As always, do your research and decide what works best for you. If you are a dog lover and want something that will hold up to a lot of washing due to those dogs, this is a great choice! The paw print adds a little flare and fun and will make you smile every time you see it. The different size options are also a great addition.
Pros

Rubber backing makes it slip-resistant

Paw print is an enjoyable addition

Soft and sticky to attract dogs and remove debris

Variety of color options

Size options for all areas of your home

Cons

Recent change in manufacturing is less than ideal

Paw prints seem randomly placed, not always centered

2. ABI Home

2. ABI Home
It is anti-slip and durable. The rubber back sticks the mat to the floor, giving it cushion and non-slippery quality. One thing I really like about this particular doormat is that it has an anti-bacterial surface. These mats are weather and moisture resistant and can withstand extreme temperatures, therefore stopping bacteria from accumulating on the surface. These are durable and long lasting with the highest quality polypropylene with non-porous and durable rubber backing. Also an easy doormat to clean.
Expand to see more
Durable and Long Lasting

This doormat is made from the highest quality polypropylene with a non-porous and durable rubber backing. It will retain its toughness and texture, making it a great option for outdoor mats because it will continue to capture dirt and debris, despite continued use for hours. It is easy to wash, you’ll just spray water through the fibers and the mat will be clean and dust-free.

Compact and Decorative

This mat is very efficient in a nice, sleek design. It is small enough to fit easily underneath most standard doors, yet big enough to be welcoming. It is designed to collect the dirt, mud, and water left by the shoes and boots that cross over it even though it is surprisingly thin. It has a nice feel under your bare feet and can be used as an indoor or outdoor mat. The design is beautiful and it throws in the extra touch of being anti-microbial.

Cost and Value

It is always nice when the product you see online perfectly matches the product that you actually receive in the mail. It arrives promptly and can be laid flat upon arrival. The size is perfect and the design is lovely. Customer service follow up is exceptional with this company. The doormat is of excellent quality and exceptional value. I would definitely recommend this product and the vendor.
Pros

Anti-slip and durable

Anti-bacterial surface

Low profile design

High quality material is long lasting

Easy to wash

Cons

Initially smells of rubber

Difficult to remove animal hair

3. Grassworx Clean Machine

3. Grassworx Clean Machine
This doormat is best used exclusively outdoors, but can be used indoors as well. It is your classic grassy-looking scraper doormat with triple cleaning action. It can even hold up to a full pound of dirt! This mat is made in the USA and has astroturf scraper blades that really work well at keeping the dirt outside. The color will stay strong, it is resistant to mildew and mold, and stands up well in all weather conditions.
Expand to see more
Clean Machine Scraper

This system of the astroturf type scraper comes with rave reviews! It would seem this mat captures all kinds of dirt, mud, sand, and debris which will keep your home looking much cleaner than other doormats. If you have dogs who love to dig then come in and show you their prizes (and dirty noses), this mat is a must for you! The rugged design is soft enough to not hurt their paws, but stiff enough that they won’t want to pick it up and drag it out on the lawn. This mat will stay put for both humans and their pet friends. It is also great to lay in front of your kitty litter box, as it is a lot less expensive than rugs made specifically for that purpose, but will function just as well! The clean machine scraper design is incredibly efficient but not painful to walk on.

Cleans Easily

Truly, one of the most important aspects of any good doormat is how quickly and easily you can clean it. This one is incredibly easy and will make you want to buy them again and again, for every door in your house! They hold up to one pound of debris per week, which is an incredible amount. Just get in the habit of shaking it out really well once per week and hosing it off every couple of weeks. The astroturf design and color will not fade, so as long as you keep it clean and debris-free this doormat will last you a very long time.

Cost and Value

This doormat is a great purchase! It is very reasonably priced, durable, fade resistant, and effective. You could easily buy one for every entry to your home and save a lot of money in maintaining your floors. It does come in three different colors so you can add a little of your own flare when decorating. It works in all weather conditions so there is no need to change it out for the different seasons it will encounter. It is incredibly easy to clean and will serve a myriad of purposes. If you’re looking for inexpensive and effective all wrapped up in one, this would be the perfect doormat for you!
Pros

Clean machine scraper technology

Holds up to one pound of debris per week

Variety of colors to choose from

Stays in place

Easy to clean

Cons

Plastic/rubber bottom will crack in extreme weather conditions

Does not absorb water well

4. BirdRock Home Welcome

4. BirdRock Home Welcome
This beautiful, welcoming Welcome mat is a front door essential! Guests will feel your warm welcome when this mat graces your entryway. It is made of coconut husks that are incredibly strong and has a vinyl backing which helps it to stay put. The strong bristles wipe away mud, dirt, and snow from your shoes, which effectively works to keep your home that much cleaner. It is also easy to clean - just shake, sweep, or vacuum and it is as good as new!
Expand to see more
Welcome Design with Scroll Border

With Welcome mats, the medium is the message! You want something more than just to wipe your feet on. You want to “welcome” your shoe-wipers from all walks of life, during all seasons. You want inclusion, warmth, and sincerity of an open-door policy. But, let’s all face it, you also need a doormat that is functional, because if it’s just cute and still lets in all the dirt, you have defeated the purpose. This one definitely does both! Made of tough and durable coconut husk and backed with vinyl, this doormat will gather all the debris and still deliver the message: Welcome. Come on in, we are glad you’re here!

Great Shipping Process

Unlike most doormats, this mat does not come folded or even rolled. It is packaged flat, in a large, thin box so you are able to take it right out of the box and lay it on the floor. No need to let it relax in order to lay flat. It arrives quickly, in good condition, and is ready to use. The material is strong and will last for a long time. It comes in the 18”x30” standard size, or the 24”x36” oversized mat, so can be custom ordered to fit any entryway.

Cost and Value

This doormat is very cost effective. It is made of high-quality materials, heavy duty, and durable. It can be custom ordered to say a variety of things so you can bring a smile to your visitors before you even open the door. It gathers the debris and is easy to clean, so you are definitely getting your dollar’s worth with this mat.
Pros

Variety of sayings on your welcome doormat

Holds a lot of debris

Heavy and durable COIR material

Vinyl backing holds it in place

Cons

Lettering wears off quickly

Coconut husk does have a tendency to shed

5. SlipToGrip Universal

5. SlipToGrip Universal
This doormat that has an exclusive plaid duraloop design that will look great in any home! It is anti-slip and durable, has a weatherproof surface and is easy to clean. This one is a little larger than some, so make sure you check the area you are planning to put it. This one measures at 42 inches by 36 inches. Made of soft polypropylene fiber which is waterproof and moisture resistant.
Expand to see more
Color Selection

I really do like to be able to choose a color for my liking! This doormat does come in three neutral colors - black, brown, beige, and gray. Whether you use it inside or outside, I always enjoy being able to splash a little of my personality through the color of the mat. It is soft on your bare feet but still scrubby enough to catch the dirt, making it nice to wipe your feet.

Duraloop Design

The Duraloop design gives this rug a unique look that will look great anywhere. This mat is thin enough to use anywhere and will not get stuck underneath your door. You can use it on your patio, in the garage, in the laundry room, or in your entryway. It provides a good cushion and is non-slip at its finest. It will capture the debris tracked inside and is moisture resistant. The duraloop design makes it easy to wash and durable enough to last for years.

Cost and Value

You definitely get your money’s worth with this doormat! It is a good looking doormat that is versatile and can be used indoors or outdoors and will complement any room in your home that just needs a little flare. It is great for shoes, boots, and even muddy paws as your dog comes barreling through the door! It is stiff enough to capture the debris and moisture, but soft enough to walk on with bare feet. This is a nice mat that is cost effective and will serve its purpose.
Pros

Duraloop design to retain moisture

Variety of neutral colors

Appealing to the eye

Durable for outdoors/Soft for indoors

Thin design will not get stuck underneath your door

Cons

More rubbery than it appears in the picture

Folded during packaging makes it hard to lay flat at first

6. California Home

6. California Home
This rug is sure to keep your floor clean with the ribbed polyester. It functions well to remove dirt and mud from your shoes in addition to absorbing moisture. The non slip back is made of a heavy duty rubber that keeps it where you want it to be and it offers great protection from rain or snow by stopping water seepage.
Expand to see more
Easy to Clean

It is reusable and easy to clean, much thanks to the polyester’s durable nature. All you need to do to clean this mat is shake, vacuum, or sweep it off and if needed, clean it further with the hose and then let it dry. The fabric is strong, doesn't fade, and will withstand even extreme weather. It will make a perfect mat for all of your shoes, both inside and out.

Sturdy Design

This mat is nice and thin and door easily open and shut over it. It works well for home or businesses even with the heaviest of traffic. The polyester makes it incredibly durable and easy to clean. Color won't face and the fabric will last for years. It is biodegradable and made of recycled rubber and recycled plastic.


Cost and Value

This is an excellent pack of doormats for the price. They are durable and long lasting, made of recycled and biodegradable material, and easy to clean. Not only that, but you can also benefit from a lifetime guarantee thanks to the manufacturer. You can reach out to them with anything you need and they will help settle your concerns.
Pros

Made of recycled material

Versatile Utility mat

Heavy duty non slip rubber backing

Lifetime warranty

Cons

Available only in black and gray

Corners tend to flip up

7. Iron Gate

7. Iron Gate
The Iron Gate Gatekeeper doormat has a few color selections, all of which come with a rubber black border. It has a raised ridge water dam design, which captures debris and water. It also minimizes the risk of slip and damage to the floor. The ridged design helps it to store moisture and dirt below the level of your shoes so it isn’t tracked in by the next person to come through your door. It is easy to clean thanks to the rubber backing which also happens to be made of recycled material.
Expand to see more
Raised Rubber Water Dam Design

This water dam design shows the rubber edging of the doormat to be slightly raised from the rest of the mat. This way dirt, debris, and water are all stuck inside the doormat itself. The ridged design of the doormat also helps to contain all of the things that get scraped off your shoes and onto the doormat, beneath your shoe level. They are very easy to clean and will serve their purpose most effectively when they are clean, so remember to take the time to do that!

Variety of Options

Alright, so back to the fact that I really like to be able to choose my color! This doormat does come in a variety of colors to choose from, and you can also choose from a selection of welcome type phrases on the rug. This doormat is also thick and somewhat heavy, which helps it maintain its grip on the floor and not move around. It comes in several sizes so you can also choose different locations inside and outside your home where you would like this mat to be.

Cost and Value

These are great quality doormats and live up to all they claim. They capture dirt and debris quickly, hold water, stay in place, and can either blend in or stand out, depending on your color choice. They come wrapped very tightly in shipping so take a little while to flatten, but the quality will be more than you’re hoping for and will last for a really long time. For the reasonable price, you’ll pay for this doormat, I am quite sure you can’t find a better deal!
Pros

Raised rubber edge Water Dam design

Heavy and thick to maintain its place

Easy to clean

Variety of colors and phrase options

Excellent floor protection

Cons

Wrapped tightly in packaging

Need to be cleaned regularly

8. Handwoven Extra Thick

8. Handwoven Extra Thick
These doormats are extra thick for increased durability, biodegradable, compostable and come in many unique designs that will captivate your guests, show off your own personal flare, and create an elegant entrance to your home. On top of all that, they are remarkably easy to clean!
Expand to see more
Unique Designs

When you research this doormat on your own, you will find over 30 (30!) design options! There are several different color options and say things like: Home, Hello, Faith, Hey Ya’ll, OMG, or have different designs, beach prints, floral designs, a crab, a picket fence, and on and on. I just love being able to have so many choices! They are all extra thick mats for increased durability. Water based pigment paint is used in the design and these mats are all a handwoven construction, biodegradable, and compostable.

Easy to Clean

One of the most important aspects of a quality doormat is that you can clean it quickly and easily. You want your doormat to retain water, but you also need to remember to empty the water on a regular basis in order to maintain the vibrant colors and dirt collecting design. To clean this rug, just scrape the dirt and mud off with a brush and then you can pick it up, shake it, and drain out the water quite easily.

Cost and Value

The price on this doormat is quite economical, especially when you consider all of the different options. It is extra thick and durable so you will not have to replace it for years to come. The shipping is great and can easily be given as a gift without having to rewrap it. It lays flat upon arrival and is quite a conversation starter! Whatever color or design you choose with this doormat option, you will not be disappointed.
Pros

Extra thick and water resistant

Incredible selection of color and design

Reasonably priced

Biodegradable and compostable

Cleans easily

Cons

Pictures and designs are not always as pictured

Doormats are thick and will get stuck under your door

9. Bungalow Flooring Waterhog

9. Bungalow Flooring Waterhog
This doormat measures 2 feet wide by 3 feet long, and is ⅜” thick. It is commercial grade, anti-static, quick-drying, and will not harm any type of floor surface. It is safe and skid free on any floor and can be used indoors or outdoors. It can hold an incredible amount of water, with its exclusive “Water Dam” design. It has a ridged geometric design and rubber border to keep water and debris on the mat, not on the floor. It has a polypropylene fiber face that will not mildew or rot. The high quality construction can stand up to extreme elements, and the rubber backing is eco-friendly.
Expand to see more
Variety of Colors

The Waterhog doormat comes in a variety of colors to match your own personal preference. Classic Bluestone, medium gray, and charcoal are nice neutral colors that will match about anything. Dark green, evergreen and khaki/camel colors are a nice switch up that will add a nice accent color to your entryway, inside or out. All of the colors are 100% USA made, premium construction and quality. The rubber backing is eco-friendly, made of 20% recycled SBR rubber.

Exclusive Water Dam Design

This is an excellent mat, especially for coming in out of the rain. The water dam design holds up to 1.5 gallons of water per square yard of fabric! The geometric pattern featured here has a rubber border that helps to keep your floor clean by accumulating both water and debris. They hold up extremely well and clean up nicely. They really don’t show signs of wear, even after years of use. This doormat is not very thick so it lays nice and flat and doesn’t get in the way.

Cost and Value

First impression may lead you to believe this doormat is a little pricey. Do your research, though, and you will find that this doormat actually features a lot of cutting-edge technology that will make your purchase worth every penny! It works well inside or outside, is just the right size and height, holds in all the dirt and moisture and cleans up like a breeze. Really, could you pour a gallon of water on the doormat you use now? Those perks and the fact that you can choose your color make this doormat the one that should be on your doorstep!
Pros

Water Dam Design holds debris and water

Match your color preference

Cleans easily

Will look brand new for years

Cons

A little pricey for a doormat

Maybe a little small for some wider entry ways

10. DII Modern

10. DII Modern
You can be sure to keep the dirt and debris outside with this unique hot mat ridged construction. It helps trap the dirt and moisture to keep floors clean and safe from accidents. This material and design is perfect for wet conditions. The polypropylene fiber hog mats dry quickly and can be used for your entryway, mudroom, laundry room, patio, or garage. To clean, you'll just hose them off with water and hang to dry!
Expand to see more
Variety of Colors

Color matters! What better way to throw out a piece of your personality when guests arrive at your door? This doormat comes in six different colors so you can choose whichever one suits you the best. All of the color options have the hog mat ridged construction which will trap dirt and moisture to keep your floors clean and unscathed.

Perfect for Many Locations

One of the great things about this doormat is that it is not only an incredible asset for your home, but it can also be used commercially, in warehouses, restaurants, office buildings, and various other high traffic industrial locations. It is comfortable enough to be used at home and durable enough to be used in a much more extensive situation. No matter where you choose to lay this rug, it will not let you slip!

Cost and Value

When compared to other, pricier options, I think you will be very pleased with the price of this highly functional doormat. The color is vibrant and it is remarkably easy to clean. It is awesome for hardwood floors and collects the dirt that is tracked in from the outside. It is packaged in a flat box which allows it to be laid out on arrival with no worries of rolling or curling on the edges. It is a quality product, works well, is very sturdy and looks great!
Pros

Water Hog design

Great variety of colors

Easy to clean

Fits under most standard size doors

Anti-slip

Packaged and shipped flat

Cons

Backing will crack if folded

Strong rubber smell

Criteria Used in Choosing the Best Doormats

Where Will This Mat Go?

One of the most important things to consider when choosing your doormat is where you plan to use it.  Will this be an inside or outside mat? If you want one for outside, it is critical that it be weather resistant or it will wear out much too quickly. Rubber is great at handling the elements. There are other materials that also work well outside and come at a lesser price, though you should take your particular climate into consideration. Outdoor mats should also have abrasive surfaces to help scrape dirt and mud off your shoes and a thick bottom really helps it hold up in the weather.

For doormats that you want to put inside, heavy duty is less of a priority and you can go for something more aesthetically pleasing instead of mostly functional. They are mostly made to trap dirt and dust found inside instead of mud and the volume of dirt found outside. Let’s go over a few more things that need to be considered before making your purchase.

Is This Doormat Easy to Clean?

Something that you don’t always think of is cleaning your doormat. Logically, it accumulates all the mud, dirt, moisture, and who knows what else from your shoes so it is going to end up very dirty. As such, you want your doormat to be very easily cleaned. This is even a bigger deal if you are getting a doormat with a pattern as it is likely to be covered sooner rather than later. Designs really only last a couple years outside at best, which may or may not be a problem, but should be in the back of your mind. Inside is a different story – you can get away with a lot more there.

Something else to keep in mind is that a light doormat will get dirty much faster than a dark one. If you keep a very clean house, this may not be an issue, but if you tend to get a little dirty (I’m looking at you parents of both human and animal children) then light may not be the best idea.

The best doormats are easily cleaned by shaking, vacuuming, and maybe even spraying off with the hose. You don’t want it to be much more intense than that because then it just becomes too time-consuming and not worth your effort.

Welcome Your Guests In Style

It is always fun to welcome your guests in style! While you’ll want something to reflect your own personal style, you still need to opt for one made out of a durable material. In a perfect world, your outdoor mat will be an extension of your indoor decor and most are designed that way. However; they have to made specifically for outdoor use so that they will trap all the dirt and debris before it comes in the house. Nobody wants that inside.

Material and Design

There are many different options of material in an outdoor rug. One of the best, in my opinion, is the water dam with ridged contours. This design will scrape the dirt off your shoes and allows it to fall between the ridges below shoe level, so the next person who comes in doesn’t step on your dirt and bring it in the house anyway. This design also holds the water inside the mat so it doesn’t leak all over your entryway. When you have a mat that retains water, it is important to remember that your mat will not drain itself! You will need to take the time to drain the doormat occasionally, especially if you are in a very cold area where it could ice over during the night. For an indoor mat, you will want one with a rubber or vinyl back so that it won’t slip or slide. Acrylic is a great option for the top of the mat because you can simply shake it off or vacuum it to remove the dirt. To best coordinate with the style of the rest of your home, opt for one in the same color scheme just darker. Darker colors will hide the dirt better but still look good.

FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Does this outdoor rug dry easily?

A: It will dry within a couple of hours hanging up in the sunshine.

Q: How does the rubber backing stick to concrete floors?

A: The cleated and rubberized backing will hold in place on various surfaces. You can also apply double-sided tape to the back of your mat to ensure the security of your doormat.

Q: Is this rug abrasive on bare feet?

A: Most outdoor mats are more abrasive than plush. However, most of these mats are not abrasive enough to scratch your bare feet.

Q: How easily can this doormat be cleaned?

A: Most indoor mats can be vacuumed just like any other rug or carpet. Because of the rubber backing on most outdoor mats, you would want to spray it with a hose and a small amount of liquid soap, then just allow it to air dry before laying it back on the ground.

Q: Does the rubber backing smell of petroleum?

A: Your doormat will likely have a minimal smell of rubber upon arrival. Once laid out and allowed to settle the scent will dissipate and have no smell at all.

Q: If I use a robot vacuum on my floor, are these doormats going to stay in place or get stuck with the robot?

A: This will depend on how aggressive your robot vacuum is. In most cases, the anti-slip backing will hold the rug in place through a vacuum.

Sources

  1. Huffington Post, How to Shop For a Good Doormat
  2. WiseGeek, What Should I Consider When Buying a Doormat?
  3. The Rug Seller, Buying Guide
Rockay Calf Sleeves
Next Giveaway draw
Your email is safe with us. Pinky swear
Share:
Enter the giveaway