to top 10 table

Best Weed Killers Reviewed & Rated for Quality

last updated: May 14, 2019

Weeds can cause a massive amount of frustration in your life. They will invade your garden and smother the flowers and vegetables that you worked so hard to grow. Just when you think you have the best looking lawn on the block, you walk out the back door, only to see a number of dandelions have sprouted up. Weeds are also notorious for popping up in the cracks of your sidewalk or patio walkway, which can definitely be an eyesore. The answer, of course, is a good weed killer but which one should you buy. Well, we've done some shopping for you and made our list of the best on the market. We're sure you'll find what you're looking for here.

In a Hurry? The test winner after 11 hrs of research

icon
 Compare-N-Save Concentrate
95/100 our score
Features
96
Bottom Line
95
Water Resistance
94
Safety Hazards
95
Effectiveness
95
Compare-N-Save Concentrate
Why is it better?

Rainproof

See Results in 2 days

Covers 25 thousand square feet

Makes 85 gallons of spray

In a Hurry? Editors choice:
 Compare-N-Save Concentrate
Test Winner: Compare-N-Save Concentrate
Amazon Link
Researched Sources
12
Researched Sources
Reviews Considered
15k
Reviews Considered
Hours Researching
11
Hours Researching
Products Evaluated
10
Products Evaluated
Last Updated:
By :

Keeping your yard and garden weed free is vital for a healthy and good looking yard. To ensure that our readers always have information about the best proucts on the market today, we make regular updates to our lists!

Sorting Options
Features Bottom Line Water Resistance Safety Hazards Effectiveness By Default
Rank
PictureProduct
Name
Rating
Shops
#1
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
95
Features
96 %
Bottom Line
95 %
Water Resistance
94 %
Safety Hazards
95 %
Effectiveness
95 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (23.09.20)
Amazon Link
$21.99
#2
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
94
Features
94 %
Bottom Line
95 %
Water Resistance
94 %
Safety Hazards
93 %
Effectiveness
94 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (23.09.20)
Amazon Link
$24.97
#3
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
92.4
Features
92 %
Bottom Line
93 %
Water Resistance
94 %
Safety Hazards
92 %
Effectiveness
91 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (23.09.20)
Amazon Link
$58.95
#4
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
90.8
Features
91 %
Bottom Line
90 %
Water Resistance
92 %
Safety Hazards
91 %
Effectiveness
90 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (23.09.20)
Amazon Link
$59.99
#5
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
90
Features
90 %
Bottom Line
91 %
Water Resistance
89 %
Safety Hazards
90 %
Effectiveness
90 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (23.09.20)
Amazon Link
$18.48
#6
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
85.8
Features
87 %
Bottom Line
86 %
Water Resistance
85 %
Safety Hazards
86 %
Effectiveness
85 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (23.09.20)
Amazon Link
#7
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
82.2
Features
83 %
Bottom Line
82 %
Water Resistance
83 %
Safety Hazards
81 %
Effectiveness
82 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (23.09.20)
Amazon Link
$38.08
#8
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
81.2
Features
82 %
Bottom Line
81 %
Water Resistance
80 %
Safety Hazards
82 %
Effectiveness
81 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (23.09.20)
Amazon Link
$36.36
#9
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
76.8
Features
78 %
Bottom Line
77 %
Water Resistance
75 %
Safety Hazards
78 %
Effectiveness
76 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (23.09.20)
Amazon Link
$28.98
#10
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
74.8
Features
75 %
Bottom Line
74 %
Water Resistance
75 %
Safety Hazards
76 %
Effectiveness
74 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (23.09.20)
Amazon Link
$17.22

Best Weed Killers

1. Compare-N-Save Concentrate

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
95
 Compare-N-Save Concentrate
Amazon Link
Features
96
Bottom Line
95
Water Resistance
94
Safety Hazards
95
Effectiveness
95
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$21.99
Pros:

Rainproof

See Results in 2 days

Covers 25 thousand square feet

Makes 85 gallons of spray

Cons:

Not as Effective as other brands

First on our list of types of weed killer is one that falls into the non-selective category. Known for enough potency to kill all the plant life it comes into contact with.

Non-Selective
A non-selective weed killer is designed to kill off the plant life that it comes into contact with. Which means that spraying your lawn with this might not be your best idea ever. You can, however, use a non-selective weed killer to prep the soil in your garden, just be sure to follow the directions down to the last letter.

Concentrate
Weed killer that is sold as a concentrate will need to be mixed according to the directions before you use it. Purchasing weed killer in concentrate form can save you a few dollars over time. You can buy this in bulk, so one container will sometimes last for quite some time.

Cost and Value
Depending on the actual size of the job you have, you can order this weed killer in bulk form. When persisting weeds have become an overwhelming issue, this weed killer can be used to kill off all life in your yard. allowing you to start over fresh from the beginning.

2. Roundup

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
94
 Roundup
Amazon Link
Features
94
Bottom Line
95
Water Resistance
94
Safety Hazards
93
Effectiveness
94
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$24.97
Pros:

Active ingredients formulated to attack the roots

Only takes half an hour to be water proof

Has a name that you can recognize

Decay starts in as little as 12 hours

Cons:

Can cause damage to your lawn

Can cost more than other brands

Next up on the list whose brand has made their way to the top of the list for lawn care needs. This is another great non-selective type of weed killer, perfect for those who put their trust into recognized names.

Systemic
A weed killer formulated such as this one will destroy the weeds it comes into contact with. Once it is soaked into the leaves, it will travel through the weed, killing the entire thing. Systemic weed killers were designed to get to the root of the problem.

Using Caution
We have already been over the fact that this weed killer has the capabilities to rid your yard of those pesky weeds. Keeping that in mind, be sure to use caution when spraying the weed killer. It has also been known to kill off your prized flowers when sprayed too closely.

Cost and Value
For those that would rather spend the extra to get a trusted brand, this weed killer is for you. Offered from a company that has been in this business for years, you can set your mind at ease that you have gotten your money worth.

3. Preen

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
92.4
 Preen
Amazon Link
Features
92
Bottom Line
93
Water Resistance
94
Safety Hazards
92
Effectiveness
91
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$58.95
Pros:

Easy to spread granules

Comes with a cap designed for spreading the granules

Provides good weed prevention

Can be purchased in several different sizes

Cons:

Not for use on lawns

The next weed killer on the list is offered to you in a totally different form. Great for preparing your yard for those upcoming summer parties. This will keep your lawn looking pristine all summer long.

Pre-Emergent
The term pre-emergent basically means that this weed killer will stop those weeds even before they get started. Use this every year in the early portion of the spring to give your yard a jump start for the grilling season.

Granules
Using your weed killer is granule form limits the possibility of overspray, which is good for the greenery you're not looking to eliminate. No hassle of mixing the granules before applying, as all you have to do is shake to distribute them.

Cost and Value
A weed killer that is offered in granule form, can save you're surrounding plants from accidental exposure. You can buy a small container or choose a larger size for those jobs that will require more. Adding this weed killer to your routine garden care can make your garden more valuable.

4. RM43 Weed Preventer

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
90.8
 RM43 Weed Preventer
Amazon Link
Features
91
Bottom Line
90
Water Resistance
92
Safety Hazards
91
Effectiveness
90
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$59.99
Pros:

Kills all vegetation

Prevents weeds for a year

Combines two herbicides

Safe after it dries

Cons:

May take a while to work

Not great for crabgrass

This type of weed preventer is a good choice if you want to get rid of all the vegetation around a certain area by your house. Maybe you have huge green areas or you just want to change the aspect of your backyard for a longer period of time. RM43 can prevent weeds from growing for up to 1 year without the necessity to repeat the process. So, if you have a vacation home but you hardly get there, you can avoid undesired plants by using this weed preventer.

Long Term Protection
Unlike other weed killers, this one is also a good preventer. Not only does it kill the weeds, but it also stops them from growing again. Its effects are visible for up to 12 months, so you don’t have to use it over and over again.

Vegetation Control
A big plus for buying this product is vegetation control. This means that you can kill all the vegetation and leave the ground bare if you want to. If you’re a farmer and want to kill the weeds without destroying your plants, you can apply this solution in a smaller area.

Cost and Value
This product is worth investing in, especially if you live in the countryside or in a house. If you use RM43 Weed Preventer, you won’t have to spend money on buying another one for a while. You won’t see any weed on the treated area for a long time!

5. Southern Ag

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
90
 Southern Ag
Amazon Link
Features
90
Bottom Line
91
Water Resistance
89
Safety Hazards
90
Effectiveness
90
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$18.48
Pros:

One bottle will go a long way

Kills Broadleaf Weeds

Won't harm your lawn

Easy to mix formula

Cons:

In some cases, more than one treatment is needed

Will not work for all weeds, read the label carefully

This weed killer is the first one we have come to that focuses solely on the weeds at hand. Even the toughest weeds will have a hard time surviving a weed killer like this one.

Broadleaf Weed Killer
This weed killer is known as a selective type of weed killer, focusing on the Broadleaf weeds. A good example of that would be the dandelion, you can feel free to mix a batch up to spray around the yard. This weed killer will attack the weeds while leaving your lawn to flourish.

Mixing
In this situation the expression, "A little bit goes a long way" comes to mind. The formula for mixing the concentrate is 2-3 tablespoons of concentrate mixed with 3-5 gallons of water. That is a whole lot of strength in a small package.

Cost and Value
With the mixing ratio not requiring much of the concentrate, you can be sure that the money spent on this will go a long way. As for the value, with a weed killer this potent it will speak for itself.

6. Agri Star

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
85.8
 Agri Star
Amazon Link
Features
87
Bottom Line
86
Water Resistance
85
Safety Hazards
86
Effectiveness
85
best offer for today
Amazon Link
Pros:

Good for heavy bushes

Safe for lawns

Selective weed killer

Can also be used on trees when needed

Cons:

Not to be used heavily

This is the stuff you would call in when you have a big job to do. Known for taking down some of the toughest weeds, this weed killer will also be gentle on your lawn.

The Big Guns
A tough weed killer can accomplish the killing of some of the most stubborn types of weeds or various plant life. It has been recorded that this type of weed killer can take down the heavy brush, sometimes being used to aid in finishing off weak trees.

Easy on the Lawn
One would think with the amount of potential killing strength this weed killer has, that it would ruin your lawn as well. That is not the case with this stuff. Feel free to use it on those stubborn dandelions, as it will not affect your lawn.

Cost and Value
A weed killer with this much strength, you know it will cost you a great deal more than some of the others. Save this type of weed killer for those times when you need to take out thick bush patches. In the event it lands on your lawn, there is no need to worry as it won't harm your lawn.

7. Ortho GroundClear

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
82.2
 Ortho GroundClear
Amazon Link
Features
83
Bottom Line
82
Water Resistance
83
Safety Hazards
81
Effectiveness
82
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$38.08
Pros:

Long lasting effects

Good for hard surfaces

Can be used to prevent new growth

Will kill weeds that have already grown

Cons:

Not for use on lawns

Containers are small

This is an option for use on your sidewalks or patios that need some weeds removed. You can use thus weed killer to prevent or rid your path of the weeds. This weed killer will knock down whatever stands in the way.

Before and After
You can use this weed killer in the spring to get ahead of the game, stopping weeds dead in their tracks. When you find your self slightly behind the eight ball when caring for your yard. You can use thus weed killer after the weeds have grown.

Lengthy Results
Here is a weed killer that has stated that you will see no signs of treated weeds until the following year. That is a long lasting solution to an age-old problem. As most weed killers will need to be reapplied at least every few months.

Cost and Value
For a fast-acting, powerful weed killer you should expect the cost to be slightly higher than some of the others. One valuable asset this weed killer has is the length of time between the treatments.

8. Gordon SpeedZone

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
81.2
 Gordon SpeedZone
Amazon Link
Features
82
Bottom Line
81
Water Resistance
80
Safety Hazards
82
Effectiveness
81
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$36.36
Pros:

Full results in one week

Four active ingredients for fast action

Can be used in cold weather

One bottle covers plenty of area

Cons:

Not for use on lawns

Follow directions carefully

Now we come to an option on the list that is known for attacking a plethora of Broadleaf weeds. Killing then on contact in a rather quick time frame. This bottle may seem small, but the contents inside can go a long way.

Active Ingredients
This formula will offer the user four ingredients that exist to do all the work. Killing up to one hundred different types of Broadleaf weeds, now that is a lot of weeds to cover.

Quick to Kill
You know you have made the right product choice when you can see the difference in a short amount of time. After application, you will start to see results in an hour, treated weeds will disappear in as little as a week.

Cost and Value
This small bottle comes with a higher price tag, but don't let that fool you. The contents of this bottle will last for long periods of time when following the ratio for mixing properly. This weed killer delivers a punch to the weeds that can't be replaced.

9. Spectracide

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
76.8
 Spectracide
Amazon Link
Features
78
Bottom Line
77
Water Resistance
75
Safety Hazards
78
Effectiveness
76
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$28.98
Pros:

Shows visible results in 3 hours

Rain resistant in 15 minutes

Takes down persistent weed systems

No residual effects on the soil

Cons:

Not for use on lawns

Here we come to another great product that will kill off the vegetation it comes into contact with. This weed killer is also known for the speed in which it reacts once it is placed where you need it.

No Soil Activity
You can treat your garden ahead of the planting season with this weed killer, as it will leave no residual effects in the soil. Perfect for those who are always running short on time for weeding their garden.

Speed
This weed killer hits the top of the charts in for the sped category. Showing you visual results in as little as three hours. It also covers the fast category for becoming rain resistant in as little as fifteen minutes.

Cost and Value
A weed killer that is known for its fast-acting potential, can save you both time and money. Since this weed killer can resist the rain in a short amount of time, you won't have to spend days tracking the weather.

10. Bayer Advanced

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
74.8
 Bayer Advanced
Amazon Link
Features
75
Bottom Line
74
Water Resistance
75
Safety Hazards
76
Effectiveness
74
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$17.22
Pros:

Can kill of crabgrass

Won't harm your lawn

Kills all the way to the roots

Lasts for 6 months

Cons:

Not for sensitive types of grass

Directions are sort of hard to follow

The last option on our list was intended to please those with daily struggles with a specific type of weed. You can be sure that the mix in this formula will get right down to the business end of the weeds.

Crabgrass
A weed that had plagued many yards, becoming a bothersome thorn in many peoples side. For ridding your lawn of this horrible problem, look no further, this weed killer is formulated to finally rid your yard of the dreaded crabgrass.

Roots
As we are all aware, in many cases the only way to truly kill a weed is to get the entire plant. Some weed killers would like you to believe that they do this, but in reality, many of the weed killers will only attack what you can see. Not this one, you can be sure that this one is attacking the roots as well.

Cost and Value
A weed killer that can rid you of even the most bothersome weeds, while attacking what grows under the ground is a valuable part of your lawn care arsenal.

Criteria Used for Evaluation

Features

As times have changed, so have the chemicals you will find in the weed killers. So if you're looking for the weed killer your father used for years to make his lawn beautiful, chances are it is no longer the same. Companies that produce the weed killers are constantly researching to stay in the now, as far as the types of chemicals to use for their product.

Often times eliminating a formula that was previously used for an improved version. In other cases, it has been found during research, that some of the chemicals previously used were not that great for our health. Understanding the chemicals used may lead to you choosing a product that suits your situation a little better.

Broad-leaf weed killer This type of weed killer will contain a mix of chemicals, that will cover killing several different types of weeds. These are normally safe to use on your lawn, but it is best to double check the label to be sure. A great example when thinking about a broad-leaf weed is the dandelion.

Grassy-type weeds A weed killer that targets grassy types of weed will most definitely kill your lawn. I mean think about it, this type of weed is just like the grass in your yard. A grassy weed located in your lawn will need to be treated with a preventative weed killer in the spring. If you missed the time span for this you will need to get down and dirty. Pulling these weeds by hand from your lawn.

Weed killer intended to target grassy weeds are fine to use in your walkway cracks. Also when removing the weeds from the cracks of your sidewalk out front. Some gardeners have been known to use this type of weed killer in their flower beds as well.

Non-selective weed killers This is the type of weed killer known for killing what it touches. Using this in your lawn will be detrimental to the health of your lawn. Non-selective weed killers are best used on walkways or paths, but not in your flower or vegetable gardens either. A prime example of a good time to use this weed killer, when you're starting a new lawn. You can mix this into the soil, following the directions, of course, to start your lawn without the growth of bothersome weeds.  Use this product to eradicate a lawn that is taken over by weeds, you will need to reseed the area later. As the grass will most likely be killed off during the treatment.

Bottom Line

Weed killer needs time to work, therefore when the results aren't fast enough for you, spraying in a heavier concentrate won't work either. In this case slow and steady will win the race, fast acting weed killers will only buy you time. They are not intended for completely removing the weeds. The most effective weed killer will be in the form of a liquid, the ones that come in granules aren't as great as they are made out to be. You can find the liquid weed killers as a concentrate or ready mixed for you. Keep in mind, when you choose to use the readily mixed version, you will pay a higher cost for the convenience.

Water Resistance

Check the weather forecast for your area a few days in advance. Doing this will improve the results of your success. You want to target your treatment for a period of time that there will be no rain for at least one full day. This will give the weed killer the time it needs to sit on the weed to better aid in killing them off.

Safety Hazards

Be sure that the weed killer you have selected to use is safe for the grass you have. Some types of grass are more sensitive than others, which makes it vulnerable to the weed killer. Always read through the directions listed on the weed killer thoroughly, cutting corners is never a good idea. Read the label carefully, this will tell you if it is safe to be on the lawn after using the weed killer. As some will require you to stay off the treated lawn for a day or so after treatment.

Effectiveness

You can treat your lawn in the spring when you know that there are areas in your lawn that weeds grow each year. This will prevent them from coming up, allowing you to get ahead of the game. These are a relatively mild form of weed killer as not to kill off the lawn you are trying to protect. To eliminate weeds, choose a spray that will travel through the weed, right down to the roots. This will eradicate the weeds you are treating. Most of the time this weed killer would be considered as a "non-selective"  type of product.

Let me break that down for you.  You can pretty much bet that when sprayed, you're killing off any plant life this product lands on. Which is why you should use this in areas like patios or walking paths, where you can control the plants this spray will touch. You should never use this type of weed killer in your lawn or garden unless you are looking to kill off either of these areas. Now should you be looking to treat your lawn, there are weed killers with a mix of chemicals that are safe to use on your lawn.

The most important aspect of choosing such a weed killer is to be sure it is safe for the type of lawn you have. Typically a weed killer for treating weeds in your lawn that are already growing will contain three things. A chemical that will act as a pre-treating agent, so you can kill off the seeds of the weed before they have a chance to sprout. Next, you may find a form of fertilizer mixed into the weed killer, this will promote growth in your lawn after treatment. The last chemical you will find thrown into the mix will be one that when sprayed will kill the targeted weed.

Expert Interviews & Opinions

Most Important Criteria (According to our experts opinion)
Sort criterias acording to:
Experts Opinion Editors Opinion Users Opinion By Default
Click on a to rate the most important criteria:
#1
ico Features
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
#2
ico Bottom Line
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
#3
ico Water Resistance
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
#4
ico Safety Hazards
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
#5
ico Effectiveness
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
expert tips icon
Getting Rid of Weeds Without Killing Your Grass

Is this even possible? Really? The answer is a qualified yes, depending on how bad your weed situation is, and what kind of weeds are destroying your grass. If your lucky enough to have just one kind of weed on your lawn you can get weed specific killer, which is going to be the best way to go. But if you're like a lot of good people their yard is a menagerie of weediness. If this is the case, it's going to take time, effort and some strict rule following.

Frequently Asked Questions

q: When should a pre-emergent weed killer be used?

a:

A pre-emergent weed killer is typically used in the spring to eliminate the weeds during their growth period. In order to be effective, you should spray your lawn in the earlier part of spring. It will allow the weed killer a chance to get to the root of the problem right away.

q: Are there weed killers that are considered to be pet-friendly?

a:

Yes, there are brands of weed killers that are considered to be pet-friendly. To find a brand that is, you will want to read the label. It will be clearly written there if the weed killer is, in fact, pet-friendly. If you are still nervous when it comes to using weed killer around your pets, there are alternative choices. Searching the web will give you a wide variety of remedies made at home for killing weeds. Just be advised, some of these work, but some also flop.

q: When should you use a non-selective weed killer?

a:

Non-selective weed killers are designed to eradicate all forms of plant life. So using this in a garden that has established plants in it is a bad choice. You can, however, use the non-selective spray before planting in the garden. Just be sure to wait the amount of time specified in the directions before planting. Another reason to use a non-selective weed killer, to kill off a lawn that has been taken over by weeds. This will allow you to start over fresh with a new lawn.

q: Why do I have to identify the weeds in my before treating them?

a:

Identifying the weeds you have in your yard will help you determine the treatment you will need. Spraying a weed killer that isn't effective for the weeds in your yard is a waste of both your time and money. In some cases, identifying the weeds in your yard can determine if there is a larger issue with your vegetation.

q: What is the difference between an annual weed and a perennial weed?

a:

An annual weed is easier to get rid of, due to a couple of reasons. They only live for one season, typically in the late spring. They spread by way of seed, so treating your yard in the early spring can reduce the number of annual weds you will see. As for perennial weeds, these can be tough little buggers to get rid of. Perennial weeds can spread by way of seed, tubers, and stems found both above and below the surface. Once these weeds have established themselves in your lawn your chances for removal become significantly less.

q: Why does my lawn seem to have more weeds than other lawns in my neighborhood?

a:

A number of factors can arise that will contribute to the number of weeds in your yard. If you have recently added soil to your yard, it is possible that the seeds were already in the soil you added. Lawns with areas that are bare can allow weeds the space they need to become established. Covering those areas with mulch or seeding them for grass growth right away can prevent the weeds from setting in. The last reason is on you, your neighbors more than likely have established a routine for treating their lawn at the beginning of the season. Perhaps you have become a little relaxed in that department. When in fact, a normal routine for weed prevention should happen every early spring.