Best Deer Calls Reviewed and Rated

Deer calling is one of an essential steps in any deer hunting strategy. There are products on the market that make you do the hard work when calling a deer. Then there are the automated ones that take all of the trouble out of that. Whichever path you choose, know that the best deer calls will always be manual ones. Once the audio technology catches up with calls, then it will be a whole different ballgame for all companies.

Best Brands

Primos is the cream of the crop, and then there is everyone else. There are two main things you can count on with a Primos product: it won’t cost a lot, and the materials are built to last years. That’s two major upsides for any hunter that wants to purchase a deer call.

Maintenance and Cleaning Tips

Cleaning obviously applies to the manual deer calls only, and just involves using a dry cloth to wipe it down. If you’re a meticulous type you could always buy a kit just for cleaning deer calls. That would be a pretty interesting expense, one that you probably won’t need unless you chew a lot of tobacco while hunting.

Our Top 3 Picks

Flextone All-N-One Deer Call
  • Flextone All-N-One Deer Call
  • 5 out of 5
    Our rating
  • A versatile deer call, best known for its authenticity and great performance
  • Price: See Here
Primos- The Original Can Deer Call
  • Primos- The Original Can Deer Call
  • 5 out of 5
    Our rating
  • The best known deer call on the market, praised for its ease of use
  • Price: See Here
Primos Hardwood Grunter Call
  • Primos Hardwood Grunter Call
  • 5 out of 5
    Our rating
  • Beautifully crafted hardwood deer call used for different types of deer
  • Price: See Here

10 Best Deer Calls

 

1. Flextone All-N-One

1. Flextone All-N-One
And the #1 spot goes to All-N-One deer Call from Flextone, which narrowly beat out Primos. Hunters are familiar with both the brand and the model, yet it still doesn’t get the recognition it deserves. The All-N-One is absolute perfection once you’re used to it, with the company providing a pretty deep manual.
Expand to see more
It’s Like An Instrument

And plays like one too thanks to volume buttons and call buttons. Flextone puts the power of the call in the hands of the hunter, but allows a more streamlined experience with the way they set up the buttons on their deer call. Out of all the manual calling learning experiences, this one in particular keeps the users interest. You’ll wake up every day wanting to be better at using the calls.

Features and Specifications

  • Fawn, Doe and Young Buck buttons

  • Mature Buck can be called just by blowing

  • Weighs 2.6 ounces

  • Dimensions are 8x5x1.5

  • Soft flexible base


Price/Value

So far it idles in the low cost range with other competing products. Buyers pretty much get a 5-6 in 1 deer call when they purchase the All-N-One, so the value is tremendous.

Decision Time

Ease of use played a big role in making this the best deer call on the list. Even in a time when Primo is dominating the market, Flextone is providing some serious competition from their side of the fence.
Pros

Buttons are clearly marked

Soft exterior means it can take some punishment

Lanyard attached so you can carry it on your wrist

Takes minimal experience to master

Cons

Sound can get a bit drowned in a busy hunting environment

2. Primos The Original Can

2. Primos The Original Can
With all of the advanced deer calls on the list, how does one of the older and simpler products in Primos’ line make the list? It turns out this is still one of their bestsellers, and is used by hunters daily. It goes beyond being a traditional choice and offers the most basic functions with the highest rate of success.
Expand to see more
The Best Of All Time

Many have tried to take the title of best deer call of all time, but all have failed to match the lifetime sales of The Original Can. It is the single most bought deer call in Primos history, and is still racking up impressive numbers. Even if dee calls come along that beat it in accuracy tests, they will never unseat its sales record.

Features and Specifications

  • Raised thumb hole locator

  • Rubberized top and bottom

  • Works for Whitetail, Mule Deer and Blacktail

  • Weighs 3.4 ounces

  • Dimensions are 5.9x3.9x2.4


Price/Value

At this rate if you haven’t purchased a Primos Deer Call Can for hunting then you’re missing out. Any hunter that has never owned one should buy it, even if you’ll be using it for backup. The price is low as always, and gives off some really authentic sounds.

Decision Time

A lot of new hunters found out about this wonderful product too late in its life cycle. That still didn’t stop them from purchasing it and continuing to contribute to the dominant legacy that Primos started.
Pros

Gives the sound of realistic Estrus Bleats

Small and non-slip design

Can take a major beating

Sound is consistent without needing a manual

Easy to pick up and use

Cons

Call can be a little bit low

3. Primos Hardwood Grunter

3. Primos Hardwood Grunter
Primos makes the list again with one of their most beloved products, the Hardwood Grunter Call. This is the most professional looking deer call on the list, and just feels right at home with any hardcore hunter. Compared to the other deer calls on the list, this one has remained consistently good through the years for calling enticing prey.
Expand to see more
Quality In Both Looks And Feel

The draw for this deer call is not just about the name, and is more towards how it looks. Primos used the finest materials when making the Hardwood Grunter Call. Inside and out is nothing but solid construction, so if by chance you do a little damage to it over the years it’ll still be useful.

Features and Specifications

  • 6 in 1 adjustable

  • Made out of hardwood

  • Hose is expandable

  • Weighs 1.6 ounces

  • Dimensions are 2.5x1x9


Price/Value

Primos keeps to its vision surrounding all of the products on their line, and the Hardwood Grunter Call is low cost. Even with its premium grade wood design, the price isn’t raised and customers get a good deal for the money.

Decision Time

Basic design, traditional wood stylings and an incredible hunt. These are all things you should love about owning a Primos Hardwood Grunter Call. It won’t let you down, and will be one of the best things in your accessory pack.
Pros

Best looking deer call on the list

Requires only a little practice

Hardwood gives it an official feel

All 6 calls sound great from long distances

Cons

Expandable hose can be a pain to adjust

4. Extinguisher & Black Rack

4. Extinguisher & Black Rack
As Seen on TV items can be a bit flaky when they are not reviewed properly. So it comes as a surprise to see one of those items make it at #4 on the list, with the Extinguisher & Black Rack Calling System being on an entirely different level than other deer calls. Hunters are still finding out about how to maximize this great device, with a small following claiming it is the best deer call ever.
Expand to see more
Take A Look At The DVD

The 2 in 1 instructional DVD is a requirement, even if you are an experienced hunter. They don’t beat you over the head with simple stuff so it’s quite enjoyable to watch-once. After that one time, you’ll know everything important about your new deer call and how to use it.

Features and Specifications

  • Patented ModiSlide technology

  • 6% NAHC Field Test approval rating

  • FreezeFree Design

  • Dual layered Throat-Tube

  • Bone-Core technology rattling system


Price/Value

This is the most expensive deer call on the list, but also the most advanced. People either love it or hate it, so the best way to figure it out is to try it for yourself. It’s a really good product that automates a lot of important calls.

Decision Time

Don’t let the average craftsmanship scare you off from a device that is still unbeaten in several deer calling tests. Hunters will have no trouble finding a place for this in their current arsenal of deer calls.
Pros

The included DVD is professional in quality

Has the world’s highest rating for a deer call

Rattling sounds are just as realistic

New uses are still being discovered

Cons

Incredible features have a hit or miss quality

Craftsmanship a step below Primos brand

5. Knight & Hale Pack Rack

5. Knight & Hale Pack Rack
The Pack Rack Deer Call looks a little bit different than the other deer calls on the list but has the same base functions. Combining years of experience with a little bit of innovative design has created a pretty nifty piece of equipment. So far, hunters are having a pretty good time with it.
Expand to see more
Compact & Silent

When a deer call is portable that doesn’t automatically make it silent while transporting. In a worst case scenario you could have your prey running away from all the noise a deer call is making in your pocket. The Pack Rack Deer Call is made to be completely silent while transporting, thus avoiding unintentional noises.

Features and Benefits

  • High density plastic

  • Loud volume when rattling

  • Can be put into silent mode while traveling

  • Olive-drab color

  • Weighs 6.4 ounces


Price/Value

There are hunters that swear by this model, and it’s inexpensive enough to where it’s worth the money. Buyers shouldn’t consider this a risk since the price is so low for getting one.

Decision Time

If the materials had been reinforced a little bit more, then it could have been higher on the list. Even with low durability this is still one of the more effective deer calls you can get.
Pros

Compact size lets you take it anywhere

Blends in well with other camouflage designs

Lightweight and easy to use

Sound carries when in use over long distances

Cons

Plastic wears out over the years

Water exposure could lessen its effectiveness

6. Primos Buck Roar

6. Primos Buck Roar
The Primos Buck Roar Call won’t win any design contests, but it does the job just fine. Once again industry leader Primos has made the list, with this iteration of their product having some noteworthy improvements. It’ll be up to hunters to decide if this product is worth replacing their current deer call.
Expand to see more
Getting The Grunt Right

With all the talks of getting sounds correct for deer calls, some in the industry only get close. The Primos Buck Roar Call is perfectly authentic, loud and aggressive. It’s a pitch for pitch performance of a buck during the rut. The effectiveness of the deer call is sometimes scary!

Features and Specifications

  • Straps to wrist or arm

  • Challenge-Wheeze is mounted to the call

  • Is the loudest Challenge-Wheeze available

  • Weighs 1.6 ounces

  • Portable


Pros

  • Comes with instructional DVD

  • Multiple roars to go through

  • As authentic as it gets

  • Easier to handle than other deer calls


Cons

  • The wrong sequence can scare off your prey

  • Takes a little bit of practice


Price/Value

Primos always does well when it comes to pricing their products. The Buck Roar Call is low priced, and is a bit more forgiving than other manual deer calls. Beginners will master this one faster than the others on the list.

Decision Time

With the right grunt you can have a full grown prey right in your sights. Getting it right only takes a few days, and will give you hunting memories that last a lifetime.
Pros

Comes with instructional DVD

Multiple roars to go through

As authentic as it gets

Easier to handle than other deer calls

Cons

The wrong sequence can scare off your prey

Takes a little bit of practice

7. Hunters Specialties True Talker

7. Hunters Specialties True Talker
Hunter’s Specialties went all in with their True Talker Deer Call. The design, functionality and user friendliness are all part of making this the one of the most effective deer calls in the industry. With a few minor quirks here and there, few people have had complaints about its effectiveness.
Expand to see more
Instructions Are A Must

A lot of manual use goes into making this the perfect weapon against deer. Without a little practice or trial and error, most users will end up regretting their purchase. The instruction manual pulls no punches in how to operate the equipment, and is the best thing about this item.

Features and Specifications

  • Tone and pitch are authentic

  • Produces full range of deer sounds

  • Fingertip controls let you control the call

  • Lanyard included

  • Portable


Price/Value

Like all manual deer calls, this product depends on how good the hunter is with mastering its calls. The included manual sheds some light on how to use the product, and with its low price should be worth the time of all levels of hunters.

Decision Time

Old School hunters that are looking for a successor to the original True Talker may have just found the answer. Just make sure to read the instructions or you’ll be in for a lot of frustration.
Pros

Instructions are concise and to the point

Deer call can fit in your pocket

Finger controls let you go through a wide range of calls and inflection

Takes less practice than other manual calling methods

Cons

Takes some time to master

Rubber housing can be annoying

8. Primos Big Bucks

8. Primos Big Bucks
Sometimes traditional is always the best, or at the very least the most trusted. Primos offers the Big Bucks Bag Call for hunters that don’t want to bother with electronic deer calls. This product works remarkably well, and is a favorite of thousands of hunters worldwide.
Expand to see more
Brand Name Quality

Primos is known for always having a hunters back. The Big Bucks Bag Call is a good reason why hunters love the company. They can do both traditional and innovative products, putting them in a very unique category. When you buy a Primos product you get a quality buy for life.

Features and Specifications

  • Two sets of Power Tines

  • Tone holes included

  • 100% Waterproof

  • Camonet bag can be used to make it louder

  • Elastic strap prevents unintentional use


Pros

  • Stronger than other bag calls on the market

  • Made of high grade sturdy material

  • About 10-11 inches long

  • Camonet bag makes a big difference if you’re in an open area


Cons

  • Bag may be a little weak

  • Not for beginners


Price/Value

This is one of the cheapest deer calls you can buy, and it works. The value problem comes into play when you think about the hunter that is using it. Inexperienced hunters will more than likely scare away deer, making this a bad buy until they get used to the sequence.

Decision Time

Experienced hunters at some point in their travels have used a set like this before, and they swear by it. In the right hands the Primos Big Bucks Bag Call will be the only deer call equipment you ever need.
Pros

Stronger than other bag calls on the market

Made of high grade sturdy material

About 10-11 inches long

Camonet bag makes a big difference if you’re in an open area

Cons

Bag may be a little weak

Not for beginners

9. Primos Hunting Speak Easy

9. Primos Hunting Speak Easy
Hunters that like things to be a little more automated with their deer calling have had good success with this Primos system. It’s a no hassle electronic deer calling system that covers all of the important sounds to get you started.
Expand to see more
Wireless Remote Control

Being able to lure out deer while in a completely different location will let hunters set up for a perfect shot. They can also create chaos in bunkers, or high up in a tree. The options are unlimited, and all thanks to this wireless remote option.

Features and Specifications

  • 50 Yard range for remote control

  • One AAA battery required

  • Speaker clips included

  • 6 Prerecorded calls

  • LED volume indicator

  • Rubber straps included

  • Price/Value

    The price is low, so this is a tricky one. The crutch of the device is the speaker attachment and its ability to be heard by your prey. A savvy hunter will be able to amplify the speaker sound and make the purchase worth it.

    Decision Time

    It may require a little tweaking, but with some patience this will make hunting a lot easier. Just make sure to be mindful of where you put the speaker attachment.
Pros

Only one battery required

Calls sound realistic

Pick up and use operation

Speaker attachment can be mounted anywhere

Cons

There is some dependence on the hunter to get the pitch right

A bit bulky to carry around compared to other models

10. Hunters Specialties 00412

10. Hunters Specialties 00412
First up on the list is the trusty Nemesis, with a simple design to get the attention of your prey. This is a proven product that has a nice loud pitch to it, and is pretty good at the one job it is expected to do. Since the sounds have to be realistic as possible, practice makes perfect with this product.
Expand to see more
Pricing

It may seem simplistic, but a lot price for a one use item is a must unless that item is the best of its class. The Nemesis is a good product that gets the job done, nothing more, and nothing less. Hunters Specialties priced it according to its usefulness and really did a great job in reading their customers.

Features and Specialties

  • Doe bleats

  • Young buck grunts

  • Rutting buck grunts

  • Mature buck grunts

  • Twist to select call type

  • Expandable bellows helps with inflection


  • Price/Value

    As mentioned before, the price is perfect. The potential of the value will come down to whether the hunter is experienced or new. An experienced hunter should be fine adjusting the few settings and making the call correctly.

    Decision Time

    Some beginners may shy away from this manual model, but it is tested and proven. When you want realistic deer calling sounds, this comes out to be one of the better buys in the industry.
Pros

Changing your inflection is easy

Sounds are realistic

Price is exactly where it needs to be

Twistable mouthpiece is great for changing calls

Cons

There is some dependence on the hunter to get the pitch right

A bit bulky to carry around compared to other models

FAQs

Do Deer Calls Work 100% Of The Time?

No, and there will never be one that is designed to do so. A deer call is not a dog whistle, so deer have free reign to come or go when they hear your sounds.

Why Not Just Stick To Primos?

They do have the most consistent track record in the game, but they didn’t make the top spot. And if you look further down the list, there are some real innovations. Just for tradition, hunters should always have a Primos Original Can as a backup if they have a primary deer call.

Is Durability Important?

Durability does play a factor in what deer call you want to purchase. When you’re out hunting there is a great risk of damaging equipment. Even though all of the items on the top ten list are mostly low cost deer calls, it’s still a frustrating experience to deal with your equipment breaking. Clumsy or rough hunters will want to pay close attention to how durable a deer call is before making a decision.

Will The Deer Hear It?

Deers have great hearing, even when things are a little busy in the area. Some dear calls on the list allow you to adjust the volume which is great for noisier settings. Other than that, your best bet is to move in closer so they can pick up the sound.