Best Cast Iron Pots Reviewed & Rated for Quality

In a Hurry? Editors choice:
Lodge Enameled Dutch Oven
Test Winner: Lodge Enameled Dutch Oven
Amazon Link
When you think cast iron, you may think of old-timey kitchens and super heavy cookware. But don’t be fooled into thinking these are an antiquated cooking item that no longer has a place in the modern kitchen.

Every serious cook needs to have a few good cast iron pots and pans in their arsenal. But why?

For one, cast iron can be pulled from the stove and put in the oven without a thought. They can also add necessary iron into your food which is great for your diet. Plus, they add incredible seasoning to food, and to top it off, they last forever.

So don’t let the size and weight of these incredible cookwares scare you away. We’ve gathered the best cast iron cook pots on the market today so you can up your perfectly seasoned cooking game and impress your friends and family.

Standout Picks

Lodge Enameled Dutch Oven
The Lodge Enameled Dutch Oven is one of the best cast iron pots with lid on the market today. It comes in multiple different sizes and colors so it can take on any of your kitchen’s needs. This product is easy to clean and can sustain temperatures up to 500 degrees Fahrenheit so it’s good for most jobs. It weighs in at 16 pounds.
Amazon Link
$79.90
Landhaus Enameled Dutch Oven
The Landhaus Enameled Dutch Oven is the most premium item on our list but it is worth the extra bucks. It boasts 4 layers of enamel coating so you will get an even heat like no other and you can be sure that your food won’t stick to the bottom of the pot. And you’ll enjoy so many different size and color options.
Amazon Link
$99.99
Cuisinart Chef's Classic Enameled
The Cuisinart Chef's Classic Enameled is an incredibly versatile cooking item that can serve as a pot or as a casserole dish. It can go in the oven or the stovetop and it is even certified dishwasher safe. With tons of colors and sizes to choose from, getting the right dish for your kitchen will be a breeze.
Amazon Link
$119.00
Lodge Pre-Seasoned Dutch Oven
The Lodge Pre-Seasoned Dutch Oven is one of the best black cast iron pots on the market. Not only is it one of the most durable products out there, but it is super versatile and can play well on the campfire and on the stove. Plus, it comes pre-seasoned and ready to cook delicious and memorable meals.
Amazon Link
$69.90
Bruntmor Pre-Seasoned 2 In 1
The Bruntmor Pre-Seasoned 2 In 1 is the first on our list to double as a pot and a skillet. Yes! You heard right. The lid on this product will actually serve as a separate skillet as well so you get twice the amount of cookware for a super low price which is a deal we can really get behind. Plus, it comes preseasoned as well.
Amazon Link
$56.95
AmazonBasics Enameled Dutch Oven
The AmazonBasics Enameled Dutch Oven is quite the looker. It comes in an array of dazzling color and size options so that you can get the best fit for your home. It is enameled on the inside so it will help to keep your food from cooking and it is easier to transport with larger handles for your convenience.
Amazon Link
$50.15
Utopia Kitchen Pre Seasoned
The Utopia Kitchen Pre Seasoned is the most budget friendly and affordable option on our list by far, but don’t let that fool you. If you are looking for an introductory piece or you just want something that’s a little more simple, this could be the perfect fit for you. Plus, it is super lightweight at just around 7 pounds so it’s easier to work with.
Amazon Link
King Kooker Pre-Seasoned
The King Kooker Pre-Seasoned is a great option for open fire cooking, as well as cooking in the home. Buyers are impressed with the pre-seasoning on this product so we give Taste points here. Folks are also impressed with the amount that they can fit inside. This is truly a heavy-duty pot as it weighs in at just over 30 pounds. Handle with care!
Amazon Link
$109.45
Commercial Chef Dutch Oven
The Commercial Chef Dutch Oven is another great option that is super kind to the pocketbook. While being on the very affordable end, it is still thick and pre-seasoned, and provides you with all of the benefits of a more elite cast iron pot. Plus it holds heat so well that it can even double as a warming serving dish so you get more out of its use every time.
Amazon Link
$59.99
Bayou Classic 2.5-Qt. Bean Pot
The Bayou Classic 2.5-Qt. Bean Pot is a smaller pot that will bring a big amount of charming rustic flair to your kitchen. Even though it is small, it weighs in at 9 pounds and can hold up to 2.5 quarts of food. You will have to season this product on your own and you’ll be able to use it for campfire cooking or on your stove at home.
Amazon Link
$33.30

Criteria Used for Evaluation

Ease of Use

When considering products, we took into account how easy they were to use. We determine a product’s Ease of Use score by looking at how easy it is to clean and maintain, whether or not it comes sufficiently preseasoned, how well the lid fits, and what different purposes it can be used for.

We value products that are relatively simple to maintain. We say “relatively” because maintaining cast iron is more involved than with your average cookware--see our Expert Tips section below. The trade-off is more than worth it, though.

We also like a pot that that seals sufficiently and that can be used for multiple different dishes. And, of course, we like when it comes appropriately preseasoned without needing to go through another seasoning process once you pull it out of the box.

Durability

Durability is another key concern of ours. When looking at how durable a product is, we take a look at how well the enamel holds up on the product and at the occurrence or likelihood of rusting.

While all products can be chipped and rust if not properly taken care of, we are looking at the frequency with which this occurs under regular use. We didn't bother including any options on our list that didn't score very well in the Durability category.

Taste

When considering taste, we look at whether or not the pot was preseasoned and how well this process held. We also look at the effect of seasoning (by either yourself or pre) at the overall outcome of meal tastes.

Weight

Because cast iron pots tend to be very heavy, we made sure to list the weights of each product so that you can have a clear idea about what you’re getting yourself into. While you may be thinking that heavier means more durable, this isn’t always the case. So pay attention to our reviews to guide you.

Value

Often times in cookware, it’s worth splurging on the more expensive items as they just hold up better over time. While this isn’t always true, we find that the higher end products on our list really do hold up better, though this still rests partially on you and how you maintain your pot.

10 Best Cast Iron Pots

1. Lodge Enameled Dutch Oven

Where to buy
Amazon Link
$79.90
Lodge Enameled Dutch Oven
Bayou Classic 2.5-Qt. Bean Pot
Amazon Link

The Lodge Enameled Dutch Oven is one of the best cast iron pots with lid on the market today. It comes in multiple different sizes and colors so it can take on any of your kitchen’s needs. This product is easy to clean and can sustain temperatures up to 500 degrees Fahrenheit so it’s good for most jobs. It weighs in at 16 pounds.

Porcelain Enamel
Just as you wouldn’t use any old fillet knife to prepare the perfect fish, you can’t use any old pot to prepare the perfect meal. The Lodge Enameled Dutch Oven is a versatile item that can be used for several jobs around the kitchen.

This product is finished with a porcelain enamel that has been bonded to the cast iron in a process that takes time and heat up to 1400 degrees Fahrenheit. The finished product resists wear and tear and disperses heat super evenly for the perfect cook every time. For these reasons, we score this product super highly in the Durability and Taste categories.

Super Easy to Use
This is one of the easiest products to maintain on our list. It is even safe to go in the dishwasher, though we suggest hand washing in warm water with a detergent that is not citrus based or super abrasive. You should not use metal brushes or pads to clean as this could damage the finish.

We give major points for Ease of Use here, but dock points for taste as washing in this way doesn’t allow for a good seasoning to build up.

Cost and Value
The Lodge Enameled Dutch Oven rings up in the middle of our price range and we love its value because it is one of the easiest pots to use which makes it a great introductory option and because it comes in an array of sizes and colors to choose from.

Amazon Link
$79.90

2. Landhaus Enameled Dutch Oven

Where to buy
Amazon Link
$99.99
Landhaus Enameled Dutch Oven
Amazon Link

The Landhaus Enameled Dutch Oven is the most premium item on our list but it is worth the extra bucks. It boasts 4 layers of enamel coating so you will get an even heat like no other and you can be sure that your food won’t stick to the bottom of the pot. And you’ll enjoy so many different size and color options.

Non-Sticking Interior
The Landhaus Enameled Dutch Oven boasts an incredible non-sticking interior. This product has 4 coats of enamel so that your meal gets heated evenly throughout and will not stick to the bottom. We give this product points in the Ease of Use department and Taste department for this.

We also love that this is great for slow roasting in the oven as well as for stovetop use. It can handle heat up to 450 degrees Fahrenheit.

BPS Free Enamel
The Landhaus features 4 layers of BPA-free enamel, so you know its a product you can rely on for quality in the food safety realm. Plus, this product is that much more durable as a result, so we give Durability points here.

It weighs in at 13 pounds so we give major points in the Weight department and it comes in a variety of colors and sizes.
You cannot put this product in the dishwasher, but it is easy to clean with soap and water.

Cost and Value
The Landhaus rings up at the very top of our price range and we love its value because it has more coats of enamel than other products which makes it more durable and a better even-cooker.

Amazon Link
$99.99

3. Cuisinart Chef's Classic

Where to buy
Amazon Link
$119.00
Cuisinart Chef's Classic Enameled
Amazon Link

The Cuisinart Chef's Classic Enameled is an incredibly versatile cooking item that can serve as a pot or as a casserole dish. It can go in the oven or the stovetop and it is even certified dishwasher safe. With tons of colors and sizes to choose from, getting the right dish for your kitchen will be a breeze.

Larger Handles
The Cuisinart is one heavy-duty product. It weighs in at around 20 pounds, so for most it will be a two-handed job. That’s why it’s so great that it has extra-large handles so that transporting the pot is much easier, even if you are wearing oven mitts. We give points in the Weight department here.

We also like that the lid features an oven-safe knob that won’t melt or warp when exposed to even the most intense broiler temperatures. We give Ease of Use points here as well as points for Durability.

Dishwasher Safe
This pot is finished with enamel on the inside. That means it won’t absorb or transfer old flavors to new dishes. This is ideal for some who cook a variety of different cuisines. We give decent points for Taste here.

It also means that you can put this product in the dishwasher without exposing it to wear and tear. However, you should still ensure that your product is completely dry before storing it. We give Ease of Use points here.

Cost and Value
The Cuisinart rings up on the higher end of our price range and we love its value because it can serve a range of functions in the kitchen and because it comes in so many sizes and colors. Plus, it can be washed in the dishwasher for super easy use.

Amazon Link
$119.00

4. Lodge Pre-Seasoned

Where to buy
Amazon Link
$69.90
Lodge Pre-Seasoned Dutch Oven
Amazon Link

The Lodge Pre-Seasoned Dutch Oven is one of the best black cast iron pots on the market. Not only is it one of the most durable products out there, but it is super versatile and can play well on the campfire and on the stove. Plus, it comes pre-seasoned and ready to cook delicious and memorable meals.

Pre-Seasoned
The Lodge Pre-Seasoned Dutch Oven is just that--pre-seasoned. This product has been seasoned with veggie oil for an initial good flavoring, so we give major points in the Taste category. And, as with most cast irons, the more you use it, the more flavor it will develop and the better your food will taste.

Approved for Campfire
This is a versatile little pot. Because it is not coated in enamel, it is safe to be used on the campfire and at extremely high temperatures around the kitchen. We give points for Ease of Use point for this.

The 5-Quart weighs in at 13 pounds, so we give points in the Weight category as it is not too heavy. This product comes in a few different sizes for you to choose from.

In order to wash, you’ll need to follow the instructions that we provide in the Expert Tips section below. It is not dishwasher safe.

Cost and Value
The Lodge dutch oven rings up on the lower end of our price range and we love its value because it boasts the quality of Lodge that you have come to expect at a price that won’t break the bank. Plus, it is insanely durable and can last a lifetime if you take care of it well, so we give major points for Durability here.

Amazon Link
$69.90

5. Bruntmor Pre-Seasoned 2 In 1

Where to buy
Amazon Link
$56.95
Bruntmor Pre-Seasoned 2 In 1
Amazon Link

The Bruntmor Pre-Seasoned 2 In 1 is the first on our list to double as a pot and a skillet. Yes! You heard right. The lid on this product will actually serve as a separate skillet as well so you get twice the amount of cookware for a super low price which is a deal we can really get behind. Plus, it comes preseasoned as well.

Skillet for Lid
This item comes with 2 pieces of kitchen gear--a pot and a skillet. The lid converts into a skillet for even more versatility in cooking.

We love that both the pot and the skillet lid come with large handles to make maneuvering easier and safer--especially at high temperatures. We give Ease of Use points here.

Domed for Roasts
The Bruntmor is also ideal for roasting as the lid is domed to allow more space on the inside. This product only comes in the one size (5 quarts), but the extra space is an added bonus here. Plus, it is still lightweight at just 13 pounds so we give Weight points for this.

This product does come preseasoned, though some were not so thrilled with the seasoning and suggested reseasoning yourself. Remember to season both the lid and the pot if you plan on using the lid as a skillet. We take some points for taste here.

Cost and Value
The Bruntmor Pre-Seasoned 2 In 1 rings up towards the bottom of our price range and we love its value because it doubles as a two in one product so you can get twice as much use out of it. Plus, it can last for ages if taken care of properly so we give major Durability points here.

Amazon Link
$56.95

6. AmazonBasics Enameled Dutch Oven

Where to buy
Amazon Link
$50.15
AmazonBasics Enameled Dutch Oven
Amazon Link

The AmazonBasics Enameled Dutch Oven is quite the looker. It comes in an array of dazzling color and size options so that you can get the best fit for your home. It is enameled on the inside so it will help to keep your food from cooking and it is easier to transport with larger handles for your convenience.

Secure Lid
The AmazonBasics comes with a super secure fitting lid. That makes this a great companion for slow cooking and for storing and marinating food as well. We give points for Ease of Use here.

This product is safe to go in the over and can withstand temperatures up to 400 degrees Fahrenheit. Because it is coated in enamel, it will not react with the different foods you cook, but you will not be able to build up a flavor base. We docked points for taste here.

Easy Transport Handles
This comes with larger handles so the product is easier to transport.

However, some reviewers report that the enamel coating is very thin and can chip easily so we dock points in the Durability category here. You should not wash in the dishwasher because of this.

It weighs in at just over 13 pounds.

Cost and Value
The AmazonBasics Enameled Dutch Oven rings up on the lower end of our price range and we love its value because it is versatile in cooking as well as in food storage and will add a lovely pop of color to your kitchen’s style.

Amazon Link
$50.15

7. Utopia Kitchen Pre Seasoned

Where to buy
Amazon Link
Utopia Kitchen Pre Seasoned
Amazon Link

The Utopia Kitchen Pre Seasoned is the most budget friendly and affordable option on our list by far, but don’t let that fool you. If you are looking for an introductory piece or you just want something that’s a little more simple, this could be the perfect fit for you. Plus, it is super lightweight at just around 7 pounds so it’s easier to work with.

Lighter Weight
The Utopia Kitchen is one of the lightest options on our list. It weighs just above 7 pounds which makes it a great option for those who want the benefits of a cast iron but who may not be able to wield the full weight of one. We give major points in the Weight category for this.

High-Temp Approved
This pre-seasoned pot may be lightweight and inexpensive, but it can still handle the super high heats of broiling in the oven up to 500 degrees Fahrenheit. And on top of that, it is super durable so we give points for Ease of Use here.

While it does come preseasoned, several reviewers report needing to reseason themselves so we take points from Taste here.

Cost and Value
The Utopia Kitchen Pre Seasoned rings up at the very bottom of our price range and we like its value because it is the most budget-friendly on our list and can still hold up for a long time if you follow the proper care instructions (which we have laid out in the Frequently Asked Questions section and Expert Tips section below).

Amazon Link

8. King Kooker Pre-Seasoned

Where to buy
Amazon Link
$109.45
King Kooker Pre-Seasoned
Amazon Link

The King Kooker Pre-Seasoned is a great option for open fire cooking, as well as cooking in the home. Buyers are impressed with the pre-seasoning on this product so we give Taste points here. Folks are also impressed with the amount that they can fit inside. This is truly a heavy-duty pot as it weighs in at just over 30 pounds. Handle with care!

Very Large
The King Kooker is the largest item on our list so far. There is some debate on whether or not it can actually hold 16 quarts, but regardless, most agree that it can hold over 14.

In fact, we have reviewers stating that they can fry two whole chickens at the very same time in this pot, no problems. We give points for Size here.

Hot Handle
It has a super neat feature in its hot handle. This feature allows for the handle to have a cooler grip as it has a spiral at the center. This is super important because the pot is very heavy (30 pounds) and you will need to grab hold of the handle very well so that you can safely take the pot from cooking to serving. We give Ease of Use points for this feature.

If you make sure to take good care of this product, you will find it to be durable, though larger products ofter get neglected for proper care.

Cost and Value
The King Kooker rings up in the middle of our price range and we like its value because it is enormous and super durable and well seasoned. If you have a lot of people to cook for--and we mean a lot, this is just the right pot for you.

Amazon Link
$109.45

9. Commercial Chef Dutch Oven

Where to buy
Amazon Link
$59.99
Commercial Chef Dutch Oven
Amazon Link

The Commercial Chef Dutch Oven is another great option that is super kind to the pocketbook. While being on the very affordable end, it is still thick and pre-seasoned, and provides you with all of the benefits of a more elite cast iron pot. Plus it holds heat so well that it can even double as a warming serving dish so you get more out of its use every time.

Thick and Insulated
The Commercial Chef does not scrimp on thickness just because it is a more affordable item. In fact, it still had a nice thickness that keeps your food super-insulated and that works to provide even heat in less time which means faster cooking times and faster eating. We give points for Ease of Use here.

With that thickness does come a bit of extra weight and this product weighs in at 15 pounds, so we take a few points away for Weight here.

Great for Serving
This pot also doubles as a great warming serving dish because it stays so well insulated due to its thickness. That means that it will keep your food warmer for longer while also looking super nice and rustic on your table. We give points for Ease of Use here.

Cost and Value
The Commercial Chef rings up at the bottom of our price range and we like its value because it is thick and durable despite being a budget option. And as long as it is given the proper care, you can enjoy this cooking item for a long time.

Amazon Link
$59.99

10. Bayou Classic 2.5-Qt. Bean Pot

Where to buy
Amazon Link
$33.30
Bayou Classic 2.5-Qt. Bean Pot
Amazon Link

The Bayou Classic 2.5-Qt. Bean Pot is a smaller pot that will bring a big amount of charming rustic flair to your kitchen. Even though it is small, it weighs in at 9 pounds and can hold up to 2.5 quarts of food. You will have to season this product on your own and you’ll be able to use it for campfire cooking or on your stove at home.

Lid is Self-Basting
The Bayou Classic 2.5-Qt. Bean Pot features a lid that is self-basting. This means that the juices from what you’re cooking will evaporate, make contact with the lid, and fall back onto your food, re-basting it continually during the cooking process. We give Taste points here.

We like that this product is safe for the broiler, the stove, and the campfire. We give Ease of Use points here.

Season, Season, Season
This pot does not come seasoned. You will need to do this on your own. And you will likely need to do it more than once. We read from many reviewers that this pot is a dream after being seasoned around 4-6 times.

Before this many seasonings, a lot of sticking and uneven cooking was happening, but after seasonings, reviewers are generally quite satisfied with the effectiveness and taste. However, we take some Ease of Use points here as this is an involved process.

Users find that it holds up well with the right care so we give Durability points for that.

Cost and Value
The Bayou Classic rings up at the very bottom of our price range and we like its value because it is a great small-sized budget option that can get the job done if you know how to season it correctly and treat it with loving care.

Amazon Link
$33.30

Sources

  1. Eating Well Contributing Writers, How to Clean and Season a Cast Iron Skillet, Article
  2. Cook's Illustrated Contributing Writers, How to Clean a Cast-Iron Pan, Article
  3. Marian Cooper Cairns, How To Season A Cast-Iron Skillet, Articles