Top 10 Turtleneck Sweaters Reviewed for Comfort & Style
- Utopia Wear Standard
- Port Authority Interlock Knit Mock
- Utopia Wear Cotton Blend
- PattyBoutik Turtleneck Lace Blouse
- Devon & Jones Suede Cotton
- Herou Women's Turtleneck
- Port & Company Mock PC61M
- H2h Slim Fit Basic Ribbed
- Terramar Cloud Nine Turtleneck
- Leif Nelson Faux Leather Pullover
- Maks Supersoft Relaxfit
- Match Casual Basic Knitted
- Leif Nelson Knit Designer Pullover
- Coofandy Ribbed Slim Fit Knitted
- Ohoo Men's Slim Fit Turtleneck
Criteria Used for Evaluation
Of the popular turtleneck sweaters out there, cotton seems to be the main material used for them. Sometimes, it’s a mixture of cotton and a man-made fiber like polyester. Sometimes it’s 100% acrylic fiber. You might also get wool from sheep, goats, or alpacas. But it’s mainly cotton.
Cotton, the soft and fluffy fiber that surrounds the seed of the plant, mainly grows in the (sub)tropical parts of the Americas, Africa, and Asia. Traces of the use of cotton could be found in India between 6000 and 5000 BC. It’s been the fiber of choice through the centuries; especially during the bad-old eras of slave labor and “cotton kingdoms.” It’s still considered the fiber of choice today, followed by wool and man-made synthetic fibers.
Cotton, however, just like with wool, is susceptible to external forces in the outside world. Harmful insects and weed are still problematic for the production of cotton. As is climate change and environmental damage caused by unregulated industries.
The cotton that does survive (most or all of them) get harvested, separated from the seeds, and baled for transportation. When they get to where they need to go, they are processed to make sure that the impurities are removed. After being cleaned and combed, they’re ready to be turned into clothing materials.
The cottonseed will be turned into cottonseed oil (like vegetable oil) and cottonseed meal. The meal is crushed cottonseed that has the oil extracted; it’s given as feed to “ruminant” (multi-stomached) animals like cattle, sheep, and goats. (During the American slave era, the cottonseed was used as a folk remedy to induce miscarriage in women and made the men’s sperm weak.)
Wool relies less on slavery, yet it’s not a good friend to vegans who don’t like wearing anything from animals. Wool, however, is great for wicking moisture off and letting it evaporate into the air; compared to cotton which is mainly good for absorbing moisture. Wool is considered the best material all around, yet cotton is deemed better for heavy and stylish winter sweaters.
There’s a healthy supply of wool; the animals that have been domesticated for growing wool need to be sheared of it yearly. Else, the wool will get in the way of their eyes, ears, reproductive organs, and mobility. The wool is then taken to manufacturing plants where they are washed of impurities, combed, and prepared to be turned into textiles.
There’s an ongoing case from animal rights groups about the procedure called “mulesing,” the removal of wool-bearing skin from the sheep's’ butts in order to make sure the larva of parasitic flies don’t slowly kill them from the inside out. The area (usually around the genitals and anus) that has its skin removed won’t grow any more wool, removing the risk of flies affecting the area. This issue is mainly found in Australia where “flystrike” is common. But despite the fact that up to three million sheep could suffer from slow, agonizing death without mulesing, animal rights groups still call this practice unethical. There are efforts right now to either make the practice more ethical or outright ban it.
Sometimes, you’ll find said fibers as a small percentage of a mixture of the natural fiber (like wool or cotton) to help strengthen a textile. Other times, there are clothes that are made of 100% synthetic fiber(s). During the times of war and rationing, synthetic fibers were considered a necessary replacement for natural fibers. (Since, you know. Places that grow cotton or keep herds of sheep tend to get blown up and used as war zones.)
Cellulose from wood was the first man-made fiber (while not being truly synthetic). It was created in the early 1880s by chemist Joseph Swan. French engineer/industrialist Hilaire de Chardonnet created synthetic silk in an effort to replace the silkworms that had been dying off from epidemics. But his silk was too flammable so something else needed to be created.
In 1894, England’s Charles Frederick Cross, Edward John Bevan, and Clayton Beadle created Rayon, a synthetic fiber that relied on a vicious chemical (carbon disulfide) to create it. DuPont, in the 1930s, created Nylon to replace silk. It’s used for women’s stockings but it’s mainly useful in military equipment like parachutes and ropes. In 1941, the British chemical company Calico Printers’ Association created their first polyesters. And other companies (like DuPont) would follow suit.
The advantages of synthetic fibers include water and stain resistance, stretching, and durability. They are also less resource-intensive than wool and cotton. The disadvantages are that they have a low melting point, cause allergies to some people, and cause more electrostatic activity than wool and cotton. They’re not very environment-friendly to make either: The chemical plants that create them tend to do a lot of polluting into the surrounding areas if left unregulated.
The more famous synthetic fibers are Nylon, Acrylic, Polyester, Rayon, Spandex, and Aramids like Kevlar.
The type of sweater you want usually depends on its purpose (among other things). Do you want an outside sweater that can help you survive the cold? Or do you want one that’s easy to use while you’re laying around the house? And if you are going to use an outside sweater, do you want one that just keeps you warm? Or do you want one that’s tough enough to survive the harsh environment? There are differences between the layering sweater you wear while tracking down deer in grueling wildlife weather and that tacky Christmas sweater with an image of a deer puking; that one you wear around the house while all your other clothes are in the laundry.
Wool isn’t really considered the most durable fiber to have as a sweater. While it’s inexpensive to buy and could be found in every thrift store, it’s also part of moths’ balanced meal. (So it’s best to use mothballs if you have wool clothing.) Wool is still usable for days that are either cold or extremely cold. But if you’re willing to spend more money, don’t be afraid to get the alternatives.
Cotton is the second least durable. Sometimes, cotton is mixed with man-made fibers to strengthen its durability. People enjoy cotton because of its natural feel and softness. However, it’s a natural fiber (just like wool). Ringspun cotton is born from an effort to compact the cotton strands and increase its durability. By twisting the cotton strands and thinning them, the ropes of cotton fibers are strengthened without its softness being sacrificed.
Synthetic / Man-Made Fibers are great because of their increased durability and (for animal lovers) the heavily reduced use of living animals. Unfortunately, the trade-off can come at the heavy price of the body and the environment. The chemicals needed to create the fibers, and the possible byproducts created afterward, are mainly known to be hazardous waste materials and must be dealt with properly. Ongoing news has shown that some companies are unable to deal with hazardous waste properly. Also, accidents DO happen.
Rayon is cellulose processed from recycled wood pulp and turned into fabric. So it can be considered the third less durable. Acrylic is usually used in paint, but it can also be used as fiber for clothing. It’s durable despite being lightweight. Nylon is made out of petroleum. But it was quick to come in handy during the time the US entered World War 2. Polyester is the most durable of the famous man-made fibers; stain-resistant and quick to dry. But it’s also quick to heat up during the summer, making the wearer feel uncomfortable.
The best way to go is to buy sweaters that consist of a percentage of a natural fiber mixed with a percentage of synthetic fibers. If it’s 100% natural, nature will find a way to destroy it. If it’s 100% synthetic, you’ll be at the mercy of chemical unpleasantries. Try to find the middle ground so you can get the best of both worlds.
Looking cool in a turtleneck sweater is also important; just as important as keeping warm. Needless to say (but should be said anyway), turtlenecks are great because they’re also able to keep your neck warm.
Men can look as great in a turtleneck sweater as women. It just takes the right amount of style. Make it part of a business suit attire. Or your sweater can make a good counter-balance for your light blue jeans. Try that “serious” look with a turtleneck under a vest and a trenchcoat. That “blues musician” look with a light-colored turtleneck under a grey plaid 3-piece suit. Or that “Matrix” look with a dark turtleneck, black biker jacket, and navy overcoat.
15 Best Turtleneck Sweaters
1. Utopia Wear Standard
As simple as it gets. Utopia Wear surely aims to be the utopia of clothing, and this hits the mark. Clean, simple, blank design. Made of an almost perfectly balanced match between cotton and polyester, this turtleneck sweater manages to be a perfect fit for almost everyone. The material is stretchy and thin, and while it will keep you just barely warm, it is breathable and very easy to clean.
You won’t get hot and sweaty in this, it’s guaranteed. Feel free to layer two of these ones over the other if you want to feel warmer though.
This sweater will stubbornly remain the same size as the day you got it, no matter how many times you try to wash it. It’s a sweater with a size set in stone – because Utopia Wear took the time and shrunk it before they sold it to you. We approve and only wish everyone did this!
- 45% Polyester and 55% Cotton
- Durable and soft
- Fits easy and comes in US sizes
- Fabric that allows the skin to breathe
- Machine washable
2. Port Authority Interlock Knit Mock
Not to be confused with (quasi-) governmental institutes that supervise sea-bound ports and the participating infrastructures; Port Authority Clothing goes out of its way to make sure that the clothing created by them is "sweatshop-free." Meaning that, for those who are concerned, the products you purchase from Port Authority haven't been made by some severely underpaid group of people at some unknown, yet volatile, part of the world.
Keeps You Nice And Warm
This turtleneck is awesome when it comes to giving you extra warmth and layering. It's "100% cotton with added spandex for some stretching." So it's not really "100% cotton;" probably a larger percentage of cotton and some percentage of spandex.
A Variety Of Sizes
This turtleneck ranges include extra-small, small, medium, large, extra-large, XXL, XXXL, 4XL, 5XL, and 6XL. So anybody in any size can be able to get a turtleneck that's the right size.
- 100% Ringspun Combed Cotton
- Cover-Seamed Neck
- Ribbed Knit Collar & Cuffs With Spandex
- Garment-Reinforcing Locker Patch
- Double-Needled Collar & Hem
3. Utopia Wear Cotton Blend
Utopia Wear still remains at the top of the charts for the people's choice in turtleneck sweaters. And lightning strikes twice... Or maybe the better term should be; "the second onslaught of snow commences" with their interlocking mock turtlenecks.
UW is a sub-company under Utopia Deals; a company that's also responsible for the sales of bedding, kitchenware, fitness products, healthcare products, and other household items. Their company is stationed in New York; but it's also well-known in Canada, China, and Pakistan.
55% Cotton / 45% Polyester
This blend of pre-shrunk cotton and polyester ensures that you get a turtleneck sweater that's durable, long-lasting, and ready for machine washing. (Avoid steam-washing, dry-cleaning, and the use of fabric softener since it might do damage to the materials.)
Knitted & Stitched To Perfection
The materials used for this turtleneck sweater are also lightweight and super-soft; ensuring that you'll look great all season long. It's been stitched with care to make sure that you're able to move around in it without any restrictions.
- It comes in a variety of sizes.
- Breathable fabric.
- Made from combed yarn.
- Able to maintain temperatures in cold and hot seasons.
4. PattyBoutik Turtleneck Lace Blouse
This uniquely styled women’s turtleneck from PattyBoutik is a perfect blend of style, elegance, and practicality. The form-fitting fabric is made of 94% rayon and 6% spandex to give you a comfortable fit while remaining flexible for easy mobility. The long sleeves feature a beautiful lace design that runs up the shoulders for a look that is sexy and fun. You can choose from three different colors and is a great choice for casual and festive settings.
This item is made from a special fabric blend that creates a wonderful look, but also requires special care. You need to hand-wash it to ensure that it keeps its form and so that the lace doesn’t get damaged.
Most people think of turtlenecks as a practical and functional piece of clothing designed to keep you warm during the cold winter months. PattyBoutik has taken it to the next level of fashion with a sexy, yet conservative, lace design along the sleeve and shoulders.
- Made from 94% rayon and 6% spandex and the lace is made of 85% cotton and 15% nylon
- Comes in three different colors including blacks, navy blue, and burgundy
- Form-fitting cut
- Lace design runs up the sleeve and shoulders
5. Devon & Jones Suede Cotton
Yet another company that doesn't have a website; choosing to sell their clothing and accessories via online shops and department stores. The goal of Devin & Jones had been found at one site though; to blow the doors off of their competitors.
Devin & Jones' goal is to be the best; equating to, if not going above, the best known and most prestigious clothing and accessory designers out there.
Plush Tanguis cotton that's been cultivated in Peru, grown and turned into fabric, and brushed into perfection. The grey heather-colored sweater is 90% cotton and 10% polyester.
Comes In Several Colors
Along with the grey heather; there's navy blue, white, black, crimson, dill green, and forest green.
- Double-Needled Stitching Throughout
- Spandex In The Collar & Cuffs
- Side Vents
- Sizes from Extra-Small to 4X-Large
6. Herou Women's Turtleneck
This long sleeve t-shirt is a great choice for wearing around the home or as a layer underneath a sweater or jacket for extra warmth. It’s made from a special blend of fabric that allows it to be lightweight, soft, and elastic for the ultimate in comfort. It comes at a pretty low price and the turtleneck design helps keep the wind and cold out without being too tight.
Modal fabric is a semi-synthetic rayon that was engineered to be soft and stretchy, making it an ideal fabric for high-quality activewear. These tops are made with modal fabric, which allows it to be lightweight and soft on the skin, yet elastic and durable at the same time.
Many women find that these types of tops are usually too tight and revealing, or too loose an unappealing. Herou has found a perfect balance with its design that flatters your curves and can be worn during your everyday routines.
- Fabric is made from 100% modal
- Comes in nine different colors
- Feminine cut for a flattering look
- Needs to be hand-washed
7. Port & Company Mock PC61M
If you own a company that makes clothing and you have multiple brands under your wings, then it's really difficult to keep a product or more (that works so well) under one brand. For example, the mock turtleneck that's featured under the Port Authority brand.
Port & Company, Port Authority, District Clothing (women's wear), Sport-Tek (sportswear), Red House (business wear), and Cornerstone (construction/workwear) each have separate websites. None of them have "About Us" pages that give out their storylines and placement in the world of clothing. District Clothing, however, gives us a physical address that is somewhere east of Seattle, Washington. A nice bit of info considering how few of the clothing companies hardly have any websites at all.
A Variety Of Colors
You'll notice right away the several shades and colors being featured in this mock turtleneck sweater. The colors also featured is "Kelly" (which is a lighter tint of green) and "Athletic Heather" (which is a lighter shade of grey).
90% Cotton / 10% Polyester
The blurb says that it's 100% cotton, but maybe that blurb had sorta been changed to address the complaints about how saying "100% cotton" is a lie. Don't let that bring you down, though. The material being used for the turtleneck sweater is still the highly durable, long-lasting material you can come to rely on for those cold-weather days and nights.
- Cover-seamed mock turtleneck.
- Shoulder-to-shoulder taping.
- Spandex in the collar and cuffs for extra stretch and comfort.
- Double-needle collar and hem.
- Variety of sizes from Small to 4XL.
8. H2h Slim Fit Basic Ribbed
H2H is a Korean manufacturer, so naturally, expect sizes fitting the Asian market. With that being said, this is truly an excellent turtleneck sweater. It’s made from 80% cotton but 20% polyester as well, which makes it a slim, snug fit, and the ribbed design of the material enhances its thermal properties. While it may look more on the thin end, it will definitely keep you warmer than expected. H2H offers a variety of colors for this sweater.
Ribbed Thermal Design
This turtleneck sweater will keep you warm thanks to its clever design. Don’t let the thin look fool you.
The slim fit design will be a joy to many, but it can also be a turn off for some. To each their own, but this is definitely a very stylish piece of clothing.
- 80% Cotton / 20% Polyester
- Men's Slim-Fit Basic Designed Turtleneck Pullover Sweaters
- Slim fit, long sleeve, basic designed and solid colors, ribbed cotton fabric, lightweight thermal pullover sweaters
- Hand wash recommended
9. Terramar Cloud Nine Turtleneck
If you enjoy outdoor activities like skiing and mountaineering, then you’ll want functional clothing that can keep you protected from the outside elements while provides comfort and mobility. The Cloud Nine top is the ultimate in activewear. It has a super-soft surface that promotes airflow, a UPF rating of 25+ for sun protection, and special technology that increases drying and wicking.
When you’re out in the extreme cold, it is important that you maintain your body’s temperature in order to perform properly. Terramar uses a patented design called Climasense that traps heat when you are cool and releases moisture vapor when your temperature rises.
The fabric is made from a blend of 86% polyester and 14% spandex which has been brushed to create a super-soft surface. This is not only very comfortable on the skin but also helps increase breathability.
- Constructed from 86% polyester and 14% spandex
- Fast drying and wicking technology
- Super-soft brushed surface
- Function thumbholes
- Sun protection
10. Leif Nelson Faux Leather Pullover
Leif Nelson was started by three brothers in 1999; their goal's to create clothing that hits the fashion scene so hard that it makes a mark in your closet or wardrobe collection. They have a Facebook page and it's all in German. Google-translate it, and it also explains how they made a hit in the activewear as well. Leif Nelson Gym is the name of that spin-off. Leif Nelson boasts vintage looks with the classic taste.
This man-made synthetic fiber, usually found working alongside wool in other clothes, ensures that this turtleneck sweater will last long without sacrificing style points. Lightweight, warm, soft; unable to shrink or wrinkle.
Faux Leather Accents
Great for those who like to look cool in leather but don't have it in you to wear the skin of dead animals. The faux leather accents add enough style points to the suave-looking designer collar; making you look like you just walked off the "Paris fashion show" runway.
- High-Quality Construction
- Durable Material
- Ease Of Maintenance
- Stylish Design
- Made In Europe
11. Maks Supersoft Relaxfit
And now here's a turtleneck sweater for those who'd rather hit the slopes instead of being inside the warm, cozy room all day. The Relaxfit Turtleneck is brought to you by Maks, another mysterious company that sells its clothing via online shops yet is kind enough to give everyone an informative blurb about what they're selling.
100% Combed Cotton
(Except for the grey heather, which is 80% cotton and 20% polyester.) It's soft to the touch, stretchy, breathable, and can either be worn as the main sweater during the spring or one of the layers during the extremely cold winter. It has low shrinkage in the wash (less than 3%), but the company asks not to wash in hot water. So it's cold wash and tumbles dry all the way.
A Variety Of Colors & Sizes
Up to nine different colors. And (European) sizes ranging from small to 3X-Large. Never say that you didn't have a wide variety of choices here.
- Double-hammered reinforced flat seams.
- Interlocking knit construction.
- Relax/loose fit great for layering.
- Medium weight.
12. Match Casual Basic Knitted
Yet another mysterious company. But this time, the reason is that the word "match" is used everywhere. The Match clothing line (if you search online) has nothing to do with helix stereo systems, coloring utensils, repair tape, or anything like that. The company uses a logo that's much more refined and stylized. Neither does it have anything to do with Matches Fashion.
Colors & Sizes
One thing you'll notice right away is the variety of colors and sizes to fit your taste. So you can always settle for something that's available if your favorite color didn't come in the exact size. (Be careful: The size is based on Asian sizes. So, say, a "Medium" there would be "Extra Small" in the US.)
This turtleneck sweater is knitted and made out of 100% cotton. It's soft, warm, comfortable, and adds a slight stretch. It's also machine washable as long as you don't add bleach to clean it.
- Good-quality, medium-weight cotton.
- Slim-fit pullover collar.
- It comes in 2 available collar styles; traditional turtleneck, or shawl collar with a button.
13. Leif Nelson Knit Designer Pullover
The three brothers from Leif Nelson strike again. This time, with a turtleneck sweater that's "EXTRA THICK." This sweater might be mistaken for a hoodie jacket; front hand-warmer "kangaroo pouch" and all. But this sweater's been designed in mind for the "fashion-conscious urban men."
Leif Nelson utilized this man-made fabric to create the best urban sweater they can. Acrylic may be an inexpensive replacement for natural cashmere, but the sweater itself doesn't come cheap.
Variety Of Sizes
Leif Nelson's knit sweaters don't have much in terms of colors. (Currently, there are three of them.) But rest assured; when you're able to figure out the European-to-US sizes, you'll find one that fits you perfectly.
- Thumb loops.
- Extended back hem.
- Drawstrings at front of the collar with a metal end.
- Hand-warmer "kangaroo pouch."
14. Coofandy Ribbed Slim Fit Knitted
Coofandy is yet another company that's not afraid to admit that it's based in China. It's one of those Chinese companies that prove to the rest of the world how self-sufficient and resilient they can be. (Building manufacturing plants in jungles and "nowhere-lands" that border Kazakhstan is newsworthy and nothing to sneeze at.) Coofandy designs clothing for men who are independent, confident, and uplifting in their spirit.
50% cotton, 50% polyester; all soft and durable. The two fibers, one of them's natural and the other's man-made, interlock to create a material that's thick and long-lasting. (Remember to wash it by hand and dry it by hanging.)
This classic ribbed knit design ensures the thickness and warmth needed to keep you moving in the cold. The turtleneck collar continues with the thickness and keeps your neck warm as well.
- Variety of colors and sizes.
- High end knit process.
- It does not shrink.
- Thick cotton knit trim.
15. Ohoo Men's Slim Fit Turtleneck
This classic, mixed ribbed men’s pullover from Ohoo is made from a 50% cotton and 50% polyester blend to give you a soft and durable top. The tabbed hem and sleeves help keep the cool air out while providing a snug fit. The slim fit design is made to hug the shape of your body, if you want something looser then order a size larger.
Standard US Sizes
Many people are hesitant to buy clothing over the internet because of sizing problems. Ohoo offers this top in five standard US sizes and seven different colors, making sure that you not only find something that fits, but also something that matches your style.
One of the main reasons people purchase this type of top is because of the extra protection and warmth you get from a covered neck. You’ll get an ample amount of fabric that can be folded over and still offer enhanced coverage.
- Made from a blend of 50% cotton and 50% polyester
- Ribbed hem and sleeves for extra protection
- Slim fit cut
- Features ample turtleneck fabric