Best Popcorn Makers Reviewed & Rated for Quality
Criteria Used for Evaluation
Microwave options are either made of silicone or stone. You simply put the kernels and oil (or not) in the bottom and push go. They are easy to use and maybe even easier to clean up. Most are even dishwasher safe. However; popcorn is easier to burn and it can be hard to figure out the right time to cook.
Stovetop versions are often considered the gold standard. They make fluffy, crunchy popcorn every time and do so quickly. They are also easy to use and easy to clean. The biggest con here is that you have to stir it constantly until done popping, but that is only a few minutes and might be worth the time commitment.
A standalone appliance can range anywhere from simple plug-in counter unit too expensive, big, movie theater-style. They too make delicious popcorn but do require a bigger storage footprint and a bigger upfront cost.
How many people do you plan on cooking for? This point can influence you in the direction of one popcorn maker over the other. If you are the only one eating popcorn, then you would likely be well served to get a smaller option. Most microwave options are good for that, as is the stovetop edition. It wouldn’t make any sense to get a big bulky unit to simply cook a couple of servings at a time.
Conversely, if you want to cook large quantities - we’re talking gallons of popcorn here - then you need a bigger unit. Not only do they cook in bulk, but they also include warmer lights and potentially trays that will keep the popcorn warm and ready to eat whenever you or your guests are ready for it.
What kind of storage space do you available to you? Do you have a large kitchen with empty cabinets or a tiny one with only a couple inches to spare? This makes a big difference. Most microwavable options are also collapsible and are only a couple inches tall when fully collapsed. They also act as their own bowl once they are fully extended and the popcorn is cooked so that removes another dish.
Stovetop versions are similar in size to pots you would have in your kitchen already. While they don’t take up a ton of space, they do need a little more room than a collapsible version does. This is also true for the Stir Crazy appliance version. It does also double as a bowl but does have a little bit bigger of a footprint.
If you are looking to have a novelty piece, then you won’t need to worry about storing as it will be out and visible at almost all times. That does mean that you ‘ll need to have the space to put it there initially, which likely isn’t a problem if you are looking for this type of popcorn maker in the first place.
In conclusion, owning your own popcorn maker is very much an achievable dream. They are affordable and practical for any kitchen. Homemade popcorn is both easy to cook and easy to customize. You can have healthy snacks when you want them and decadent treats when you prefer something a little heavier. You will appreciate the ability to have fresh, warm, exactly as you like it popcorn on demand right in the comfort of your own home.
10 Best Popcorn Makers
This is a collapsible silicone popcorn maker that is easily stored and easy to use. All you have to do is open the bowl to its fully open position, put ¼ to ½ a cup of kernels in the bottom, add your oil or butter, put in in the microwave, and enjoy delicious, fresh-popped popcorn. It is easy, but more importantly delicious.
Food Grade Silicone
Only the best silicone was used in making this popcorn maker. You can rest easy knowing that it has been tested by third-party laboratories and deemed acceptable for food use (and the company will happily provide you with a copy). It is perfectly safe in the microwave.
Cool Touch Handles
Like many things do when microwaved, silicone gets hot. Salbree has addressed this issue though and included handles that are cool to the touch and allow you to remove your bowl of delicious, hot popcorn from the microwave without burning your fingers. No need to touch the bowl here.
Cost and Value
This Salbree popcorn popper is very inexpensive. It is good for the environment and good for your wallet. You will get many a good bowl of popcorn out of this popcorn maker for very little upfront cost. If you are a lover of bagged popcorn, this will ultimately pay for itself because simply buying kernels is less expensive than buying the premade bags.
2. Whirly Pop
This aluminum popcorn maker will have you eating delicious, movie theatre popcorn at home with very little effort and in very little time. It is used on the stovetop and comes with a stirring handle so that none of the kernels burn. It is easy to clean and will produce perfect popcorn in only 3 minutes.
No Burned Popcorn
The stirring system that is the essence of this popcorn maker is patented and ensures that you don’t get any burned popcorn. It does so by constantly stirring the kernels which makes it so that they evenly heat and evenly pop. You’ll have big, beautiful, and most importantly delicious popcorn that can get up to 42 times the original size!
Easy To Clean
As in all things that are used in the kitchen, clean up can make or break any fancy tool. If something is easy to clean, it is a lot more likely to get used and even recommended. This unit is incredibly easy to clean. All you have to do is wipe it out with a paper towel so that there are no popcorn or butter/oil remnants and move on with your life. Easy.
Cost and Value
This Whirly Pop popper is very reasonably priced. It makes delicious, evenly popped popcorn every time, quickly and with little effort. That alone makes it more than worth the small amount you will be spending on it. Compared to others on this list, it is not the cheapest but is not far from that point.
This is another completely different style of popcorn maker. Here you have gemstone cookware that is unbreakable and comes with a plastic lid. This cooking method requires no oil and will have your popcorn popped and ready to eat in under 4 minutes. It is both dishwasher and microwave safe and is made in the USA.
No Oil Required
Unlike other methods, this one requires absolutely nothing besides the corn kernels. This can make for a much healthier popcorn experience and also gives you the benefit of being able to dress it exactly how you like it. Any condiments or toppings are added after it is done cooking so that you don’t have to worry about grease, artificial flavorings, or salt.
The unbreakable cookware used here makes for a unique experience. It is weighted, molded, and then cured in a 450-degree oven which makes it oven safe up to 400 degrees forever and it won’t be melting on you. The bowl is then trimmed and smoothed by hand, paired with a lid and sent directly to you!
Cost and Value
This one falls right close to the bottom of our list price-wise. It will make you quality popcorn, and even provide the bowl to eat it out of, for a very small price. If you are a popcorn lover but want to enjoy it without all the grease then you will love this purchase.
This unit is another silicone popcorn maker. It is made of food-grade silicone, easily collapsible for storage purposes, and will make about 15 cups of popcorn in 4 minutes. It allows you to bypass the noise and hassle of using electric hot poppers or stovetop models while still enjoying the delicious, not bagged, popcorn you love.
Quickly Make Popcorn
When you decide you want popcorn you probably want it now, or as close to that as possible. Good news! In just about 4 minutes you can have 15 cups of popcorn! This unit is quick, effective, and produces a lot of delicious popcorn in no time.
This popcorn maker is BPA-free and is made of food-grade silicone. It can be used with or without oil and helps to avoid whatever lines the bags of popcorn you buy at the store. If you want to ensure that you and your family are only eating the best and healthiest popcorn, then this is a great option.
Cost and Value
This may be the cheapest item on our list. It does a great job at cooking popcorn quickly and effectively and does so with very little money out of your pocket. If you are looking for a quick, easy, and inexpensive solution to your popcorn popping problem then you will love this one.
This one might look similar to others we offer on this guide but its quite different. One of the biggest difference being it is made out of aluminum, what this means is this popcorn maker is capable of distributing heat better then stainless steel does. Having this feature ensures most of your kernels are popped at the same time for even popcorn throughout. Additionally, this popcorn maker is cooked at your stovetop giving you a traditional feel that’s a bit nostalgic yet oh so delicious.
If you’re looking to entertain a movie night or have several family and friends over, you might want to take a look into one of these. This popcorn making is 6qt which means it makes enough popcorn to feed a large crowd. Furthermore, it was designed with a large rotating handle that allows you to rotate your kernels as they pop for better, non-stop popcorn. Having this feature allows your kernels to pop even the difficult ones that seem to never rise.
Easy Clean Up
Nothing is quite as satisfying as being able to clean a pot or pan quickly, and being able to enjoy your company or your bowl of popcorn with friends. This popcorn maker allows you to do just that. You will simply need to wipe down the interior, and exterior of your pop after every use and you’re good to go- that’s it once your pot is wiped down it is prepared for the next time you want to use it.
Cost and Value
The cost of this popcorn maker is a bit on the medium price range. However, taking into consideration that you’re receiving a quality product with a lifetime warranty from the brand you will quickly realize you’re getting a great bargain. The pan is easy cleanup it holds a whole load of popcorn so you don’t have to make batch after batch for your guests and you can easily store it away as it doesn’t take up much space- a win, win if you ask us.
6. West Bend
The design found here is somewhat unique. It doesn’t require the use of an oven or a microwave, the Stir Crazy simply needs an outlet. You plug it in, turn it on and let it do the rest of the work. It’ll produce up to 27 cups of fresh, hot popcorn in about 4 minutes that you and all of your family and friends will love!
When the bowl is in popping position, there is a well to put butter in it on the top. If there is butter in it while it is popping, the heat from the heating element that is popping the popcorn will also melt the butter which makes it drip down. This dripping will evenly and beautifully coat every fully popped kernel. But wait - you don’t have to only use butter! You can use whatever type of oil or seasoning combination you want for the same effect.
Easy to Store
As this is one of the bigger units we’ve talked about it’s easy to wonder how much room it is going to take up. The manufacturers have taken this into account and really made it as storage-friendly as possible. The lid, that also doubles as a bowl, will allow the unit to nest right into it. The cord is permanently attached and will wrap up nicely on the bottom of the base.
Cost and Value
This one goes right along with other mid-range units on this list. It does have some advantages though that make it worth the purchase. It doesn’t have to be babysat like other units and it doesn’t require the use of any other appliance other than itself. It also evenly coats the popcorn with the topping of your choice which is another big plus. This is definitely worth its cost.
This Lekue popcorn maker is a similar style to the HOTPOP and Salbree options we’ve already discussed here. It is collapsible and easily stored, making it the perfect option for small spaces like busy kitchens or dorm rooms. It’ll make fluffy, delicious popcorn lightning fast. It measures 8 inches height-wise, is 5 inches tall when fully extended, and 2 inches tall when collapsed.
One thing that makes the Lekue different than the others is that it comes with a suction lid. The lid will keep your popcorn in the bowl instead of letting it pop right out of the bowl and all over your microwave. This makes for no cleanup of your microwave and makes the fact that the bowl itself is easy to clean just icing on the cake.
With this unit, you won’t just be given a fancy new tool and then have to figure out the best way to make popcorn in it. It comes with a recipe book! This way you will easily know how to best utilize it and make yummy buttery popcorn, healthy oil-free popcorn, and anything in between.
Cost and Value
This microwave popcorn popper is very affordable. Like others, it will ultimately end up saving you money because you won’t be consistently buying bags of popcorn at the store. It is a great purchase that you will get a lot of use out of and won’t regret for a second.
8. Colonel Popper
Sometimes less is more and if you’re looking for a no-fuss, easy to use, won’t break down on you popcorn maker look no further. This unit is simply a bowl, similar to others we’ve talked about thus far, that is made of silicone and collapsible. It’ll give you that air-popped popcorn taste that you love with none of the hassle and all of the speed and convenience of microwave popcorn.
Use Any Kernels
Do you like your kernels organic? Amish? Maybe with all the butter movie theater-style? This popcorn maker is perfect for you then. It is compatible with any kernels and with a little variation on cook times and seasonings, you can make the popcorn that you love.
Smart Grab Handles
Microwaving popcorn is great for speed and even taste. One thing it isn’t great for though is pulling the bowl out of the microwave once it’s done. Most of the time handles are hot, the bowl itself is hot, and you find yourself either burning your fingers, your countertop, or looking for a couple of hotpads. The smart grab handles featured here will allow you to grab it right out of the microwave as soon as it is cooked without burning anything.
Cost and Value
This is one of the least expensive popcorn poppers you can find. It is simple and effective to use and your wallet will appreciate the small dent that it makes. If you love popcorn but want to ditch buying expensive kinds, buy the kernels and make your own here!
9. Cuisinart CPM-100MR
If you live in a dorm or you live alone, or you just want to make enough popcorn for yourself this is the perfect option for you. This small popcorn maker had to be a part of our selection because sometimes convenience is the perfect addition to any guide. When you first might look at this popcorn maker you might come to terms that it is a smaller size than most of our favorites; however, don’t be fooled by the size this small yet powerful popcorn maker gets the job done with a powerful 1500 watts that can make up to 10 cups of popcorn in 3 minutes. Therefore, not only do you have the option of using it as a single serving, but you can also make a bunch for friends and family.
Those who make popcorn regularly know most popcorn is made with lots of oil or butter yet there are healthier options like this one. This particular popcorn maker makes your popcorn with air. What this means is you do not need oil or butter to make your kernels turn into popcorn instead the air compression makes them pop. By removing the need for oil, your popcorn instantly becomes healthier and a better snacking choice.
Why be conformed to your kitchen when you can essentially make popcorn anywhere you would like. This popcorn maker can be transported anywhere it is lightweight and small enough to allow you to take it with you. Additionally, it comes with a long cord to avoid the hassle of having to find where to plug your new machine.
Cost and Value
The price on this unit is right in the middle, but when you take into consideration that it is smaller than most, the price might seem a bit on the higher end. Keep in mind you are getting a good product that offers a healthier way to pop your popcorn.
10. Great Northern Countertop
This unit combines everything you love about a fancy movie theater popcorn maker with the convenience of those you fit in your home. This is a countertop model that can hold up to 2.5 ounces of kernels, features a light warmer, a pullout popcorn tray, and hanging popcorn tray. It even comes with a measuring cup and spoon for serving.
Pull Out Popcorn Tray
The tray that the popcorn falls into once popped is easily pulled out. This makes it possible to use for serving or transporting without having to do so in small batches. It is also super convenient because the tray itself is dishwasher safe which will eliminate a dish and make clean up a snap.
Sometimes it’s all about the look. This is especially true in popcorn makers. If you are going to buy a big, visible one, it may as well be one that looks neat and catches your attention. This one has a cool retro look to it, but is a smaller version and doesn’t take up all of your space like others of the similar design do. Odds are good too that the 1 gallon of popcorn this will produce at a time will be more than enough for your family to enjoy.
Cost and Value
This is the second most expensive unit on our list. Logically, it falls there because it is a step above in both quantity of popcorn produced and styling than the standard stovetop or microwave versions. But, it is smaller and takes up less space than the most expensive. That being said, this unit comes at a great price for what you’re getting and you’ll be more than happy you spent the money.