to top 10 table

Best Flannel Shirts Reviewed and Rated & Comfort

last updated Oct 08, 2019

Yes, Winter is Coming. This quickly became the most overused phrase in history but we thought we’d give it a try one more time as a way to let you know that it’s time to dust off your flannel shirts and get ready for winter. Everyone in the world, man, woman child, and some animals need to have a generous amount of flannel in their wardrobes. Back in the day flannel was primarily a woolen garment but times and materials have changed and flannel has come a long way and is now made with all kinds of fabrics from cotton to synthetics. We’re not so worried about the materials but we do think that just as a general rule having some flannel ready for the cold weather months is just a smart thing to do.

In a Hurry? The test winner after 17 hrs of research

icon
 Legendary Whitetails
94/100 our score
Materials
95
Insulation
94
Weight
93
Value
94
Legendary Whitetails
Why is it better?

Fits perfectly

The material used in making this shirt is one of the best

Warm

Affordable

Good design

In a Hurry? Editors choice:
 Legendary Whitetails
Test Winner: Legendary Whitetails
Amazon Link
Researched Sources
5
Researched Sources
Reviews Considered
11250
Reviews Considered
Hours Researching
17
Hours Researching
Products Evaluated
15
Products Evaluated
Last Updated:
Shanena Ketchum
By Shanena Ketchum:

For this update, we looked ahead to winter and double-checked on products as well as prices. We've introduced a few new products like the Gioberti, a new shirt from Columbia and a really nice new entry from Mocotono. We've also updated our intro and looked over the FAQ for the latest on flannels. Winter is coming, so take a look.

Sorting Options
Materials Insulation Weight Value By Default
Rank
PictureProduct
Name
Rating
Shops
#1
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
94
Materials
95 %
Insulation
94 %
Weight
93 %
Value
94 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (13.11.19)
Amazon Link
$32.99
#2
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
93.5
Materials
94 %
Insulation
94 %
Weight
93 %
Value
93 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (13.11.19)
Amazon Link
$74.95
#3
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
93.3
Materials
92 %
Insulation
94 %
Weight
94 %
Value
93 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (13.11.19)
Amazon Link
$24.99
#4
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
93.5
Materials
93 %
Insulation
93 %
Weight
94 %
Value
94 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (13.11.19)
Amazon Link
$39.99
#5
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
92.3
Materials
93 %
Insulation
93 %
Weight
92 %
Value
91 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (13.11.19)
Amazon Link
$29.95
#6
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
92.3
Materials
93 %
Insulation
93 %
Weight
92 %
Value
91 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (13.11.19)
Amazon Link
$19.99
#7
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
91.8
Materials
93 %
Insulation
90 %
Weight
92 %
Value
92 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (13.11.19)
Amazon Link
$30.16
#8
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
93
Materials
93 %
Insulation
93 %
Weight
94 %
Value
92 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (13.11.19)
Amazon Link
$26.99
#9
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
91.8
Materials
93 %
Insulation
92 %
Weight
92 %
Value
90 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (13.11.19)
Amazon Link
$65.00
#10
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
90.5
Materials
90 %
Insulation
92 %
Weight
91 %
Value
89 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (13.11.19)
Amazon Link
$39.99

Top 10 Flannel Shirts

1. Legendary Whitetails

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
94
1. Legendary Whitetails Flannel Shirts
1. Legendary Whitetails
1. Legendary Whitetails
Amazon Link
Materials
95
Insulation
94
Weight
93
Value
94
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$32.99
Pros:

Fits perfectly

The material used in making this shirt is one of the best

Warm

Affordable

Good design

Cons:

The seam at the cuff is not strong enough

The Legendary Whitetails flannel is one of the shirts you will see in a hunter’s closet. A hunter who doesn’t have this shirt in his closet does not have a complete closet. This Legendary flannel shirt with high-class plaids are made from the finest cotton material, they are soft and have a brushed flannel.

Double Pleat
This comes with a double pleat back so you can move easily and distinct corduroy which comes with furrowed collar and cufflinks for better appearance and lifelong resilience.

Convenient Pocket
The left pocket by the chest has a space you can put your pencil together with a button finish, and cufflinks that can be adjusted.

Cost and Value
This shirt is ideal for amateur and skilled hunters as it protects you from cold and it is comfortable which is what you need to kill that big game. It is affordable at the same time durable. We highly recommend this for hunters who take comfort and durability in high regard.

2. Woolrich Men's Oxbow

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
93.5
2. Woolrich Men's Oxbow Flannel Shirts
2. Woolrich Men's Oxbow
Amazon Link
Materials
94
Insulation
94
Weight
93
Value
93
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$74.95
Pros:

Durable

Fits perfectly

Available in numerous sizes

High-quality material

Limited lifetime warranty

Cons:

A bit expensive

This one by John Rich & Bros is one of the best shirts for hunting. The shirt is lightweight, making it easy for hunters to wear and comfortable when in use. It is 100% cotton and also comes with a long sleeve that is certain to withstand the cold of fall and winter head-on. This is sure to keep you warm as much as possible during the worst conditions on your adventures.

Solid value
Here is a good find to have in your wardrobe. The material used in making this shirt is one of the best. Though the price might be a concern to some, overall it is a fantastic choice for hunters.

Lifetime warranty
On the off chance that one of their shirts doesn’t hold up to their rigorous standards, Woolrich has included a lifetime warranty to ensure that at the very least, the consumer is left satisfied.

Cost and Value
It is a bit expensive compared to others in this review. But at the same time, still considered at a reasonable price. If you are on a small budget, it is advisable to go for other options.

3. Gioberti Men's 100% Cotton

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
93.3
Gioberti Men's 100% Cotton
Gioberti Men's 100% Cotton
Gioberti Men's 100% Cotton
Amazon Link
Materials
92
Insulation
94
Weight
94
Value
93
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$24.99
Pros:

Fabric Lined Collar

Button Flap

Tapered Fit

Colors Galore

Cons:

Massive Shrinkage After First Wash

This is a cotton flannel so the one thing you know about it right off the bat is that it is going to be comfortable. The cotton guarantees not only warmth but a pajama-like comfort that you’ll be able to relax in no matter where you are, indoors or outdoors. It also comes in a number of different tartans so if you know enough about your Scottish history you might see your clan colors show up.

Fabric Lined Collar
We’re not sure this adds that much to the comfort of the collar but hey it looks great. It’s fabric but it looks like leather and it is soft as the dickens so you can wear this for days though we’re not sure we’d recommend it. Keep in mind it does not have button-up collars so keep that in mind.

Nice Color Schemes
This shirt comes in so many great patterns we don’t really know where to start. But no matter the color you’ll find a few extras tossed in like the fabric lined collar for comfort and also take a look at the rolled-up sleeves, they’re a solid color so it just adds to the aesthetics of the shirt when you roll it up.

Cost And Value
Now, this shirt is a steal for the money. You get a fabric-lined collar and sleeves, a left-hand pocket with a button flap and a nice tapered fit that’s sure to flatter. For the money, it’s hard to beat this little flannel number.

4. Rothco Heavyweight Brawny

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
93.5
4. Rothco Heavyweight Brawny Flannel Shirt
4. Rothco Heavyweight Brawny
4. Rothco Heavyweight Brawny
Amazon Link
Materials
93
Insulation
93
Weight
94
Value
94
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$39.99
Pros:

Warm

Affordable

High-quality material

Limited lifetime warranty

Cons:

Comes in only one size

This Rothco shirt is one of the best found on this buying guide. Made from 100% cotton, they are heavyweight shirts that deliver incredible warmth and comfort in the worst weather conditions. It comes with a button up front and another two button flap pockets, all of which help make Rothco the leading contractor for military gear.

Top quality materials
This shirt is made up of the best quality 100% cotton, and it definitely shows. It was designed to be stylish and functional, comfortable enough to keep you going throughout the day.

Holds up well
This shirt has been tested in the worst possible conditions and passed them effortlessly. The Rothco fits perfectly, and it is affordable. We recommend this Rothco to all hunters; it won't disappoint you.

Cost and value
This shirt comes very reasonably priced. The manufacturers produced it with every day, working-class consumers in mind. They know not many people can afford an expensive one so, they made the Rothco affordable for all.

5. Wolverine Mens Redwood

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
92.3
5. Wolverine Mens Redwood Flannel Shirt
5. Wolverine Mens Redwood
5. Wolverine Mens Redwood
Amazon Link
Materials
93
Insulation
93
Weight
92
Value
91
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$29.95
Pros:

Made with 100% cotton

Machine washable

Double chest pocket

Fits perfectly

Warm even in the worst conditions

Cons:

The color is not that good

The Wolverine Men's Redwood is excellent in extreme weather conditions because of its warmth. The Redwood was made with pure cotton, making this very comfortable when wearing it, and it is also very stylish for those that prefer to wear it for something other than hunting. The Redwood flannel allows smooth movement, and it is lightweight, unlike most, which makes this one an excellent choice.

Wash it and forget it
A very nice perk to choosing this shirt over other options is the ease of care. It doesn't require any special treatment. In fact, throw it in with your other clothes, give it a quick iron, or hang it for a bit, and you`re good to go.

Perfect fit
The Wolverine Men's Redwood is going to fit you pretty much perfectly. That is crucial when choosing clothing that is designed to protect you from the elements. A poorly fitting shirt, regardless of how warm it is, it essentially useless, so Wolverine took the time to ensure that their clothes will fit right.

Cost and Value
Despite its unique qualities, or maybe because of them, this shirt comes with a very reasonable price. So, if you are concerned about the price, rest assured this shirt is for you.

6. Dokkia Men's Button Bown Buffalo Plaid

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
92.3
6. Dokkia Men's Button Bown Buffalo Plaid Flannel Shirt
6. Dokkia Men's Button Bown Buffalo Plaid
Amazon Link
Materials
93
Insulation
93
Weight
92
Value
91
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$19.99
Pros:

Warm

High-quality material

Fits perfectly

Limited lifetime warranty

Cons:

Costly

The Dokkia Buffalo plaid is an excellent choice for hunters who value quality and comfort. The shirt has a wealth of important features, such as breathability and durability. It's exceptionally comfortable to wear and will keep you warm even in the most severe winter weather. This is a must-have for every hunter or adventurer who wants reliable gear on their adventures.

Good looking shirt
It is jaggedly attractive without losing its comfort and resilience; it has been brushed on both sides which make these plaid shirts soft inside and outside. The Dakine Men's Cascade is the definition of refinement.

Perfect for hunting
It is truly a typical hunter’s shirt as it is lightweight, yet at the same time keeps you warm on your hunting expeditions. It fits perfectly and as such is very comfortable to wear. It is highly recommended that you add this to your hunting gear.

Cost and Value
The price of the Dakine Men's Cascade is a bit high compared to its competitors. Therefore, it is safe to say it is expensive, but the high level of quality helps make it quite affordable.

7. Columbia Men's Silver Ridge

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
91.8
Columbia Men's Silver Ridge
Columbia Men's Silver Ridge
Columbia Men's Silver Ridge
Amazon Link
Materials
93
Insulation
90
Weight
92
Value
92
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$30.16
Pros:

Omni-Wisk Technology

Machine Washable

Loop Pockets

100% Polyester

Cons:

Frays At the Sleeves

This is a unique shirt that’s all polyester but it mimics a cotton or wool flannel really well. Plus the polyester means it will resist shrinkage and wrinkling and we’re not even mentioning the cool color schemes and the Omni-wick technology that’s going wick moisture away from your skin just in case you find it so comfortable you wear it in July.

Omni-Wick Technology
Not something we’re used to seeing but we certainly do appreciate the inclusion of this moisture-wicking material in the shirt. These shirts tend to hold in heat, especially this one since it’s all polyester so it’s good that it can handle a bit of sweat when things get rough.

Machine Washable
Like we said the polyester construction ensures that this won’t turn into a dishrag the first time you throw it in the wash. Not only does it hold it’s size but it will also hold it’s shape and won’t come out of the dryer too wrinkled to wear. Just toss it in the washer and drying and it’s good to go.

Cost and Value
A great price though there are some outlets that are going to charge you a bit more than others so be careful. But generally, this shirt comes in at a great price so get plenty.

8. MOCOTONO Men's Long Sleeve

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
93
8. Wrangler Authentics Flannel Shirt
MOCOTONO Men's Long Sleeve
MOCOTONO Men's Long Sleeve
Amazon Link
Materials
93
Insulation
93
Weight
94
Value
92
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$26.99
Pros:

Water Treated

Pockets

Lots of Styles

Machine Washable

Cons:

Sizes are Off

Mocotono is giving the people what they want with this 100 percent cotton shirt that’s going to keep you warm when you need it and settle into wonderful wearability over time. We like the colors we like pockets and we like that these shirts have been water treated to stop shrinkage.

Water-Processed Shirts
What this means is that those shirts have already done all the shrinking they’re going to do. This is a good thing because there are few things worse than a great flannel shirt that’s tight at the shoulder or arms. With Mocotono the shirt that arrives is the shirt that sticks around.

Styles Galore
No matter the color combination you’re looking for chances are you’ll find it here with this shirt. There are dozens of different designs to take some time to find the exact shirt you want.

Cost and Value
These come in at the general price of flannel that we’ve found across the market. Pretty cheap, and all in all a wonderful choice if you’re looking for new flannel to get you through the winter.

9. Backpacker Flannel Quilt Lined

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
91.8
9. Backpacker Flannel Quilt Lined Flannel Shirt
9. Backpacker Flannel Quilt Lined
9. Backpacker Flannel Quilt Lined
Amazon Link
Materials
93
Insulation
92
Weight
92
Value
90
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$65.00
Pros:

Durable

Lightweight

Warm

Soft and comfortable on the body

Good material

Comes with a double-needle stitching

Limited lifetime warranty

Cons:

Pricey

The Backpacker Men’s shirt is soft to the touch, with the look and feel of a good chamois. The fact that it is brushed on both sides makes this soft to the touch both inside and out. On top of that, it has a box pleat at the back with double stitching. This attention to detail gives the shirt a high-quality finish.

Quilted for your protection
Taking extra precautions to protect you from the wind, Backpacker lined the inside of this shirt with polyester quilting, resulting in a breathable, heavy-duty piece that is ideal for outerwear.

Comfort is key
This shirt was designed with comfort in mind, clearly, and they covered every aspect. Not only is soft on the skin, but it was made to be roomy enough around the torso to promote an adequate range of motion.

Cost and Value
The Backpacker might seem expensive, but its unique qualities give the impression of being a real bargain. In this case, it is, so don’t hesitate to buy it because you won’t likely regret it.

10. Noble Mount Cotton

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
90.5
Noble Mount Cotton Flannel Shirt
Noble Mount Cotton
Noble Mount Cotton
Amazon Link
Materials
90
Insulation
92
Weight
91
Value
89
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$39.99
Pros:

Comfortable 100% cotton

Shrink control

Ideal for colder days

Long-tail keeps shirt tucked in

Cons:

Fits large until washed

Tends to lose its shape

Noble Mount states that they are a small, family-run business with the sole purpose of providing top quality garments directly to the consumer. They eliminate any unnecessary steps while not compromising their standards and expectations, so the clothes you are left with are very affordable and stylish enough to make anybody stand up and take notice.

Cotton is great
There are so many benefits to using cotton in the construction of this shirt. Not only is it going to be very comfortable, but being a natural fabric makes it very breathable, which keeps you dry all day.

Very minimal shrinkage
Noble Mount took steps to ensure that what you see is what you get but making sure that the shirt you buy is not going to shrink by more than 5% during its lifespan.

Cost and Value
The Noble Mount is a small business, by design, and as such, they are able to bring top quality clothing to their customers at a very affordable price by cutting out the middleman as much as possible.

Criteria Used for Evaluation

Materials

Most brands claim to use the best materials for their shirts which are not always the case after purchase. The above selections have been chosen based on the quality of the material used. They are the best you will find on the market today. A suitable material must be soft, comfortable and fit the body perfectly. We can assure you these are made of 100% cotton. You might also find some with some percentage of polyester, but that is because they are necessary due to some attachments to the shirts.

The quality of the material used in making these is paramount, especially for hunters. On your hunting expeditions, you will come in contact with many obstacles that can damage your shirt. If the material used in making the shirt is of poor quality, there’s a great possibility it gets damaged thereby ultimately putting an end to your hunt. Therefore, the quality of the material used is one of the criteria we used in evaluating.

Insulation

The primary purpose is to keep you warm either indoors or outdoors. There are many out there today that their manufacturers claim to provide enough warmth, but at the close of the day turns out to be a farce. We have handpicked the above shirts based on the warmth they offer. All of them are sure to keep you warm on your outdoor adventures or hunting expeditions we can assure you. All you are required to do is pick the one that suits you best out of the ten shirts above.

Weight

Nobody wants anything to do with a heavy shirt, do they? It must be as light as possible so you can feel as comfortable as you can be on your hunting expeditions. Rest assured ours have been picked because they are lightweight. It is one of the criteria we used in evaluating the above shirts. A lightweight shirt gives you the confidence you need to kill that big game you have always wanted.

Value

The price of these is also one of the criteria used in evaluating them. There are some on the market today that is expensive at the same time with poor quality while there are some that are affordable with great quality. We have selected the best ones based on their price. You might find some of the shirts in this review to be expensive, but we can guarantee you they are of the highest quality and vice versa.

Expert Interviews & Opinions

Most Important Criteria (According to our experts opinion)
Sort criterias acording to:
Experts Opinion Editors Opinion Users Opinion By Default
Click on a to rate the most important criteria:
#1
ico Materials
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
#2
ico Insulation
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
#3
ico Weight
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
#4
ico Value
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
expert tips icon
Sizing

You should always purchase your shirts in a size that will benefit you the most. For instance, if you plan to be hunting, you may want to buy a size larger so that you have room to layer. For those who just wear these for comfort and looks, you want one to fit slightly more snug. This will prevent you from snagging the shirt.

Other Factors to Consider

Features

Unlike other materials, flannel does not make noise when you move. When you are hunting, any material which makes noise when you walk or rub against stuff is your enemy. Remember the animals you are hunting have survived in the wild for millions of years because of their good hearing.

Noiseless, material like flannel help you keeping yourself concealed, you will blow your cover if the material from which your hunting clothes are made makes noise. Flannel does not crackle, scratch or squeak when you move. The reason behind this is that it is soft.

Frequently Asked Questions

q: Is it harmless to purchase flannel shirts on the internet?

a:

Totally! With specific cautions certainly. Make certain to purchase from a trustworthy seller and read the reviews to know what previous buyers think about their purchase. We would recommend all the time you buy from Amazon as they ensure the best customer service along with a huge collection of flannel shirts and many other products.

q: What type of material is used in making a flannel?

a:

Flannel shirts are made of 100% cotton or wool.

q: Can you wear flannel shirts in the summer?

a:

You could...but you would probably overheat from the thick cotton or wool fabric that flannel shirts are made from. However, some people have been seen wearing them in summer, in the evening, or night time as a light layer in the cooler hours of the day.

q: Are flannel and plaid the same?

a:

The most common confusion in fashion is the difference between plaid and flannel. Plaid is a design used for shirts while flannel is the material used in making the shirt. Plaid comes in different designs and colors.

q: What is the best quality flannel?

a:

A decent quality material is one that is 100% cotton. Needless to say, the denser fabrics will last longer and so offer better value for your money. Normally the grade of flannel used in work clothes will be substantial to cope with the bigger wear and tear they are exposed. However, they don’t have to be precisely work clothes to be made with the best fabric.

q: What’s the history of flannel?

a:

We’re not going to go too deeply into the weeds, or the heather, but while the flannel seems linked to the Scots and their tartans, flannel itself seems to be of Welsh origin and there’s evidence of warm flannel weaving that dates back as far as the 16th century.