Best Pizza Pans Reviewed & Rated for Quality

In a Hurry? Editors choice:
Lodge
Test Winner: Lodge
Amazon Link
Who doesn’t love pizza? Whether you’re a fan of a deep-dish pizza with tons of cheese or a pan pizza with all the toppings, you know pizza isn’t the same without a great crust. With the prices of delivery fees rising, calling up your favorite pizza place and ordering a pie to go isn’t the easiest option for people nowadays. To save money, many people find themselves taking on the mission of crafting the perfect pizza at home.

However, choosing the best option to complete your kitchen isn’t as easy as everyone may think. It takes time, a bit of effort, and of course, some research to find the product that is best suited for you and your kitchen. If you are ready to discover the world of pizza pans, read on below to discover which pizza pans made the cut!

Standout Picks

Lodge
The Lodge pre-seasoned 14-inch round baking pan is the first on our list. This piece of seasoned cookware is quite versatile. With its excellent heat retention and ability to heat quickly, this pan is both sturdy and great in size. Able to withstand up to 400 degrees of heat without losing the seasoning, this pan is great for cooking pizza and other goodies when needed.
Amazon Link
$60.00
Pro Bake
The Pro Bake Teflon non-stick 12-inch pizza pan is the next on our list. This piece of cookware is coated with Teflon Platinum High-Performance non-stick coating on both the inside and outside of the pan which allows for easy cleanup. The professional weight steel construction provides even dispersal of heat, allowing for great crust each time.
Amazon Link
$14.99
Cuisinart
The Cuisinart AMB-14PP Chef’s Classic nonstick bakeware 14 Inch pizza pan offers pizza lovers everything they want in cookware. This heavy-gauge aluminized steel pan offers even heat distribution and even baking, resulting in perfectly baked pizzas or other dishes. This nonstick pan is also dishwasher safe offering up easy clean up after your dinner is done.
Amazon Link
$14.95
T-Fal
The T-Fal nonstick pizza pan is any pizza lover’s dream. This piece of cookware offers even browning of crusts and thorough baking throughout. It uses dual sheets of aluminum to provide perfect baking without the worry of overheating. At 12.75 inches, the perforated surface releases moisture allowing for perfect pizza each time.
Amazon Link
Baker’s Secret
The Baker’s Secret Signature 14-inch pizza pan offers advanced non-stick coating to help prevent pizza’s from sticking to the surface and for easy release. With large contour handles a lifetime warranty, and is safe for use with metal spatulas this piece of cookware will make any pizza lover’s night a great one.
Amazon Link
Chicago Metallic
This option offers those who prefer deep dish pizza the perfect piece of cookware to make their own masterpiece at home. Made from carbon steel this piece is both durable and strong. The silicon-based surface is treated with a non-stick coating for easy release of your pizza and clean up that is a breeze.
Amazon Link
$17.49
LloydPans Kitchenware
We wanted to make sure we bring you a large variety of high-quality pizza pans so that you can find which one will work best for you and your favorite style of pizza. Therefore, we covered traditional pizza pans, deep-dish pizza pans, and now we have a Detroit style pizza pan. A Detroit pizza is a deep-dish square pizza served with all your favorite toppings. This pizza pan was designed to bring you the Detroit pizza experience right to your home. Measuring at 10 inches in length, 14 inches in width, and 2.5 inches in depth this pan was typically used by commercial pizzerias, and now it will be in your hands as well.
Amazon Link
$37.60
New Star Foodservice
The New Star Foodservice coupe style pizza tray offers customers everything they could want in a pizza pan. Made from commercial grade aluminum there is no coating to flake off allowing for easy clean up when you are finished using it. With gently sloped edges, and a convenience all its own, this piece of cookware is great for anyone hoping for a family pizza night.
Amazon Link
$5.97
USA Pan
The USA Pan bakeware aluminized steel pizza pan is the next up on our list. Made in the US from commercial grade and heavy gauge materials this pan offers a unique corrugated surface design for even baking and easy release of food. Coated with Americoat, a patented nonstick material, to ensure your pan doesn’t stick and your food looks great.
Amazon Link
$21.99
Maxi Nature Kitchenware
Why purchase one pan when you can get two for the price of one! This pan set allows you to do just that. Featuring a multi-hole design for even heat distribution these pizza pans were created to give you succulent, crispy pizza crust time and time again. Paired with high-quality steel construction to give you a long-lasting product that can be used indoor or even on the grill. Plus let's not forget it does come with two so you can make two personal 13-inch pizzas for you and a guest at the same time, saving time and money.
Amazon Link
$19.99

Criteria Used for Evaluation

Size

When choosing an addition to your kitchen cookware, size is always something you should consider. This is especially important when it comes to deciding which pizza tray is best suited for your use around the kitchen. If you are a fan of larger sized pizzas that will feed a large family, you want to invest in a tray that gives you this ability. Larger pans are great for get-togethers and large family gatherings. Smaller trays are great for families who have picky eaters who like different toppings or other types of dishes others aren’t as fond of. These types of pans allow you to make separate dishes while still being able to cook meals at one time. Keep in mind, however, your tray must fit in your oven. Some homes have more compact cooking ovens. This means when choosing the one best suited for your home, you should ensure the sizing is compatible with your oven.

Durability

Durability is one of the most important aspects to look for when choosing a pizza tray for your home. A pan that can stand up to the heat of your oven while still retaining its shape and the non-stick coating is key when making your online purchase. This is why its key to choosing a tray that is made of strong materials that have the ability to evenly heat whatever you decide to cook on it. This ensures that not only is your food evenly cooked and tasting great, but your pan is able to stand up to the heat you and your family are bound to put it through.

Versatility

Versatility is important for any piece of cookware you add to your kitchen. Although they are mostly used for cooking great tasting pizzas, certain pans have the ability to be used for much more. Some people like using theirs for biscuits or other types of bread due to the even cooking that is provided. The heat distribution of pizza trays allows for even cooking, which is great for a wide array of other dishes. If you are a fan of cookware in your kitchen that can be used for several dishes, then choosing one of the more versatile trays in this top 10 list may be the best option for your kitchen.

10 Best Pizza Pans 

1. Lodge

Where to buy
Amazon Link
$60.00
Lodge
Amazon Link

The Lodge pre-seasoned 14-inch round baking pan is the first on our list. This piece of seasoned cookware is quite versatile. With its excellent heat retention and ability to heat quickly, this pan is both sturdy and great in size. Able to withstand up to 400 degrees of heat without losing the seasoning, this pan is great for cooking pizza and other goodies when needed.

Loop Handles

This baking pan comes with loop handles that offer easy maneuvering. No matter what you are cooking with your pan, easy removal is a key aspect to great food.

Cast Iron

This piece of cookware is solid cast iron which means it will last for years to come. Seasoned cast iron is great at retaining flavor, as well as heat, and will give you a perfect crust with every pizza.

Cost and Value

This baking pan is a great value for the price. Competing closely with less sturdy aluminum pans in cost, this cookware offers superior quality and flavor. If you are a lover of pizza, paying the price for this pan will allow you to enjoy many nights of great tasting food for years to come.

Amazon Link
$60.00

2. Pro Bake

Where to buy
Amazon Link
$14.99
Pro Bake
Amazon Link

The Pro Bake Teflon non-stick 12-inch pizza pan is the next on our list. This piece of cookware is coated with Teflon Platinum High-Performance non-stick coating on both the inside and outside of the pan which allows for easy cleanup. The professional weight steel construction provides even dispersal of heat, allowing for great crust each time.

Teflon Coated

Teflon Platinum High-Performance non-stick coating allows your pizza to simply slide off the pan. This addition gives you the ease of cleaning up quickly which means more time to enjoy your great tasting pizza with family and friends.

Dishwasher Safe

This pan can be cleaned in the dishwasher unlike some other types of cookware. Once the food is ready and clean up is over, simply load the Pro Bake into the dishwasher, then dry and put away for use on your next pizza night.

Cost and Value

The Pro Bake baking pan is an incredible value for the small price you’ll pay. Priced competitively against any other cookware for making pizza, this pan’s non-stick additions and sturdy construction make it a great addition to any kitchen.

Amazon Link
$14.99

3. Cuisinart

Where to buy
Amazon Link
$14.95
Cuisinart
Amazon Link

The Cuisinart AMB-14PP Chef’s Classic nonstick bakeware 14 Inch pizza pan offers pizza lovers everything they want in cookware. This heavy-gauge aluminized steel pan offers even heat distribution and even baking, resulting in perfectly baked pizzas or other dishes. This nonstick pan is also dishwasher safe offering up easy clean up after your dinner is done.

Cuisinart

The Cuisinart AMB-14PP Chef’s Classic nonstick bakeware 14 Inch pizza pan offers pizza lovers everything they want in cookware. This heavy-gauge aluminized steel pan offers even heat distribution and even baking, resulting in perfectly baked pizzas or other dishes. This nonstick pan is also dishwasher safe offering up easy clean up after your dinner is done.

Even Heat Distribution

The even heat distribution offered from this aluminized steel pan means more consistent baking. This ensures your pizza’s crust is cooked thoroughly instead of being doughy in the middle.

Cost and Value

This inexpensive piece of cookware offers buyers everything they want in a pizza pan. The nonstick surface, sturdy design, and perfect size team up to make this a great pan for the price.

Amazon Link
$14.95

4. T-Fal

Where to buy
Amazon Link
T-Fal
Amazon Link

The T-Fal nonstick pizza pan is any pizza lover’s dream. This piece of cookware offers even browning of crusts and thorough baking throughout. It uses dual sheets of aluminum to provide perfect baking without the worry of overheating. At 12.75 inches, the perforated surface releases moisture allowing for perfect pizza each time.

No Rust

This heavy-duty aluminum pan doesn’t rust thanks to its dual sheet aluminum design. With even cooking, proper heat distribution, and its unique design this pan will last for ages without rusting issues.

Dual Sheet Design

Made from two sheets of aluminum this nonstick pan is designed to make perfect pizza every time. The bottom sheet protects from the heat of your over, while the layer of air acts as an insulator ensuring the top sheet of aluminum doesn’t get overheated and your pizza doesn’t burn.

Cost and Value

With its unique dual sheet design, this nonstick pan is a great value. This low-cost pan will be a great addition to any kitchen. You will love the foods you prepare while remaining pleased at the amount of money you’ve saved versus the price of calling for delivery.

Amazon Link

5. Baker’s Secret

Where to buy
Amazon Link
Baker’s Secret
Amazon Link

The Baker’s Secret Signature 14-inch pizza pan offers advanced non-stick coating to help prevent pizza’s from sticking to the surface and for easy release. With large contour handles a lifetime warranty, and is safe for use with metal spatulas this piece of cookware will make any pizza lover’s night a great one.

Metal Spatula Safe

The advanced nonstick coating used on this piece of cookware provides a tough coating that not only helps keep your pizza from sticking but also makes your pan safe to use with both plastic and metal spatulas.

Lifetime Warranty

Baker’s Secret stands by their pan so much, they offer a lifetime warranty. If this pan doesn’t live up to what you are expecting or is damaged, you’ll have the opportunity to receive a replacement.

Cost and Value

At the reasonably low-cost of this pan, it’s a great bargain. At two inches deep, this piece of cookware can easily make great tasting pizza while offering great bonuses you’ll love.

Amazon Link

6. Chicago Metallic

Where to buy
Amazon Link
$17.49
Chicago Metallic
Amazon Link

This option offers those who prefer deep dish pizza the perfect piece of cookware to make their own masterpiece at home. Made from carbon steel this piece is both durable and strong. The silicon-based surface is treated with a non-stick coating for easy release of your pizza and clean up that is a breeze.

Deep Dish

The deeper sides of this pan offer those who love deep dish pizza exactly what they want. Take the time to toss on the toppings you love, and you’ll find yourself digging into a great pizza in no time.

Durable and Strong

This piece of cookware is constructed of carbon steel. This offers increased durability, allowing your pan to last for years. It also gives your deep dish the strength to stand up to cooking temps without damages.

Cost and Value

Lovers of deep dish pizza can’t deny the value of this pan. With the low cost, grabbing one online is a breeze and gives you the opportunity to enjoy your favorite pizza sooner than you imagined possible.

Amazon Link
$17.49

7. LloydPans Kitchenware

Where to buy
Amazon Link
$37.60
LloydPans Kitchenware
Amazon Link

We wanted to make sure we bring you a large variety of high-quality pizza pans so that you can find which one will work best for you and your favorite style of pizza. Therefore, we covered traditional pizza pans, deep-dish pizza pans, and now we have a Detroit style pizza pan. A Detroit pizza is a deep-dish square pizza served with all your favorite toppings. This pizza pan was designed to bring you the Detroit pizza experience right to your home. Measuring at 10 inches in length, 14 inches in width, and 2.5 inches in depth this pan was typically used by commercial pizzerias, and now it will be in your hands as well.

Pre-seasoned

While most pizza pans come with the need to be seasoned in order to prevent sticking this one comes already prepared for use. Its pre-seasoned to perfection so that you don’t have to go through the hassle of doing it yourself. Created out of heavy-duty anodized aluminum that has been paired with a DK finish; furthermore, the non-stick coating is PTFE free. Traditionally, darker pans do tend to make pizza crusts a bit darker, so you want to adjust the temperature or lower it a bit to ensure your crust is cooked to perfection.

Safe for High Heat

When you’re baking your own pizza at home, it is smart to know how much heat your pizza pan can withstand. This pizza pan can resistant up to 700 degrees Fahrenheit which means you can place your pizza pan inside of a brick oven and you will be just fine. Additionally, you can place it on the grill and have excellent pizza as well.

Cost and Value

The cost for this pizza is a bit on the mid-range of the spectrum. It's not quite expensive but it's not what you would consider as affordable, you are getting a well-constructed pizza pan that will last you a long time so that does make up for the price. Additionally, the pan is a deep size pizza pan that comes already pre-seasoned.

Amazon Link
$37.60

8. New Star Foodservice

Where to buy
Amazon Link
$5.97
New Star Foodservice
Amazon Link

The New Star Foodservice coupe style pizza tray offers customers everything they could want in a pizza pan. Made from commercial grade aluminum there is no coating to flake off allowing for easy clean up when you are finished using it. With gently sloped edges, and a convenience all its own, this piece of cookware is great for anyone hoping for a family pizza night.

Convenience

This commercial grade aluminum tray allows you to prepare, bake, slice, and serve all in one pan. The strength demonstrated will make your pizza nights the talk of the town.

Sloped Edges

The gently sloped edges allow those who prefer a pizza with lots of toppings everything they want and more. These edges mean you can pile on the toppings without worry.

Cost and Value

The surprisingly low cost of this pizza tray makes snatching one up a real steal. Whether you are planning on cooking your own homemade pizza or one you buy from the store, this pan will ensure a great tasting pizza each time without breaking the bank.

Amazon Link
$5.97

9. USA Pan

Where to buy
Amazon Link
$21.99
USA Pan
Amazon Link

The USA Pan bakeware aluminized steel pizza pan is the next up on our list. Made in the US from commercial grade and heavy gauge materials this pan offers a unique corrugated surface design for even baking and easy release of food. Coated with Americoat, a patented nonstick material, to ensure your pan doesn’t stick and your food looks great.

Corrugated Surface

The uniquely designed corrugated surface of the USA Pan bakeware allows for the facilitation of air circulation. This allows an evenly cooked crust, or other goods, that don’t burn but turn out looking and tasting amazing.

Americoat

The product is coated with Americoat, a non-stick silicone that is tested for safety. This coating ensures your pan won’t stick and that food releases easily when finished. Add in the ease of clean-up and you have a winning combination.

Cost and Value

The reasonable price of the USA Pan aluminized steel pizza pan makes it one of the best values on the market. The durability and unique design of this piece of cookware is well worth the money you will pay to add this piece to your own kitchen.

Amazon Link
$21.99

10. Maxi Nature Kitchenware

Where to buy
Amazon Link
$19.99
Maxi Nature Kitchenware
Amazon Link

Why purchase one pan when you can get two for the price of one! This pan set allows you to do just that. Featuring a multi-hole design for even heat distribution these pizza pans were created to give you succulent, crispy pizza crust time and time again. Paired with high-quality steel construction to give you a long-lasting product that can be used indoor or even on the grill. Plus let's not forget it does come with two so you can make two personal 13-inch pizzas for you and a guest at the same time, saving time and money.

Easy Clean Up

There’s nothing quite as obnoxious then after eating a good meal having to scrape and scratch a pan to remove food residue that has been stuck on. These pans prevent that from happening by having a non-stick coating that goes from the front of the pans to the back; therefore, you can simply wipe it down or throw it in the dishwasher as it is also dishwasher safe.

Scratch Resistant

As previously stated this man is made out of steel; therefore, it only makes sense that it is quite durable. Not only that but it’s also scratch-resistant. These pans were constructed to last you a very long time they are made out of quality material in order to become your new favorite item in the kitchen.

Cost and Value

Taking into consideration that you’re getting two pans for the price of one you are getting an excellent deal. They are long-lasting durable and have a 60day money back guarantee warranty to ensure if you’re dissatisfied you will be getting your money back. However, let's face it you won’t be returning these instead, you will come up with new recipes to try with your family and friends.

Amazon Link
$19.99

Sources

  1. Nordicware, FAQ,
  2. The Prepared Pantry, A Buyer’s Guide to Pizza Pans at the Prepared Pantry ,
  3. webstaurantstore, Types of Pizza Pans,