Best Casserole Dishes Reviewed & Rated for Quality
Criteria Used for Evaluation
It is important to read the instructions that come with your product before sticking it in the freezer straight out of the oven or putting a cold pan in the oven straight from the freezer. Most of the pans in this buying guide can do both, but you need to make sure before you try it.
This concludes our buying guide on the best 10 casserole dishes on the market today. Take your time, do your research and make sure that you have at least a few of these in your kitchen at all times. Happy cooking everyone!
As a home cook or chef, you already know that the meals you create come in different shapes and sizes, so they bakeware you use to cook them should as well. Your best bet is to have several types in different shapes and sizes. Your standard set of bakeware should include a 2-quart square, 2-quart round, and a 3-quart rectangular, in this way all of your bases are covered. The top-rated on our list come in all of these sizes, shapes, and much more.
These products come in a variety of styles and colors to choose from. Many can also go straight from the oven to the freezer or to the table for serving purposes. Our top-rated come in a variety of vivid colors and often unique shapes as well. Whether it’s leaves yellow or a vivid red, there are plenty of color choices, you can choose from to match your kitchen decor or just to look pretty sitting on the table.
The one thing you can’t forget when searching for the perfect casserole dishes is the price. The top-rated in this buying guide range from simple elegance at around $10 to unique, full depth, and colorful at close to $100. The thing to remember is that you should choose based on the functionality of the dish, not the price. If the dish is durable, does what you need it too and is safe to use, it doesn’t matter what the price tag says.
This sums up our criteria section for the best casserole dishes on the market today. Whether you need a ramekin for individual desserts or a large roaster for lasagna for the annual neighborhood potluck, these are the criteria and metrics you should be looking for. The best bakeware is the one that is functional, durable, safe, and can go from the oven to the table or into the container to be transported with ease. Add in the fact that many of the top-rated are dishwasher safe for easy cleanup and you have quite a list from which to choose the best ones to put in your kitchen.
10 Best Casserole Dishes
1. Cuisinart CI670-30CR
It's truly no surprise that Cuisinart landed at the top of this top 10 list. Made of cast iron, this round dish comes in your choice of two vibrant colors, blue or red, this item is perfect for those small meals, such as a small chicken noodle casserole for just a few of you. It is 7-quarts and comes with a porcelain enamel lid that makes the pan perfect for heat retention. The product also features wide, easy to grab handles for ease of transport from the oven to the table.
Easy to Clean
This product is worth its weight in gold in the kitchen, just because it's easy to clean after cooking your favorite meal. The dishwasher-safe product means no more scrubbing when it comes to cleaning up. The product also features an oven-safe knob on the lid, making it easy to grip and perfect for cooking on everything from an induction stove to putting under a broiler.
Features Cast Iron Construction
Since this item has a sturdy cast iron construction, it provides perfect heat retention and even heat distribution, making for even cooking of your favorite dishes. The elegance of this round pan makes entertaining, cooking, and clean up a breeze.
Cost and Value
For baking, roasting, and even serving your favorite dishes, this product can't be beaten. The brand name itself is enough to make it affordable and every chef needs a cast iron casserole dish in their kitchen, wouldn't you think?
2. Pyrex Portable
There is nothing like packing up creations you made and taking them to a friends house for dinner or a party. Pyrex makes that easy with their portables glass bakeware and food storage set. The combo features four pieces, a 3-qt oblong baking pan, a red lid to cover your green bean casserole, a black carrier, and a hot or cold insert to keep it just the right temperature. From the oven to the carrier, and to your dinner party is accomplished with ease with this product.
If you have ever burned yourself grabbing a pan out of the oven, because there were no handles, then you will certainly appreciate the easy grab, wide handles on this product. It's easy to take the pan from the oven, with oven mitts of course, and deposit it on the counter to cool.
Features a Black, Portable Bag
There is nothing much worse than getting a fragrant meal to a party, only to find it's cold as ice, or even worse, having the entire dish spill into the back seat of your car, because it wasn't secure and you took a corner too fast. You don't have to worry about either of those things with the black portable bag and hot/cold unipack that comes with this set. The bag is temperature controlled and with the unipack, you are almost guaranteed to get your food to the party unscathed, piping hot, and ready to eat!
Cost and Value
This set comes not only with the pan to cook your favorite foods in, but a portable bag to tote it in and a unipack to keep it hot or cold, whichever the case may be. It's dishwasher safe for easy cleanup, durable, and won't warp, stain, or retain the smells and flavors of the food that is cooked in it. All of this combined, with the red lid, of course, makes this set well worth the amount of money asked for it.
3. Bruntmor Self-Basting
The Bruntmor dutch oven is a round enameled cast iron casserole dish that is perfect for cooking everything from stews to shepherds pie in on those cold, snowy winter nights. Its 6.5-quart capacity makes it perfect for entertaining at those family gatherings or whenever you have friends over. The cast iron material of the product ensures that heat stays inside the pot where it belongs, meaning you can save on your energy bill by cooking at a lower temperature than with most baking pans. It is durable, heavy duty, and high quality, the perfect dutch oven to cook everything from stews to pot roasts, and from bread to a small chicken.
Features Self-Basting Condensation Ridges
The days of having to pull the food out of the oven and let out the heat, because you have to baste the roasted chicken to keep it from drying out are long gone with this product. It features self-basting condensation ridges on the lid, so when condensation builds up, the lid directs the juices back into your food. This ensures that your meals are always savory and moist, something your family will love.
Available in 4 Colors
Not only is this dutch oven durable and heavy-duty, it comes in four vibrant colors to match the decor of your kitchen. Choose from your choice of turquoise, olive green, sky blue, or fire red. No matter, the decor in your kitchen, or what your favorite color is, your food can stand out with more than the taste with these vibrant color choices.
Cost and Value
This high-quality, cast iron dutch oven is ideal for cooking all of your favorite dishes, whether it's a casserole for a weeknight dinner or a roasted chicken on Sunday. Just the self-basting condensation ridges alone make this baking pan worth the money. Add in your choice of vibrant colors and this one is a winner for sure.
4. Amazon Basics 4.5-Quart
The Amazon Basics pan is made of enameled cast iron and features loop side handles and a secure fitting lid. It is safe for use on all cooking surfaces, including the BBQ and the oven, making it the perfect addition to any kitchen where the chef is always on the go. It comes in your choice of a vibrant blue or red and holds 6-quarts of your favorite food. This pot will be of great use in your kitchen, whether you are baking, roasting, braising or more.
Oven Safe to 400 Degrees
This product is oven safe for up to 400 degrees, and the cast iron dutch oven ensures the heat stays inside the pot where it belongs for fragrant, moist, and delectable food, you will be proud to serve the family you love.
Safe for All Cooking Surfaces
Whether you are baking a casserole, fixing a fragrant beef stew, or whipping something up to BBQ on the grill, this product is safe to use on all cooking surfaces. You can also serve and store the food in this versatile Dutch oven, making it a must-have for any kitchen.
Cost and Value
With its securely fitting lid and versatile usage, it's no wonder this baking pan made it onto our list. Perfect for everything from simmering to braising, this should be a must-have gift for anyone who loves being in the kitchen, and well worth every penny.
5. Rachael Ray 2-3/4-Quart
This 4.25 quart Rachael Ray stoneware is a unique addition to our list. Its unique shape and colorful design make it a pan that everyone will compliment when you put it on the table, along with the great food inside. It's dishwasher, freezer, and microwave safe, making it an easy pan to use for everything from baking to roasting to storing leftovers. It's oven-safe, up to 500 degrees and features extra wide handle holes for easy grabbing and carrying to the table.
Perfect for Entertaining
No longer do you have to worry about switching food from your baking pan to a serving dish, because you hate the way they look. This product is perfect for entertaining with its bright colors and unique design. Put dinner on the table with pride and expect easy cleanup with this stoneware dish.
This products interior is stain resistant due to the glazed stoneware. This means you don't have to worry about putting foods, such as lasagna in your cookware. This is the perfect stoneware for everything from roasting to braising and much, much more.
Cost and Value
Just the unique, fun shape and the vibrant color are enough to recommend bringing this stoneware into your kitchen. From kitchen to table, then to freezer, this is well worth the money you will spend to own one, or even more than one.
6. Emile Henry Baker, 13 x 9
If you are looking for classic style in your baking dish, then the Emile Henry rectangular baker is just what you need in your kitchen. The baker comes in your choice of five different colors. Those colors are leaves yellow, which would be perfect for those savory fall recipes you love, rogue red, spring green, sugar white, and twilight blue. These bakers have been made in France since 1850 and are made of all natural materials. They are also durable, scratch resistant and dishwasher safe, something everyone wants in a rectangular baking pan.
Resists Temperature Change
One of the best things about this baker is that it is resistant to temperature change. In other words, it can go directly from your oven to your freezer or from the freezer to the hot oven. It also looks gorgeous on the table when you're serving your family as well. This baker is safe up to 520 degrees Fahrenheit as well.
This high fired burgundy clay dish is scratch resistant, as well as being dishwasher safe for easy cleanup. The extremely hard glaze surface of the baker makes it resistant to any scratches, and also makes it durable enough to be used in the kitchen every day, to make the meals you love.
Cost and Value
One of the more expensive products on our list, the durability and scratch resistance of this product makes it well worth the price. The vivid color choices make it perfect to take from the oven to the dining room table to serve guests and the temperature change resistance the baker offers is an added bonus that can't be denied.
7. Mason Cash
If you’re searching for a sleek and elegant casserole dish that gets the job done without all the frills and fuss this is the one for you. Measuring at 8-1/4-inches in diameter, and 5-3/4-inches in height, this dish can hold up to 2-1/2-quarts of food allowing you to have a deep casserole dish for large gatherings. Constructed out of high-quality chip resistant stoneware this dish is not only aesthetically pleasing but it was created with the everyday consumer in mind
While this is marketed as a casserole dish it can be used for multiple different purposes including roasting vegetables, multiple large casserole dishes, lasagna, and even desserts. Being able to cook multiple dishes in this one-pot allows you to use it as often as possible and even on a daily basis.
When it comes to cooking and serving a meal convenience is key. With this being said, this casserole dish is extremely convenient when it comes to how it is cleaned and used. This dish is microwave, freezer, dishwasher, and conventional oven safe; therefore, you can use it and wash it in any manner that suits you.
Cost and Value
Featuring an aesthetically pleasing exterior and multifunctional ability, the cost of this casserole dish is actually quite cost-effective. Furthermore, it can be used as a display item or a family heirloom.
8. CorningWare French
If you remember the casserole dishes your mom and grandmother used, then you may already be familiar with the white round dish with the lid included. This is 1.5-quarts and is perfect for any side food you make to go around a meal. It's pretty enough to be set on the table for serving and is both versatile and stylish at the same time. It's made of a durable stoneware material that resists chipping and cracking and is easy to clean.
These are the dishes that used to grace your grandmother's table during Sunday dinner, now they can grace yours as well. This product has a traditional, yet timeless, elegance that screams green bean casserole all day long.
Includes a Lid
This product includes a lid that is oven safe and fits over the pan securely. Many recipes call for food to be covered during cooking and putting leftovers in the fridge requires a lid as well. This set has you covered in both departments.
Cost and Value
One of the less expensive items on the list, this product has years of being good cookware to back it. This traditional pan with lid is worth every penny, for the good food it produces and the memories it conjures for many of us.
9. Le Creuset Stoneware
It comes as no surprise that the Le Creuset stoneware ended up on our top 10 list. This product comes with a lid and is 12.5 x 8.5 inches, making it perfect for those small recipes you like to make. It features unmatched thermal resistance and an exterior enamel that makes it resistant to scratches. This product is durable and it's nearly non-stick glazing makes cleanup quick and easy after a meal. You can take it from oven to freezer of to the table, whatever the occasion warrants.
Maintains Even Temperatures
Because this product is made out of durable stoneware materials, it distributes heat evenly, so your food cooks the way it's supposed to without burning or scorching. This in itself makes this product well worth the money spent to purchase it.
This product can be taken from the oven to the table as it is perfect for entertaining as well as cooking your favorite foods. Whether it's an apple cobbler or a fall feast, this is the cookware you need to entertain and serve food in for your family and friends.
Cost and Value
One of the higher end products on the list, the name itself recommends this item.
10. Libbey Baker's Basics
Why bake one casserole when you can bake three? This 3-piece glass casserole set by Libbey Baker's Basics allows you to do just that. Featuring 1-quart round glass casserole with glass cover, a 2-quart round glass casserole with glass cover; and a 3.2-quart round glass casserole with glass cover all conveniently stackable so they can be stored away easily and quickly. Furthermore, this collection is lead-free and completely made out of glass.
While most glass kitchen items might seem intimidating due to how easily they can be shattered if placed in a non-convenient place, these casserole dishes are quite durable. The glass they’re constructed out of is thicker then most for that classic durability yet its crystal clear, so you are able to monitor it from the outside while your dish bakes.
Cooking is always a good idea, but the cleanup always seems to be a different story, which is where glass appliances and dishes come in handing. One of the greatest aspects of glass is that it is traditionally easier to clean, and this set proves just that. This three-piece set is made of high-quality, durable glass that is a breeze to clean, even when food has been caked on.
Cost and Value
Keeping in mind that you are receiving a three-piece high-quality glass set, this casserole collection is quite the bargain. Furthermore, having more than one casserole dish allows you to bake a few dishes beforehand and have them in the freezer until it is time to be used, allowing you to save time and effort.