to top 10 table

Best Saddle Pads Reviewed & Rated for Quality

last updated Dec 01, 2018

You’re riding your horse through the field, the wind blowing in your hair. You gallop along, smiling, racing the long strands of grass that blow in the wind as your stride past them. But, what if this ride could be better? Besides its main purpose of protecting leather, a saddle pad can help absorb some of the shocks your spine feels when bouncing up and down. It can also help your horse feel better, by assisting in distributing the weight of the rider in a way that reduces the stress the horse feels. Most importantly, a saddle pad helps to keep your saddle leather from withering away and they can be extremely expensive. Following this guide will lead you one step closer to choosing the saddle pad that will suit you the best.

Interviewed Experts
5
Interviewed Experts
Total Readers
9000
Total Readers
Reviews Considered
12000
Reviews Considered
Hours Researching
30
Hours Researching
Products Evaluated
14
Products Evaluated
Last Updated:
By Katie Baxter:

This article has been recently revised to allow readers to have access to the most current information available regarding saddle pads. The top saddle pads have been reviewed to ensure they are still the greatest of quality and reviews. More links have been added throughout the article to give readers access to more information that may be beneficial in their horse riding journeys.

Sorting Options
Fit Shock Absorption Materials Style By Default
Rank
PictureProduct
Name
Rating
Shops
1
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
97
Fit
96%
Shock Absorption
97%
Materials
99%
Style
96%
Price Comparison Last Updated (18.12.18)
$27.46
2
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
95.8
Fit
95%
Shock Absorption
98%
Materials
96%
Style
94%
Price Comparison Last Updated (18.12.18)
$94.95
3
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
95
Fit
97%
Shock Absorption
96%
Materials
95%
Style
92%
Price Comparison Last Updated (18.12.18)
$75.77
4
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
93.3
Fit
96%
Shock Absorption
90%
Materials
93%
Style
94%
Price Comparison Last Updated (18.12.18)
$24.95
5
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
91.5
Fit
91%
Shock Absorption
94%
Materials
89%
Style
92%
Price Comparison Last Updated (18.12.18)
$129.27
6
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
89.8
Fit
92%
Shock Absorption
89%
Materials
87%
Style
91%
Price Comparison Last Updated (18.12.18)
$51.01
7
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
88
Fit
90%
Shock Absorption
86%
Materials
89%
Style
87%
Price Comparison Last Updated (18.12.18)
$68.95
8
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
85.3
Fit
87%
Shock Absorption
82%
Materials
86%
Style
86%
Price Comparison Last Updated (18.12.18)
$129.95
9
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
81.5
Fit
83%
Shock Absorption
82%
Materials
78%
Style
83%
Price Comparison Last Updated (18.12.18)
$29.95
10
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
79.7
Shock Absorption
79%
Materials
76%
Style
84%
Price Comparison Last Updated (18.12.18)
$85.98
In Depth Review Top 10
  • TuffRider Basics
  • Kavallerie
  • Diamond Wool
  • Equine Comfort Products
  • Classic Equine
  • Derby Originals
  • Back on Track
  • Southwestern Equine
  • Roma F.C.
  • Weaver Leather
Table of contents
  • Criteria Used for Evaluation
  • Other Factors to Consider
  • Frequently Asked Questions

BEST SADDLE PADS REVIEWED & RATED FOR QUALITY

1. TuffRider Basics

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
97
TuffRider Basics
Fit
96
Shock Absorption
97
Materials
99
Style
96
best offer for today
$27.46
Pros:

Made from cotton

Flannel underside

Basic design

Comes in multiple colors

Cons:

Sizes are not accurate

Colors are slightly off

A saddle pad that has gotten back to the basics with their design. This saddle pad offers your horse protection while pleasing you with the color choices.

Read more

Basic Design
Made to offer the horse the protection it needs from the saddle, this saddle pad has a relatively basic style design. No fancy features to worry about, as this saddle pad won't have any.

Color Choices
Although your horse won't care what color the saddle pad is, you might. Maybe you want a flashy color to show off with. You can even be more practical, choosing a color that will be easier to maintain.

Cost and Value
The protective padding your horse needs, at a price that you can be happy with. Choose a color that looks great or stick with something more traditional. The choice for color and the comfort of your horse are up to you.

2. Kavallerie

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
95.8
Kavallerie
Fit
95
Shock Absorption
98
Materials
96
Style
94
best offer for today
$94.95
Pros:

Prevents slipping

Reduces soreness in the horses back

Absorbs shock

Easy to clean

Cons:

Seems heavy

Complaints of instability

This saddle pad can give you the riding experience you have been missing all along. Improving the relationship between your saddle and your horse. Your horse will thank you for a saddle pad like this one.

Read more

Back Protection
Designed to absorb the shock during your ride, this saddle pad can improve your riding experience for both you and your horse. Intended to mold to the shape of your horse, the pad eliminates the soreness in the horses back.

Non-Slip
You don't have to worry about your saddle slipping and sliding while you ride. The low-profile style of the pad will keep the saddle still. This will prevent the sores that can plague a horse due to friction.

Cost and Value
When you are willing to spend a little more money, you will get a more trusted saddle pad. Made from quality materials, with the safety of the horse being number one on the list.

3. Diamond Wool

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
95
Diamond Wool
Fit
97
Shock Absorption
96
Materials
95
Style
92
best offer for today
$75.77
Pros:

Shock absorbing

Wither relief

Made from wool

Durable

Cons:

Complaints that it is hard to clean

Not as dense as expected

Next comes a saddle pad that is made to work as hard as your horse. Made from a material that can withstand plenty of punishment. You can be sure that using this saddle pad will benefit you as well as your horse.

Read more

Relief
At the area of the withers of your horse, there can be some issues with pain and sensitivity. This saddle pad has a built-in relief for the wither area of your horse. Doing away with the discomfort a horse can experience during a ride.

Wool
Made from a compressed wool, this saddle pad can absorb the blows to a horse during rigorous activity levels. Another great value to this wool pad, it can be used to offset a saddle when the fit is slightly off.

Cost and Value
With so many benefits for your horse, this pad can become a valuable asset to your horse riding gear. As for the cost, well you will have to pay the price for high-quality riding gear.

4. Equine Comfort Products

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
93.3
Equine Comfort Products
Fit
96
Shock Absorption
90
Materials
93
Style
94
best offer for today
$24.95
Pros:

Fit can be adjusted

Topline allows for air circulation

Relieves pressure

Absorbs shock

Cons:

Thinner than expected

You can adjust this saddle pad to the changes your horse will go through. This saddle pad will have many great benefits for the health of your horse. A pad such as this one will stick around for future rides to come.

Read more

Adjustable
With this saddle pad comes the ability to change the way it sits and fits with the saddle. There are pockets that hold shims, these shims can be removed or replaced according to the changes your horse will go through.

Air Flow
The top of the saddle is designed to allow air to circulate under the pad. Which in turn will reduce the amount of sweating your horse will do. Which is great for the horse, as the less the horse sweats, the less the risk of getting sores.

Cost and Value
This saddle pad is packed with benefits for the cost of the saddle. Keeping the health of your horse at the top of the list right as it should be. You can control the fit by adding or removing the shims of the pad. Making sure you get the perfect fit at all times.

5. Classic Equine

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
91.5
Classic Equine
Fit
91
Shock Absorption
94
Materials
89
Style
92
best offer for today
$129.27
Pros:

Good for high withers

Durable

Easy to clean

Quick drying

Cons:

Seams came apart rather quickly

The next pad on the list offers the perfect place for saddles, even with high withered horses. Filling in the gaps when other saddles pads just didn't cut the mustard.

Read more

Saddle Fit
You can be sure that this pad can help to compensate for the high wither area of your horse. Offering enough padding, that your saddle will rest properly. Reducing the amount of discomfort and stress to your horse.

Easy to Clean
With a regular routine for maintaining your saddle pad, you can ensure that the pad will last for rides to come. You can be sure that the materials used to create this saddle pad are easy to clean and keep them that way.

Cost and Value
Coming in as one of the more pricey options on our list, one must ask themselves if this will be within their budget. In the event that it is, you will not be disappointed with this purchase.

6. Derby Originals

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
89.8
Derby Originals
Fit
92
Shock Absorption
89
Materials
87
Style
91
best offer for today
$51.01
Pros:

Fleece lined

Has pocket for storage

Foam padding

Comes in several colors

Cons:

Seems somewhat thin

Poor construction of the seams

A saddle pad option that can be used for all your horseback riding needs. Whether for work or for play, this saddle pad can make a lasting impression on both you and your horse.

Read more

Storage Pocket
For those long rides or even longer workdays, a rider might need a little extra storage space. Perfect for this is the smaller sized pocket toward the back of the saddle pad. You can set your car keys in the pocket or maybe even your afternoon snack.

The Fit
To keep your horse comfortable and cool all at once, this saddle pad has a few tricks up its sleeves. The inside is partially lined with fleece, which will reduce the amount of sweating. Not only that, but the fleece adds a certain level of comfort as well.

Cost and Value
Whether you're riding your horse for work reasons or for a good time with friends, this saddle pad will please your horse the entire time you are riding. As a bonus, there is a pocket for you to use as storage.

7. Back on Track

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
88
Back on Track
Fit
90
Shock Absorption
86
Materials
89
Style
87
best offer for today
$68.95
Pros:

Reduces soreness

Promotes good bloodflow

Easy to clean

Durable

Cons:

Complaints that this is way too thin

Next, we come to a saddle ad that offers your horse a little therapy while it is on. This can keep your horse happy, making your riding experience more memorable.

Read more

Therapy
For muscle support, this saddle pad has its own heating therapeutic properties to it. Promoting muscle health, as well as reducing the amount of soreness the horse will feel.

Increase to Blood Flow
The warming effect of the saddle pad tends to keep the blood of the horse pumping, which aids in the recovery time for the horse. Reducing the residual soreness in the muscles of the horse.

and Value
This saddle pad acts as a heating pad, therefore aiding in reducing the amount of soreness your horse will feel in their muscles. Using heat to promote blood flow, which cuts the time it takes for the horse to recover. These two qualities alone will set this pad apart from the others.

8. Southwestern Equine

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
85.3
Southwestern Equine
Fit
87
Shock Absorption
82
Materials
86
Style
86
best offer for today
$129.95
Pros:

Made from wool

Comes in two thickness sizes

Comes in several size varieties

Durable

Cons:

Seems to be hard

A saddle pad made from materials such as this can have lasting effects on the horse. Keeping them comfortable, while you enjoy your ride through the trails. You are sure to find one that best fits your saddle needs.

Read more

Health Benefits
This saddle pad is made from wool, which has its very own cooling and moisture wicking properties. So you can be sure that the horse's body temperature will remain regulated throughout the length of the ride.

Sizing
Depending on the size of your saddle, there are plenty of options for both size and thickness available. You can choose the size that will better suit the needs of you and your horse.

Cost and Value
Here we have another amazingly qualified choice for a saddle pad. That is one of the reasons for the higher price tag. You will learn rather quickly, that skimping on the cost of your riding equipment will get you nowhere in the long run.

9. Roma F.C.

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
81.5
Roma F.C.
Fit
83
Shock Absorption
82
Materials
78
Style
83
best offer for today
$29.95
Pros:

Basic design

Stylish

Comes in different colors

Wicks away moisture

Cons:

Dulls after washing one time

This saddle pad can function well no matter what you are using it for. As we all know, fashion won't be on the top of your horse's list. But that doesn't mean that your horse doesn't need to look nice.

Read more

Basic Design
Designed to do as saddle pads have been intended to do for years. This one will protect the horse during all types of activities. Horses will need something between them and the saddle, that is exactly where this saddle pad comes into play.

Sharp Looking
With the two-tone color design, it will add some style to the look of your horse. The color contrast of the stitching adds a neat looking appearance to the saddle pad.

Cost and Value
This saddle pad does its job without all the fancy things added to it. It has proven that even the simplest of designs can be functional and fashionable at the same time.

10. Weaver Leather

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
79.7
Weaver Leather
Shock Absorption
79
Materials
76
Style
84
best offer for today
$85.98
Pros:

The product is made from Merino wool.

This saddle pad is resistant to mold and mildew.

Horses will find this pad comfortable and soothing.

Consumers will enjoy the unique design of this product.

Cons:

Consumers have complained that this product is not great for horses with significant withers.

Our last saddle pad on the list isn't last because it has nothing to offer. Instead, think of it this way, someone had to go last. In this case, we may have even saved the best saddle pad for last.

Read more

Moisture Wicking
For this saddle pad, there was no expense spared, using Merino wool to line the underside of the pad. Merino wool is known for adding comfort to the pad while keeping the sweat off the horse.

Resistance
To add to the many great aspects of this saddle pad, it has been coated with a protective layer. This layer adds a level of resistance to both mold and mildew, which in turn can lower the rate at which your horse will catch looming illnesses.

Cost and Value
Once you have used this saddle pad, you will see just how beneficial it can be. Upon figuring this out for your self, you will not even bat an eye at the overall cost of the pad. With so many benefits, the value of this pad far exceeds the cost.

Criteria Used for Evaluation

Fit

When looking into purchasing a saddle pad, the best line of defense you have is knowledge. Knowing how to fit your saddle properly will better improve the riding experience for both you and your horse. If this is your first time purchasing the gear you need to ride, we recommend seeking professional help to be sure your saddle fits the horse accordingly.

Some will argue the point that the saddle pad serves the purpose of aiding in the fit of the saddle. This is only true to a point, thinking of it in a different way can help you understand a separate way of thinking. Say you have a pair of work boots that are snug fitting, then you slap on a pair of thick wool socks. How do you think these boots will feel on your feet now? Well, the same theory can be applied to a saddle and pad combination for a horse. When the saddle is snug, you don’t want to add a thick pad underneath.

Style

Straight: This pad shape is the most common one, seen more often than most. A straight pad is simply a rectangle shape with no extra cushion or curves. This type of pad best serves a horse that has a straight, more normal shaped back. For those familiar with horse terminology, this pad shape is well suited for a horse with mutton-withers. To familiarize some with the terminology mutton-withers, the withers of a horse is the shoulder area of the horse. The term mutton refers to them being flat.

Contour: The contoured pad works well for a horse that has high withers, with a dip in the back to follow. This design will reduce the amount of pressure carried in the area of the shoulders. Giving the horse a more comfortable saddle fit, as well as balance.

Cutout: A cutout saddle pad is closely related to the straight-shaped pad. These can be found to be round or square in shape but will have an area that has been cut-out. This cut-out section is found to reduce the irritation to the withers of a horse by eliminating the amount of pressure on the area.

Round: A horse with a back that is considered to be short, a round saddle pad can do wonders for them. Since the edges of the pad have been rounded, they tend to cause less restriction to the movements of the horse.

Sway-Back: Swayback for a horse means that just past the shoulder blades the back of the horse will dip. A sway-Back saddle pad will help support and compensate for this issue. A sway-back pad will add height in the area of the withers, while offering added cushioning in the middle of the pad. This will give the saddle a more level position for riding.

Wither Relief: Designed for a horse with very high withers, this type of saddle pad will keep the saddle off of the withers by adding a slightly lifted area. It will also slightly resemble the cutout style saddle pad.

Materials

Fleece: This material is the most used material for saddle pads. It can mop up the sweat of the horse while providing a decent amount of cushion. It has been noted that with use, a fleece pad can lose some of its level of cushioning due to compression.

Felt: A felt pad is actually made from wool that has been compressed. They do a fantastic job absorbing shock for the horse while defending against heat build up. Some riders will use a felt pad for a saddle that doesn’t quite fit the way they need it to.

Neoprene: A saddle pad made from neoprene will reduce the chance of slipping. This is due to the pattern used on the bottom of the pad. Made to act as a rubber, these are waterproof, yet breathable at the same time. Many riders will choose this type of pad just for the amount of durability it holds.

Foam: Here we have two choices to look at. There are the open-celled foam pads, these are breathable and can mold to the shape of the horse over time. They will also have a softer feel to them. Closed-cell foam pads are slightly more firm than that of its counterpart. It has been said that the closed-cell foam has more anti-bacterial properties as well. Both are found with a cover normally made from nylon.

Cotton: Typically the pads that are made from cotton, are said to be the most basic form of a pad. These can be found with added pockets, for you to add some inserts. The inserts are to help adjust the fit of the saddle for the horse’s comfort.

Overall Fit

With the ever-changing times, saddle pads have greatly evolved in the area of looks. With changes to materials used to cover the pads, you can surely find one that will suit your sense of style. some will come with what seems to be all the bells and whistles to make it as flashy as possible. Just be sure that your number one reason for choosing the saddle pad is the comfort of your horse. After all the horse is the one that has to wear the saddle pad, not you. I can assure you that your horse doesn’t give a toot about fashion.

Expert Interviews & Opinions

Most Important Criteria (According to our experts opinion)
Sort criterias acording to:
Experts Opinion Editors Opinion Users Opinion By Default
Click on a to rate the most important criteria:
1
Fit
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
2
Shock Absorption
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
3
Materials
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
4
Style
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
Choosing the Right Saddle Pad

Match the shape of the saddle to the shape of your horses back. This will help the saddle pad do its job tremendously. By doing so, you will know that the saddle pad isn’t adding any pressure to the back of the horse.
Find the style of the pad that best suits the normal activity of your horse. There are pads designed for different aspects of saddling the horse. Think of how the horse feels and acts while wearing the saddle, this can help you decide if the pad is right for your horse.
Pads are designed with specific saddle types in mind. Choose a pad that is intended for use with the saddle you are currently using. If you use more than one type of saddle you may need to purchase more than one type of pad. A little food for thought, allow your pad to just peek out the edges of the saddle. That way you know the full saddle has coverage.
On contrary to popular belief, saddle pads should not be used to justify a saddle that just doesn’t fit. First, find a saddle that fits your horse, there are people out there that can help you determine the fit of the saddle. The saddle pad can, however, be used to alleviate problem areas the saddle may have. You can use a pad to lessen the pressure felt by the horse, as well as choosing one that fits the horse’s body shape.

Caring for Your Saddle Pad

Always take great care of your saddle pad, doing so can prolong the use of the pad. A pad that has lost the fill potential should be replaced. Pads made from neoprene should be replaced when noticeable wear or tearing begins to show.

You should have a regular routine for the care of your saddle pad, as well as the rest of your riding equipment. Using a dirty pad is detrimental to your horse, as it can cause your horse to get sores. Washing the pad according to the manufacturer’s directions will eliminate this issue. A more soiled saddle pad can be rinsed clean using a pressure washer, in the event you don’t have one, a do-it-yourself car wash will. To dry a saddle pad, turn it over topside, allow it to dry in the sun. The sun is better for killing bacteria caused by sweat than your dryer ever will be. Be sure the pad has dried completely before storing for the next use.

Check the Fit of the Saddle Pad Often

What most people may not think of, is depending on several factors both the shape and condition of your horse can change. When choosing a saddle pad for a younger horse, you know that their body shape will continue to change. So you certainly expect that you will need to monitor the fit of both the saddle and the pad. It works the same for your older horse as well. During periods of less activity, your horse will bulk out more, you will then notice that the fit for the saddle pad may not be right.

Other Factors to Consider

Breathability

The ability of your saddle pad to wick moisture is important. It not only helps keep your horse cool and dry, but it'll avoid sores that can appear after a while, which will cause your animal pain. Find out what material the item is made of and find out what others have said about it. It's important that you are not only comfortable, but that your horse is as well.

Durability

Horse riding is far from a smooth experience. In fact, it can be quite bumpy depending on how fast your horse is going. With all this momentum, there is going to be a lot of friction, and your saddle pad needs to be able to handle it or else you'll be buying a new one more often then you'd like. You also need to take other factors into account, such as the weather conditions you usually ride in. Different situations call for different materials, but no matter what, it needs to be durable!

Frequently Asked Questions

q: What does it mean to shim a saddle pad?
a:

Shimming a saddle pad can help adjust the way a saddle sits on your horse. A saddle pad that can host shims will have pockets sewn into the pads. You can insert the shims into the pockets to adjust for a saddle that is too wide. For a narrow saddle shimming will do you no good. If you are struggling to determine whether or not you need the shims, it is best to consult for help from a professional.

q: How do you choose a saddle pad thickness?
a:

To answer this question properly, you will need to ask yourself a serious of questions. How long are your typical rides? What is your weight? What kind of ground will you be traveling over?

For those who ride for extensive amounts of time on a normal basis, you will want to look for a pad that is just short of an inch thick. Combining the weight of your gear with your own weight can tell you what the thickness of your saddle pad should be. With a combined weight of 200 pounds or more, a pad that is at least one inch thick is best. Lastly, if the ground you travel is rough, a pad with thickness is better. You can start with one that is just under an inch thick, but be sure to keep an eye on the effectiveness.

q: What type of foam pad is better to open or closed-cell?
a:

It has been found that an open-cell foam pad is more beneficial to a horse than the closed-cell foam. The open-cell is breathable, therefore allowing air to circulate, reducing the amount of moisture that gets trapped under the pad. The closed-cell foam tends to trap sweat under the pad, this can lead to health issues over time.

q: How do you fix pad sliding issues?
a:

When your pad tends to slide around, you may have saddle fitting issues that you never knew existed. Another reason for this is the way you saddle your horse, placing the saddle either too far back or forward. Try lining the back edge of your saddle with the edge of the pad. If the sliding problem persists you may want to consult with a professional to check the fit of your horse saddle.

q: Why would you want a saddle pad made from wool?
a:

Wool has some beneficial properties to it that make it a great choice for clothing or even a saddle pad. Wool can add both warmth and a cooling effect on the person or animal wearing the wool. So when your horse sweats, the wool will pull the moisture away from the horse, which in turn will cool the horse down. Wool is an easy material to care for, it can be cleaned and will dry quickly. Last we come to the fact that wool can withstand a tremendous amount of use. With proper care and cleaning, a good wool saddle pad can hold up for years as they pass.

q: How long should a saddle pad last before having to replace the saddle pad?
a:

As much as you care for your saddle pad, they still won’t last forever. Although material choices have come a long way over time, they still don’t last forever. The length of time that the saddle pad will last can depend on several different factors. The first, the amount of time the pad is used, say you use your horse for work. Riding the horse for long periods of time, several times a week. You will notice that the saddle pad will wither more quickly, even when the best a materials are used to make it. Your routine for caring for the saddle pad will also come into play, a saddle pad that is not properly cared for will not last as long either.

q: Why is it important to have your saddle pad fitted?
a:

It is important to have a fitted saddle pad not only for the saddle but also for the horse. If you have the right fit for your saddle, the pad can help reduce extra weight and rubbing the horse might experience while riding. This, will, in turn, allow your horse to be more comfortable and increase its ability to continue working.