Best Toasters Reviewed & Rated for Quality
Toast, bagels, frozen pastries, and thick bread are all foods that most people love and can be made quickly, just by popping them into a toaster and grabbing them when they pop back up. Toasted foods are great in the mornings when you’re in a hurry and need to get out the door. You pop two, or four, pieces of bread into the toaster, slather some jelly on it and eat it on the way to work or school. Easy-peasy, right? Hmm, sometimes, not so much if the toaster doesn’t toast evenly or you have to dig the toast out with a fork when it’s done, which is dangerous by the way, so please don’t try it.
- Extra Wide Slots
- LED Panel
- Increased Toasting Efficiency
In this buying guide, you will find the top 10 best toasters on the market today, rated and reviewed for quality. From design and appeal to functionality and safety, this list will judge the toasters based on certain metrics and criteria. Tired of unevenly toasted toast? Can’t choose between two or four slice toasters? Not sure whether to buy an expensive toaster with all the bells and whistles or a basic one that just does the job right? If you have any of these questions in mind, then follow along as this list rates the top toasters in order from one to ten. Ready to see the first product on the list? Okay, without further ado, here is the first product on the list!
10 Best Toasters
Toast isn't the only thing that's put in a toaster in the mornings anymore. You can turn the settings up and down on the dial to get the desired shade for your toasting pleasure. This toaster even includes a bagel option, that will adjust the time it toasts according to the thickness of the bagel.
Extra Wide Slots
The toaster features extra-wide slots, so you no longer have to cram bagels down into the slots and hope they toast. The extra-wide slots can accommodate different varieties of food and the slots are also extra-long to help as well.
Cost and Value
The sleek design and metallic finish add to the value of the toaster, as it will not look out of place in any kitchen, traditional or modern. The added bonus of extra-wide slots and 7 adjustable settings catapulted this toaster to the top of the list for cost and value.
Seven shade settings
Simple to clean
Accepts thicker sliced bread
One of the best features about this toaster is the LED toasting indicator that lets you know how your toast is doing. No longer do you have to stand and lift the lever to check your toast for brownness.
This toaster features five settings to ensure your toast is done the way you like it, then it has something a little different. It has settings for "lift and look" and "a bit more." With its one-touch technology, this toaster is one for the ages.
Cost and Value
With its five setting, LED toasting indicator and one-touch design, this toaster is well-worth the money you spend. It takes the toaster to a whole new level of performance. This one is worth it in value and cost.
- Intelligent one touch
- Modern looking
- Large toaster
- Evenly toasts
- Fire hazard
While it comes in different color choices, the toaster has an awesome old-fashioned look to it. It combines sophistication with simplicity in a way that can't be copied anywhere else.
Extra-Wide 28mm Slots
The best feature about this toast is the extra-wide 28mm slots that are perfect for toasting anything from homemade bread to sandwiches.
Cost and Value
With the extra-wide slots for toasting and the fact that you have a choice of 26 color varieties, this toaster is worth it in cost and value. Combined with the ProHeat elements, removable crumb tray, and the adjustable rear foot and you have a winner for sure.
- Extra-wide slots
- Old-fashioned design
- Adjustable rear foot
- Toasts to perfection
- Lasts for years
- Toasts unevenly
4. Pangea Brands
This toaster features extra-wide slots that are perfect for toasting any type of bread. Put your bread in and watch it pop out of the Death Star, perfectly browned and ready to eat.
Removable Crumb Tray
The removable crumb tray on this toaster makes for easy cleanup for everyone in the house.
Cost and Value
Just the fact that the toaster is shaped like Star Wars Death Star is enough to give it value and make it well-worth cost. Add in the extra-wide slots, adjustable thermostat, and the removable crumb tray and it deserves to be on the list!
- Shaped like Star Wars Death Star
- Great gift for a Star Wars fan
- Lightweight design
- Character appears on toasted bread
- Slots are too short
The toaster features a shade selector that lets you choose from six settings for light to dark toast, so yours is always just that perfect shade of brown. Other features include defrost, reheat, and cancel controls for easy use.
The design of this toaster is sleek and elegant, a welcome addition to any kitchen. The brushed stainless steel body of the toaster is not only eye-catching, it helps the toaster to cool down as well after toasting is completed.
Cost and Value
With the multifunctional settings, sleek design and LED indicator lights, it's no wonder this toaster made it on the list. For cost and value, this one can't be beaten.
- LED indicator lights
- Sleek design
- Removable crumb tray
- Self-adjusting guides
- Easy to use
- Toasts unevenly
This toaster features a futuristic design that will look great in any modern kitchen. Take your toasting to a different level with this sleek 4-slice toaster. You can toast two pieces of bread if it's just you, or four pieces of bread if you have a friend come over!
Breakfast becomes simple with the bagel function, manual cancel, defrost and reheat buttons, and the removable crumb tray for easy cleaning after breakfast.
Cost and Value
From the separate bagel button to the 7-shade indicator, this toaster is worth the money that you will spend to purchase it. Combined with the sleek, modern, yet compact design, this is one you don't want to miss.
- Sleek, futuristic design
- 7 shade settings
- LED indicator lights
- Even toasting
- Lever control is faulty
This toaster is designed with a retro look that will fit well in any retro kitchen. However, its old-fashioned look doesn't take away from the functionality.
Stainless Steel Crumb Tray
The toaster comes with a stainless steel crumb tray that makes cleaning up after breakfast, or even just a snack, a breeze, as it's removable.
Cost and Value
Just the retro design and choice of six colors, make this toaster well-worth the price. Add in the removable crumb tray, the three preset programs, and the six shade browning functions and this toaster is one for the ages.
- Comes with six browning levels
- Retro design
- 6 color choices
- Self-centering racks
- Breaks within a year
- Burns toast
8. Amazon Basics
No longer do you have to worry about digging out smaller items from the toaster with a fork, that is dangerous because this toaster comes with an extra lift lever that allows you to lift the smaller items so they can be retrieved with ease!
It's possible to toast everything from bagels to frozen pastries and much more in this toaster due to the extra-wide slots included.
Cost and Value
With the extra lift lever and extra-wide slots, this toaster is already worth the money. Add in the bagel setting and the sleek, gorgeous design and this is one you will want to keep in your kitchen for years.
- Extremely affordable
- Toasts evenly
- Cool to the touch
- Toasts bagels perfectly
- Looks cheap
- Smells like plastic when toasting
9. Russell Hobbs
One of the best features with this toaster is it has a removable warming rack. Keep your pastries, buns, and even rolls warm, while you are getting the rest of your meal ready. The wire rack can be attached to the top of the toaster when needed and removed when you want to use the normal toasting function.
This toaster has a toasting timer that counts down exactly how much time you have left until your toast is done. No more, standing by the toaster hoping it doesn't burn before the lever pops it up.
Cost and Value
The removable warming rack and toasting countdown timer add value to this toaster more than anything else. The retro design and choice of two colors make it well-worth the money spent.
Fashionable retro style
Toasts frozen bread evenly
Can check the bread for brownness without restarting the timer
Chrome flakes off easily
Long toast time
This toaster features extra-wide slots so that you can toast anything from bagels to thick bread, with ease.
6 Browning Settings
The toaster features 6 different browning levels, so you can get the perfect shade and crispness to the morning toast you love.
Cost and Value
This toaster is worth the money spent with its extra-wide slots and even browning capabilities. It's a product that will look great in your kitchen.
Six toasting settings
Easy to clean
1.5 inch wide slots
May not toast both sides evenly
May not fit all sizes of bread
If you love toast, but can’t seem to find the toaster that works the best for you, at the most affordable price, then you should have for sure found something on our top ten list to suit your needs.. The best toasters are going to give you crispy toast browned to just the desired shade you choose, no matter what type of bread you’re using. These toasters should toast a bagel to perfection and give you crispy English muffins as well.
Criteria Used in Choosing the Best Toasters
Toasters cover a lot of categories and there are many different brands and types on the market. There are some that come with bells and whistles and others that just perform the basic functions of toasting bread and pastries. Toasters come at many different price points, from relatively cheap to super expensive. Since breakfast is the most important meal of the day, it stands to reason that you would need a reliable and sturdy toaster to get you ready for the hecticness of the day ahead.
The criteria used to rate and review the best toasters in this list are combined of a few different things. We researched for design and appeal, settings, size, functionality, whether the toaster can be had with all the bells and whistles or was just your basic toaster, and even the types on the market.
If you are still searching for a replacement toaster, read on below to see the metrics used in this list to help you find the perfect toaster to meet your needs.
Types of Toasters
When you are picking out a toaster for your kitchen, you are going to want to decide which type of toaster is best-suited for your needs. There are pop-up toasters, which are mostly referred to as just toasters. These are usually affordable, easy to use, and come with quite a few bells and whistles to recommend them. The other type of toaster out there is the toaster oven, which sits on your countertop and can be used for a variety of foods, other than toast, breads, bagels, English muffins, and frozen pastries. For the list here, the pop-up toaster was concentrated on, but so you know, there are other choices of toasters out there for you to consider.
The next metric used to develop this buying guide was the size of the toasters offered. Most of the top-rated toasters come in either 2-slice or 4-slice options. Most of the time, the type of toaster it is will be apparent in the title. For you to determine which is the right size for you, decide whether you will be toasting two or four slices of bread at the time, how big you want the slots to be on the toaster, and how much counter space you have to devote to the toaster itself. Most of the top-rated models are compact and able to fit easily on a countertop and are also compact enough to be stored easily as well.
Bells and Whistles
The days when toasters performed one basic function, and that was to brown bread, are long gone. Today, you can get toasters whose only function is to make toast or you can buy a toaster that comes with a ton of bells and whistles. The top-rated toasters on this list come with bells and whistles such as LED indicator lights or a countdown timer to tell you how close your toast is to being done. Many also feature removable warming racks and some even come in different shapes and sizes. You need to decide if you want the bells and whistles or simply want the toaster to brown your bread instead.
Design and Appeal
While you want your toaster to work well, and maybe even have a few of the bells and whistles mentioned above, design and appeal play a huge part in choosing the right toaster to meet your needs. The top-rated toasters come in a variety of different styles, colors, and can even be gotten in the shape of the Star Wars Death Star. Whether you are looking for a toaster that is sleek and modern or one that is retro to fit your art-deco kitchen decor, there is a toaster out there to meet your needs.
The best-reviewed toasters come with a variety of settings to create toast that is to your liking. Many have six to eight different toaster settings, so you can choose the correct brownness and crispness you want in your toast. It’s also common for these toasters to come with a defrost, reheat and cancel button as well, so you can stop the process of toasting whenever you want. Many options come with a bagel setting, so you can toast bagels as well. Consider which settings you want on the toaster you are considering carefully.
One of the biggest metrics considered in this list was the cost of the toasters reviewed and rated. The average price of a no-frills toaster can cost anything from $20 to $40. Some of the high-end toasters, however, can run you anywhere from $100 to $300 a piece. There are a few factors to consider when deciding the cost you are willing to pay. Do you want the toaster to have the bells and whistles? Then you will pay more, if not, then you can usually go with the low end of the price scale. Make sure to consider the durability of the toaster when making your decision.
A good toaster should last you a good number of years. The top-rated ones on this list, as stated by reviews, last a good long time. The best way to ensure the toaster that you are considering will last you for years is to do some research on the brand and read the reviews on the product.
Ease of Use/Cleaning
No one wants a toaster that they have to squint at to use or be a rocket scientist to toast their bagel first thing in the morning. The top-rated toasters have LED indicators and easy to push buttons, so that toasting your English muffin at 6 am, doesn’t take a master’s degree. When it comes to cleaning, you want a toaster with a removable crumb tray, so that cleaning the toaster only takes a few seconds, and then a quick wipe with a rag to complete the process.
While the list has already determined the proper bells and whistles that come on many of the top-rated toasters, that’s not the same as the features many come with. Some of the best features to watch out for when you are considering the best toaster for you are listed here. An extra lift lifts the toast up so you don’t have to dig smaller pieces out with a fork or your fingers. Bagel settings are becoming more and more common and are designed to toast bagels, English muffins and other breads that are thick. A sandwich toasting cage could be considered a bell and whistle, but it does come in handy. They are designed to help you make toasties, (sandwiches,) easily and have a solid bottom to stop cheese from dripping down into your toaster and making a mess.
No matter what type of product you are considering buying, looking at the safety features for that product should come first and that includes toasters. The top-rated toasters on this list have safety features, such as crumb trays that catch the crumbs and make it easy to empty them, to prevent them from being a fire hazard. Other features include retractable cords that don’t get tangled on something and pull the toaster off the counter when not in use and cool touch sides, so you don’t have to worry about burning yourself or melting the bread bag if it touches the side of the toaster during or after use. These safety features are important and looking for them when searching for the perfect toaster for your kitchen is a must for the safety of you, your property and your family.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: How do you clean a toaster?
The first thing you need to do before thinking of cleaning your toaster is making sure that it is unplugged. Once the toaster is unplugged and cool enough to touch if you have been using it recently, then slide the removable crumb tray out of the toaster gently and empty it in the trash. Once you have emptied the crumb tray, wipe the tray out and replace it. Take a damp cloth and wipe down the outside of your toaster, dry it well, and you are good to go!
Q: How many slices of bread can you toast at once?
The answer to this question is according to whether you have a 2-slice or 4-slice toaster. With a 2-slice toaster, you can toast one slice or two slices, no more. If you have a 4-slice toaster, you can toast one, two, three, or four slices of bread at a time.
Q: Should you unplug your toaster when it’s not in use?
A toaster can be considered a fire hazard if someone should accidentally toss a towel over it when it’s still hot or press down the lever unintentionally. It is best to unplug your toaster when it’s not in use to not only reduce the fire hazard but to save electricity as well.
Q: What does the bagel button on the toaster do?
Many toasters come with a bagel button so that you can toast bagels and English muffins. Bagels and English muffins are thicker than normal slices of bread, so they take longer to toast and come to an even brownness and crispy feel. When you select this feature on your toaster, it automatically adjusts to the bagel setting.
Q: What does the frozen button on the toaster do?
The frozen button on a toaster will defrost the frozen bread you put into the toaster and then go on to toast the bread for you as well.
Q: What does the reheat button on the toaster do?
The reheat button on a toaster is designed to reheat foods you have already toasted without toasting them further.
Q: What type of foods can go into a toaster?
Toasters are designed to toast bread, bagels, English muffins, pastries, and pop tarts. It is not recommended to put anything into a toaster that doesn’t belong.
Q: Do toasters have cool sides?
Many of the top-rated toasters come with cool to the touch sides. You have to read the description to ensure the brand you are choosing offers this option.
Q: Why does the bread only toast on one side?
In many cases, the bread is to thick to be toasting on a regular setting. Try turning the setting to the bagel function to ensure even toasting. Sometimes there may be something wrong with the heating elements in your toaster as well, so it is a good idea to have it checked.
Q: Does paying more for a toaster make it toast better?
In reality, no paying more for a toaster doesn’t make it toast better. What makes it toast better is whether it’s a high-quality toaster and the features the toaster comes with. In many cases, the basic toasters that were inexpensive toasted better than the more expensive ones did. Sometimes, paying more for a toaster is paying for the sleek design, LED indicator lights, and other bells and whistles, and has nothing to do with how the toaster performs when used.
Q: What does the cancel button on a toaster do?
The cancel button on the toaster is so you can cancel the toasting whenever you want. It is a good safety feature to have. There are manual cancel buttons and automatic cancel buttons as well, according to the model of toaster you choose.
Q: How do you make toast in a toaster?
Toasters are made to toast different types of bread, bagels, pastries, and English muffins. When you are ready to make the toast, the first thing you need to do is ensure that the toaster is plugged in. Once you are sure it’s plugged in, put the amount of bread you want to toast, according to whether you have a 2-slice or a 4-slice toaster, then choose the setting you want to determine the shade of brownness you desire, whether it’s lightly toasted, dark brown or even burnt. Press the lever to lower the toast and then wait on it to pop up. Put on your butter and favorite jelly or jam and enjoy!
Q: Why does my new toaster smell like it is burning when toasting?
It is possible that your toaster has gathered dust on the element during shipping. This will cause a burning odor, the first few times that you use the toaster. It should burn off and is not a hazard and won’t hurt you in any way.
This concludes the buying guide on the best toasters out there on the market today. The list was made using reviews, research and metrics we felt would go into choosing the top-quality toasters. If you are a toast lover, then it’s good to know there are so many different toasters out there to choose from. The days when toast was just toast are long gone and now you can get them with different settings, bells and whistles, and even easy to clean removable crumb trays. If you are in the market for a toaster and aren’t sure which one to buy, this list should have helped you make a decision. From the different designs, colors, and features, there is plenty to choose from out there for sure. Happy toaster hunting everyone!