to top 10 table

Best Throw Rugs Reviewed & Rated for Quality

last updated: Jul 03, 2019

Nothing pulls a room together quite like a throw rug. A space can be filled the floor to ceiling with decor pieces but a nice area rug will make all the difference in making a space feel full, together and comfortable. There are a variety of sizes and designs available on the market today. It is important that the piece not only be attractive and the right size, but also that it is durable.

In a Hurry? The test winner after 4 hrs of research

icon
Safvieh Shag
96.8/100 our score
Materials
98
Effectiveness
97
Durability
98
Style
94
Value
97
Safvieh Shag
Why is it better?

Ultra-soft feeling

Thick

Made of high quality materials

Feels great on the feet

In a Hurry? Editors choice:
Safvieh Shag
Test Winner: Safvieh Shag
Amazon Link
Sorting Options
Materials Effectiveness Durability Style Value By Default
Rank
PictureProduct
Name
Rating
Shops
#1
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
96.8
Materials
98 %
Effectiveness
97 %
Durability
98 %
Style
94 %
Value
97 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (04.06.20)
Amazon Link
$44.24
#2
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
95.8
Materials
97 %
Effectiveness
96 %
Durability
94 %
Style
96 %
Value
96 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (04.06.20)
Amazon Link
$174.46
#3
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
95.6
Materials
95 %
Effectiveness
92 %
Durability
98 %
Style
95 %
Value
98 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (04.06.20)
Amazon Link
$18.92
#4
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
94
Materials
95 %
Effectiveness
94 %
Durability
93 %
Style
93 %
Value
95 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (04.06.20)
Amazon Link
$30.99
#5
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
93.8
Materials
94 %
Effectiveness
92 %
Durability
95 %
Style
97 %
Value
91 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (04.06.20)
Amazon Link
#6
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
93.6
Materials
95 %
Effectiveness
92 %
Durability
96 %
Style
93 %
Value
92 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (04.06.20)
Amazon Link
$14.43
#7
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
92.8
Materials
93 %
Effectiveness
93 %
Durability
95 %
Style
93 %
Value
90 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (04.06.20)
Amazon Link
$51.66
#8
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
92.6
Materials
93 %
Effectiveness
93 %
Durability
92 %
Style
94 %
Value
91 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (04.06.20)
Amazon Link
$17.99
#9
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
92.4
Materials
93 %
Effectiveness
93 %
Durability
95 %
Style
91 %
Value
90 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (04.06.20)
Amazon Link
$76.02
#10
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
91.6
Materials
90 %
Effectiveness
91 %
Durability
90 %
Style
95 %
Value
92 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (04.06.20)
Amazon Link
$35.99

10 Best Throw Rugs

1. Safvieh Shag

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
96.8
Safvieh Shag
Amazon Link
Materials
98
Effectiveness
97
Durability
98
Style
94
Value
97
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$44.24
Pros:

Ultra-soft feeling

Thick

Made of high quality materials

Feels great on the feet

Cons:

Not as soft as more expensive products on the market

Returns are a bit of a hassle

This product is a beautiful California shag product. It is made of power loomed construction and polypropylene pile making it durable and resistant. It is a contemporary design and comes in numerous shades and colours. It is highly rated and comes in vibrant colours, for these reasons, this product is our Editors Choice product.

Versatile
This product is versatile in that it comes in numerous shades and colours, making it easy to fit in any space in any preferred colour.

Durable
It is also made of powered loomed construction and high-density polypropylene making it highly durable, making it ideal for any circumstance including children and animals.

Cost and Value
This product a little higher in price, however, this product is highly rated, durable, modern and offered in numerous colours and sizes, for these reasons this product is worth the cost.

2. Mohawk Home Free Flow

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
95.8
Mohawk Home Free Flow
Amazon Link
Materials
97
Effectiveness
96
Durability
94
Style
96
Value
96
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$174.46
Pros:

Adds a large pop of colour to any room

Stays in place well (little slippage)

Vibrant

High-quality

Cons:

Thinner than expected

Has a strong odour when initially taken out of packaging

This product is a beautiful and vibrant, short piled product. It has a classic patchwork design and offers a tight, cut loop pile. It is made of 100% nylon and is wear dated and offers action backing. It is also made in the United States. It is highly rated and durable, for these reasons this product is our Top 3 products.

Easy-to-clean
This product can be spot cleaned with a mild detergent and can also be cleaned professionally with a steam cleaner.

Durable
This product is constructed with loop cut pile which offers a tighter hold to the fabric and will be able to handle more wear and tear as a result.

Cost and Value
This product is decently priced. It is only offered in one size (13/32 inches in height) but is durable, beautiful and can easily be cleaned. For these reasons, this product is worth the cost.

3. DII Home Essentials

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
95.6
DII Home Essentials
Amazon Link
Materials
95
Effectiveness
92
Durability
98
Style
95
Value
98
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$18.92
Pros:

Made of recycled products (eco-friendly)

Extremely durable

Beautiful in appearance

Good quality

Cons:

They smell bad initially

Due to the unique coloring, the product isn't like the photo

This product is a highly durable denim product from the very popular home essentials line DII. It is offered in numerous colors and designs. It is also offered in numerous sizes. They are also very competitively priced, this is why this product is our best value product.

Durable
This product has no pile at all, it is a woven denim carpet. It is constructed as a rag rug process which is highly durable and ideal for homes with children and pets or in high traffic areas.

Unique
This product is handmade and during the manufacturing process they are hand dyed meaning that each rug is unique and different. So no two rugs will be the same.

Cost and Value
This product is our best value item because it is very competitively priced. It is durable, unique and attractive in design, for all these reasons this product is worth the cost.

4. ACTCUT Shag

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
94
ACTCUT Shag
Amazon Link
Materials
95
Effectiveness
94
Durability
93
Style
93
Value
95
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$30.99
Pros:

Very soft

Ideal for 'tummy time' with babies

No chemical smell

Well priced

Cons:

Photos and actual photos can be a little different

Doesn't lay completely flat on the floor (corners can curve up a bit on flat floors)

This product is ideal for the bedroom as it ultra-thick and fluffy. It is offered in three different sizes and numerous colors including sweet pinks and purples, ideal for a children's room. It is made of a synthetic material and is easy to clean.

Ideal for children
This product is extra soft and cushioned. It also is offered in tons of fun colours and is machine washable. It is a perfect addition to any children's room.

Anti-slip
This product has an anti-slip grip underlay attached. It will keep the product in place, even on slippery surfaces, for a safer grip and less need for readjustments.

Cost and Value
This product is reasonably priced. It is ultra-soft and ultra-thick. It is also has the unique no-slip feature. For these reasons this product is worth the already reasonable price.

5. HAOCOO Faux Sheepskin

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
93.8
HAOCOO Faux Sheepskin
Amazon Link
Materials
94
Effectiveness
92
Durability
95
Style
97
Value
91
best offer for today
Amazon Link
Pros:

Hypoallergenic

Super soft and thick

Affordable

Machine washable

Cons:

Sheds a little bit

Does feel synthetic

This product is a little more unique in that it is not a traditional square rug. It is made of a faux fur and sheepskin. It is a beautiful ivory white color and is only offered in one color (2 feet by 3 feet). It is also shaped as though it is a real hide.

Versatile
This product can be used either on the floor or on furniture. It is perfect as a decor piece or for animals to cuddle up on.

Eco-friendly
It is made of eco-friendly materials and looks like the real thing but no animals were hurt in the process while still being so real feeling.

Cost and Value
This product is mid-range in price. It is unique in that it looks like a fur hide (in shape and texture). It is also made of non-toxic materials and is hypoallergenic. For these reasons, this product is worth the cost.

6. Maples Accent

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
93.6
Maples Accent
Amazon Link
Materials
95
Effectiveness
92
Durability
96
Style
93
Value
92
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$14.43
Pros:

Modern desgin

Perfect for entryway

Durable construction

Lightweight

Cons:

Colors are different than photo (a little more faded)

Some shape issues (one side is a little curved in some of them)

This product is an accent rug offered by Maples Rugs. It is part of the Reggies Artwork collection which offers unique designs. It comes in four different sizes and is made of 100% nylon and has short piling, meaning that it is quite durable.

Skid-resistant latex backing
This product has a latex backing which will stop the product from sliding around decreasing any accidents or having to move it back into place.

Machine washable
This product is easy to clean because it is completely machine washable adding convenience.

7. Distressed Persian

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
92.8
Distressed Persian
Amazon Link
Materials
93
Effectiveness
93
Durability
95
Style
93
Value
90
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$51.66
Pros:

Colors are exactly like the website

Lays down flat in less than 24 hours

Soft on the feet

Simple design

Cons:

Can be a little slippery and could use a non-slip lining

Expensive

This product is an incredibly gorgeous product that is offered in 10 different colors and 4 different sizes. It is made in Turkey and is made of high quality polypropylene. It is highly rated by consumers and is short piled, so it is quite durable.

Beautiful and stylish design
This product offers a very modern design often seen in current designer magazines. It is distressed in appearance and every single colour offered is beautiful.

Durable
This product offers a shorter pile meaning that it is a little more durable and can be used in higher traffic areas.

Cost and Value
This product is quite expensive in price. It is gorgeous, stylish and durable. For these reasons this product is worth the cost.

8. LOCHAS Deluxe

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
92.6
LOCHAS Deluxe
Amazon Link
Materials
93
Effectiveness
93
Durability
92
Style
94
Value
91
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$17.99
Pros:

Made of 100% microfiber

Has a 100% leather bottom

Super soft to the touch

Doesn't shed

Cons:

A little slick (may slide a bit)

Edges curve up a bit

This product is another faux fur hide product. It is super soft to the touch and ultra-cozy. It works both as a floor mat as well as a decor piece, draped over a couch or on a lounging chair. It is ideal for cold weather as well as children or animals.

Easy-to-clean
This product is machine washable meaning that it is easy to clean, as well as ideal for children and animals.

Variety
This product is offered in numerous colours and sizes making easy to match with any room.

Cost and Value
This product is very reasonably priced. It is offered in different sizes and colours. It is also extra soft to the touch and easy to clean. For these reasons this product is worth the cost.

9. Ottomanson Contemporary

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
92.4
Ottomanson Contemporary
Amazon Link
Materials
93
Effectiveness
93
Durability
95
Style
91
Value
90
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$76.02
Pros:

Low pile

Elegant design

Skid resistant

Good quality

Cons:

Colors online aren't exactly like the photos

Not soft in feel

his product is contemporary in design. It comes in one design and numerous sizes. It is extremely durable and is ideal for the entry way (as it will absorb liquids and can handle wear and tear from boots). It is made of a premium nylon material and is easy to clean (can be steam cleaned on low heat but is not machine washable).

Non-slip
This product has a rubber backing making it ideal for wood floors. No slip, no accidents and no having to move it back into place.

Stain-resistant
This product is also stain resistant and offers a low fade surface.

Cost and Value
This product mid-range in price. It is offered in numerous sizes making it customizable, is extremely durable and stain resistant. For this reason, this product is worth the cost.

10. Sheepskin Shag

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
91.6
Sheepskin Shag
Amazon Link
Materials
90
Effectiveness
91
Durability
90
Style
95
Value
92
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$35.99
Pros:

Pictures are the same as the actual colour

Fur blends well

Eco-friendly

Catches the sunlight nicely

Cons:

A little thinner than expecting

Sheds a little bit

his product is beautiful in design and offers the faux fur rug and sheepskin bottom. It is offered in one size (3-feet by 5-feet) and one color, a sheeny grey. It is very soft and durable. It is also versatile in that it can be used on the floor as well as as a decor piece on furniture.

High-quality
This product is very attractive in colour. It has a nice shine to it and the grey is surprisingly bright.

Light-weight
This product is quite lightweight, making it easy to carry around, as well as using on furniture.

Cost and Value
This product is mid-range in price. Due to its beautiful appearance and machine washable nature, this product is worth the cost.

Criteria Used for Evaluation

Materials

The materials used are important because this is a piece that is walked on in order to get to another part of the house. Due to this, there will be wear and tear (no matter how light the person is that is stepping on it). The product should be made of durable materials that don’t shed. They should be stitched close together tight enough that there will be no excess coming off the rug when trecked upon. It should also offer a vibrant color that will accent the room and the vibrancy should not fade over time. The bottom of the product should not damage the underlying floor with cheap glues or resins left over from pressing the product to the floor. And ideally, the product doesn’t move around too much when walked on. It should have clean and sealed (by glue or stitching) edges that don’t start fraying over time. This will make the product look old and used. The material should also be able to be cleaned with relative ease. Remember, that no matter how clean one’s house is, there will be dirt, debris, and food that track onto the carpet over time and the carpet will need to be cleaned from time to time. This is usually done with a steam cleaner so the material should be able to withstand heat and water. The material, especially when shag, shouldn’t alter when under those conditions. Overall, the materials will be the difference between being happy with your purchase and being dissatisfied with it. This product isn’t the cheapest, so you want to be happy for a long time with it.

Effectiveness

The construction of this product matters because if the construction of the product is poor then the product will start to fall apart and cause frustrations. Construction goes hand in hand with materials used because even with the best materials, if the product is not put together well, the materials will not even matter. The carpet should offer a snug fit to each and every piece of fabric coming out of it. It should also be properly sealed at both the base, as well as the edges. The edges are typically sealed with overlapping stitching, done with heavier thread. The thread should be thick and made of quality materials. It should be gone over several times in order to ensure that if one stitch breaks, the entire threading doesn’t fall apart. The base of the carpet is often times sealed with a chemical, resin or glue. This product should be high-quality liquid and should not be too tacky (unless meant to keep the carpet in place) and should steal the base of the product all together. These chemicals should not leave any residue on the floor either which could cause long-term damage to the underlying floor. This could cost a bit to fix. The construction will ensure that no stray strings or fabrics track off the product and ensure that the product looks newer longer. It will also ensure that the product stays together with time, wear and tear, and cleaning. For these reasons, and for the buyer’s satisfaction levels, the construction of the product is very important.

Durability

The durability goes hand in hand with the materials used and the construction of the product. Overall, the product needs to be durable. In a home, there are children, pets, and dirty feet. This product is usually placed in areas of high traffic like in front of the couch or by the kitchen sink. The kitchen and the living room are the most popular areas of the home for both residents and visitors. In these areas, there is also usually food. Food brings people together but it also makes a mess. As a result, you see the carpet attract all sorts of debris. Even when something is stick to a foot, a rug will take it off before hardwood does. Overall, this product is going to get dirty. The best and easiest way to clean a product like this (discussed more below) is to steam clean it. However, if the product is not made of good materials or is constructed well, the product may fall apart in that kind of heat and moisture exposure. Additionally, with feet walking across the product, it will wear down quite rapidly. If the product is durable then it will last longer and stay newer looking longer as well which will ultimately dictate whether or not the buyer is happy with their purchase long term. It will also cost more to replace them more frequently (this is where quality over price comes into play, also discussed below). Ensure that the product you are purchasing is durable and well-made, otherwise, this product is going to be frustrating down the road.

Style

The style of this type of product is important because it will satisfy the buyer, help the room and dictate the price. The style is based on the person buying it and the style of their home. It could match with everything with the room or maybe it contrasts for the purpose of adding a pop of color. This type of product comes in numerous textures including short pile, long pile (shag), faux fur and even harder ones like plastic and bamboo. The material used should fit the room but also those in the room. If there is a home with animals, even if a pure white faux fur is desired, it might not be ideal for if there are new puppies in the home. Something in a higher traffic area may want to be a little shorter in pile as the shorter the pile the less chance of breakdown of the fibers. Another item to consider is the size of the product being purchased. This type of product usually comes in a wide range of sizes. The space it is going into should be measured and the product should match up as close as possible. A rug that is too small will look silly and one that is too big may not fit. Overall, the style of the product and its intended purpose always needs to be considered in order to get the most out of the product for the best price. This will also help with consumer satisfaction with the product and improve the space it is going into.

Value

The price of this type of product is important for a couple of reasons. First of all, this type of product is on the more expensive side in general. The larger they are the more drastic of a price jump you see. For this reason, the price does need to be taken into consideration. Typically with this type of purchase price does dictate the quality of the product. You’ll click the link to each product and see a price gap. This is due to size. If comparing products of similar sizes, you do typically see (if with reputable and fair manufacturer) competitive pricing. The prices do change with the type of each though, as more materials, softer materials, more durable materials, they will cost more. It is important that the item you are buying is that price for a reason. First, consider its size. Ensure that it is competitive with others in the market, then compare the materials used and the products reviews. If they are all in line then the purchase makes sense. You definitely don’t want to overspend, and this is where non-reputable companies may attempt to make too much on a particular item. This type of product is incredibly frustrating to shop for because they really do end up all over the place in regards to the pricing of each. The item should be the right size, made of high-quality materials, should hold together for extended periods of time, should be used in the right areas and should be easy to clean. Consider all these factors before making your next purchase.

Expert Interviews & Opinions

Most Important Criteria (According to our experts opinion)
Sort criterias acording to:
Experts Opinion Editors Opinion Users Opinion By Default
Click on a to rate the most important criteria:
#1
Materials
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
#2
Effectiveness
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
#3
Durability
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
#4
Style
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
#5
Value
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
expert tips icon
The product should not only fit your style, but should durable and easy to clean.

There are numerous products on the market though, and interior design is a huge, profitable industry meaning that it could be hard to know if the product you are purchasing is the right one for you. This article gets a little more into that.

Other Factors to Consider

Bottom Line

As discussed above, this product, no matter how well it is taken care of, will need to be cleaned. The product bought should be able to withstand the cleaning process without falling apart or altering the feel of the product. It also shouldn’t shrink or warp the shape of the product. Spot cleaning is available to anyone with this type of product but eventually, a full cleaning is going to need to be done and this is typically done with steam cleaning. It should be able to cleaned without any issues and without having to go to extreme measures and costs to do so. Ensure that the product being purchased can handle ongoing maintenance and that is not going to cost too much in order to do it.

Brand

The manufacturer of a product is important because this will also dictate the value of the product. A manufacturer should have a good reputation for the quality of the product as well as customer service. If their reputation is regularly about the quality and poor durability of their products then think twice about shopping with them unless their return policy and warranty policy is good. If the customer service is poor then those returns and warranty claims could be a huge, frustrating hassle. The company should also be well-established. All companies will have complaints, no company is without its faults and some people having a bad day could exaggerate their issues with the company. That said, the company will need to work out some kinks with their product and their team. This will sort itself over time. If a company is producing a bad product and have poor customer service then the company probably will not last over 10 years. Consider looking for a company with around 10 years of experience to really know if the company is going to withstand another 10. Around this time they should have worked out their issues and started to produce a better product and hired proper, helpful staff. It also doesn’t hurt to shop locally for the environment, as well as the community, but also because local manufacturers may have first-hand experience of the general demographic and environment and produce a product that is better suited for you. This isn’t always true but it increases the chances. Plus, returns are easier and shipping is probably faster and cheaper for the purchase and any potential returns. Always consider purchasing a product that is made by a reputable company with a good track record before buying this type of product.

Frequently Asked Questions

q: How is this type of product washed?

a:

It depends on the product. Some can be washed in the washing machine- typically on low heat (or warm, not hot, water) and should be laid flat to dry. Others should be steam cleaned rather than machine washed and should be done on the lowest temperature. Others require professional cleaning. It is wise to reference the manufacturers website. When there are little stains here and there it will help t o use spot removers, specific to carpets. Using soap and water first is advised though. This will help keep the carpet clean, as well as prolong the life of this product.

q: How can I extend the life of this product?

a:

Regular maintenance will go a long way with this product. As mentioned above, spot cleaning rather than full washing will help extend the life of this product. Regular vacuuming will also help keep this product in the best condition. With more vibrant colors, consider keeping this product out of direct sunlight as it will bleach the color (potentially blotchy if not full y submerged in light or if there is something on top of the product). These little things can help prolong the life of the product, as well as keep it looking new looking longer.

q: How do I know what size I need?

a:

Measuring out the area is the best way to figure it out. Measure the area with a measuring tape to find the closest size. When measuring the area the product does not need to go against the wall or to the back of the couch (if in a living area), it can also sit at the front feet of the couch. Consider consulting decor magazines beforehand to ensure that the product fits in the space in the most efficient and attractive way.

q: Are they hypoallergenic?

a:

They aren’t all hypoallergenic, no. This can be figured out based on the materials used. Usually lower piled products are better for allergies. Consult the website to find out what type of materials are used. Wool is a common material used for this type of product and is hypoallergenic. Other materials that are are silk, cotton, sisal, animal skins and some other synthetic materials. It is wise to check the manufacturers website before purchasing this product to see if it falls in all of these categories.

q: Can it be used with animals?

a:

Some products can be used with animals depending on the product. It is important that the product is easily cleanable. No matter how clean the floors in the house are animals do walk outside without shoes. They are also prone to accidents. For these reasons, this product needs to be machine washable in order to keep it in the best condition. Anything with lower pile, as well, is ideal as it will be able to handle the wear and tear of little ones and animals. The issue with lower pile rugs is that they are less likely to be machine washable and may require professional cleaning. This isn’t ideal for little ones and animals.

q: Are there stain-resistant products?

a:

Some are stain resistant, these are usually the products that are meant for the door. It is usually products that are not soft and tend to be made of plastics and have a chemical treatment. This is ideal for areas of high traffic with heavy shoes. It is wise to double check with the manufacturer’s website beforehand as this is not a frequent feature in this type of product, unfortunately.